Journalism of Courage
Advertisement
Premium

A session washed away

An extended weekend is clearly not long enough to make our MPs yearn for the rigour of parliamentary debate. Instead, when they convened on ...

.

An extended weekend is clearly not long enough to make our MPs yearn for the rigour of parliamentary debate. Instead, when they convened on Wednesday morning, they preferred to limit their duels to an obstinate standoff, punctuating the day with repeated adjournments and walkouts. The issue at hand has already produced much noise and little progress in recent weeks. The Opposition remains insistent that the government furnish details of the CVC8217;s report on defence purchases to the public accounts committee inquiring into Operation Vijay. Nothing doing, the government counters, the withheld portions have nothing to do with the 1999 Kargil war. For days on end, both sides have been repeating their positions with all the emphasis they can muster; but beyond that, they appear to be unwilling to explore a way out, to locate a meeting ground to depolarise proceedings and move on to other business before the two Houses.

Is the rest of the monsoon session of Parliament then destined to be washed away? To be sure, the session was always expected to be politically charged. With assembly elections round the corner and with the Congress and BJP upping the stakes by moving into campaign gear, only the compulsively optimistic could have expected anything resembling bipartisanship. Still, this session appears to be spiralling out of control. It is not the din that depresses. Besides legislating, parliamentarians have a duty to represent the concerns of their constituents in particular and the people of India in general as well as to scrutinise the affairs of the executive.

To that end, raising a ruckus over issues of national import 8212; and defence is certainly one of them 8212; is legitimate. It is the seeming refusal of the ruling dispensation and the Opposition to engage on substantive issues that is worrisome. If the government cannot take the PAC into confidence on the CVC report, surely it should at least strive to explain why, to provide a more convincing answer than pithy one-liners about the report not detailing Kargil purchases. Equally, the Opposition has to find a way to balance its political boycott of Defence Minister George Fernandes and its duty to debate as crucial a sector as defence. By refusing to grill him, the Opposition fails in its responsibility to scrutinise the functioning of the government.

Curated For You

 

Tags:
Weather
Edition
Install the Express App for
a better experience
Featured
Trending Topics
News
Multimedia
Follow Us
Express ExplainedWhat America's Greenland claim could mean for NATO, Russia, and Canada
X