Journalism of Courage
Advertisement
Premium

Less pay, no work

Government salaries are pathetic. So it works pathetically. Sixth pay panel must remember this

.

Early in the cabinet-mandated year and a half the sixth pay commission has been given to submit its report, there has to be the firm recognition that the way to approach a government pay review is to figure how to make government work better. It should be clear to commission members, some of whom would have had private sector work experience, that the government cannot be made to work better at the current abysmal levels of compensation. A junior corporate executive will probably choose unemployment over what the government pays a middle-level official. Private sector top management probably put more in their PF accounts every month than what the government pays its departmental secretaries, PSU and public sector bank chiefs and institute heads. At the low end, the picture is in some ways worse. The police constable on the street and the army jawan on the border are paid less than office peons in the private sector. Even if one monetises perks, government pay is way too little compared to private sector salaries.

This is silly when economic reform and incentives are the broad official credos. Badly paid government officers may well have a jaundiced view of market rewards. Pay is also why the government is no longer even the second or the third career option for the very bright. Of course, government pay and private sector salaries will always differ. But the difference can8217;t be at levels that make government jobs a refuge for those doling out and seeking mass patronage.

Put another way, if serious efforts can be made to reform government pension, why can8217;t pay be subjected to radical, market-linked change? Indeed, the chance that pension reform will be implemented is, as our columnist explains, one reason why the sixth pay commission awards seem less fiscally daunting to the government. Incidentally, will political parties who back government unions on pay rise and oppose pension reform, please see the contradiction in their stand? Many will see a contradiction in our advocacy for substantially higher government pay and lifetime job security. Private sector hire and fire isn8217;t possible in government. But definitely, midterm, performance-determined pink slips should be handed out. Pay should be structured to reflect performance incentives. And political hiring at lower levels must totally stop. Government jobs need not and should not feel like sarkari handouts.

Curated For You

 

Tags:
Edition
Install the Express App for
a better experience
Featured
Trending Topics
News
Multimedia
Follow Us
Neerja Chowdhury writesMGNREGA to G Ram G: How a new flashpoint may shape BJP vs Gandhi family conflict in 2026
X