Journalism of Courage
Advertisement
Premium

Case for change

Lalu the minister wanted a makeover. Will court acquittal mean Lalu the politician won8217;t want one?

.

One way of assessing the political significance of Lalu Prasad Yadav8217;s acquittal by a CBI court in Patna in a long-running disproportionate assets case is to ask: what if he had been convicted? The union railway minister would have had to most probably resign. The UPA, under some renewed pressure on the 8220;tainted ministers8217;8217; issue because of Shibu Soren8217;s recent conviction and resignation, would have had to perform far more demanding firefighting. More, the Congress would have been terribly hard put to fill up a Lalu-sized hole in the ruling coalition. Lalu may not be Bihar8217;s chief minister any more but he is still the most charismatic mass politician of the Hindi heartland from the doggedly anti-BJP camp; he has proved himself a generally loyal ally to the Congress. On the other side of the political divide, a conviction of Lalu would have roused a sagging BJP8217;s morale, giving it an issue it could ride with far more authority and at far less risk to itself than the ones it is attempting to mount currently 8212; be it the Indo-US nuclear deal

or the prime minister8217;s 8220;appeasement8221; of minorities.

To be sure, the case that led up to the acquittal in the Patna court has always been seen to bear a significance far more political than legal. But if that be the case, here is another question: what happens now? Does the acquittal of Lalu in this particular case mean that the 8220;tainted ministers8221; issue has gone away from the UPA for the foreseeable future? Does it mean, also, that Lalu Yadav himself can work up this legal victory in one case in Patna into a more elaborate political justification? In recent times, especially after his unseating in Patna, Lalu had visibly embarked upon a re-invention. From the chief minister who presided over a raging de-institutionalisation in his state, he had become the railway minister who was seen to propel the organisation in a more forward-looking, more entrepreneurial direction.

What, if anything, does the legal triumph in Patna bode in terms of the possibility that Lalu Yadav, administrator, would eventually re-make Lalu Yadav, politician? While Lalu Yadav has every reason to celebrate the verdict in Patna, it would be unfortunate indeed if one of India8217;s most exciting political personalities were to read a political alibi into the legal verdict.

Curated For You

 

Tags:
Edition
Install the Express App for
a better experience
Featured
Trending Topics
News
Multimedia
Follow Us
Express PremiumIn Kerala, a mob and its many faces
X