Premium
This is an archive article published on July 14, 2006

Ahead of N-vote, Burns, Saran meet in Paris

Just days before the Indo-US Civil Nuclear Cooperation Bill comes up for vote on the floor of both chambers of the US Congress...

.

Just days before the Indo-US Civil Nuclear Cooperation Bill comes up for vote on the floor of both chambers of the US Congress, principal interlocutors from both sides Foreign Secretary Shyam Saran and US Under Secretary for Political Affairs Nicholas Burns met in Paris today.

The two officials discussed the next steps in the process given that versions of the Bill in the Senate and the House of Representatives are different in some respects. The reconciliation of both versions is an important aspect of the entire process.

The Bush Administration is in touch with the Congress to ensure that some of the difficult elements in the Bill are modified or dropped in the final versions. Burns is said to have briefed Saran on the efforts being made by the administration on these issues.

Story continues below this ad

India had pointed out to the US that it was not comfortable with some elements in both versions of the Bill, which have been passed by a healthy majority of the relevant committees in both chambers of the Congress.

In the Senate version, this relates to not giving India reprocessing technology. While this may not be an immediate concern, New Delhi would prefer not to have it as part of the law in the long run.

Then, there is the issue of the Bill stating that US will stop civil nuclear cooperation in case India violates NSG (Nuclear Suppliers Group) and MTCR (Missile Technology Control Regime) guidelines. While India is committed to adhere to these guidelines, the problem is that there are several minor violations which happen when companies do trade and that should not lead to termination of all cooperation.

Even NSG has graded responses for different kinds of violations. To insert such a condition in a law, sources say, may prove detrimental and needs further clarification.

Story continues below this ad

Besides this, Saran and Burns also discussed the sequencing of the remaining steps including the signing of a safeguards agreements with the International Atomic Energy Agency. For India, this has always been the last step in the process, but Bill in the House of Representatives places it as a pre-condition.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement