Premium
This is an archive article published on May 9, 2016

How journalsists who got ads from MP govt responded: ‘No more ads’, ‘genuine site’, and no comments

The Indian Express spoke to journalists who got ads. Here is how they responded.

 indian express investigation, journalist websites, Hari Dayal Pateria, Suman Tripathi, Pawan Devalia, Shabddeep Samiti, www, web sites, madhya pradesh based web site, state governmnet, www.mpmirror.com, www.bigbreaking.com, www.newsroom24x7.com http://www.ekhabartoday.com website

Several web sites based in Madhya Pradesh linked to current or former journalists got advertisements worth over Rs 7 lakh or more from the state government during the period 2012-15, an investigation by The Indian Express found. Examples:

1 http://www.news1st.org (Rs 18.70 lakh) — Hari Dayal Pateria, related to local journalist Prabhu Pateria, who works with Bhopal news channel Swaraj Express.

2 http://www.no2politics.com (Rs 18.25 lakh) — Archna, another relative of Prabhu Pateria. No ‘About Us’ or ‘Contact’ links. Prabhu did not respond to queries sent by The Indian Express.

Story continues below this ad

3 http://www.madhyabharat.net (Rs 17.25 lakh) — Shafali Gupta, a journalist who formerly worked with a news channel. She had earlier worked for http://www.dakhal.net, run as http://www.kolarnews.net (Rs. 10.75 lakh) — both carry similar content. http://www.madhyabharat.net and http://www.kolarnews.net have no ‘About Us’ or ‘Contact Us’ links.

“I own madhyabharat.net. I had also started kolarnews.net but sold it. I still write articles for all three web sites,” Gupta said.

4 http://www.kharikhari.net (Rs 16 lakh) — Suman Tripathi, a journalist working in Bhopal with Hindi weekly L N Star, and wife of Ajay Tripathi, who works for a local TV channel IBC 24. “We have no staff, we run it ourselves,” said Ajay Tripathi.

5 http://www.nvmp.in (Rs 15.99 lakh) — Tarun Gupta of N V News and Views. Gupta said he earlier worked for local channel Bansal News, and currently does some work for Doordarshan. “I have not yet received any government money for this web site,” Gupta said.

Story continues below this ad

6 http://www.newsaaj.in (Rs 15.6 lakh) — Arun Kumar Bhandari, a former journalist. ‘Contact Us’ page is blank. “We are a group of retired journalists. Our purpose is not to earn money,” Bhandari said.

7 http://www.bhartiyam.in (Rs 15.5 lakh) — Vijay Kumar Tewari, retired journalist. ‘Contact Us’ and ‘About Us’ are blank. Links only under Culture, Religion, Tantra, etc. “The government has stopped advertisements from January. They had a discretionary basis but have revised it,” Tewari said.

8 (Rs. 14.45 lakh) — Husna Raja, related to Aman Shawar, who runs a Hindi daily in Bhopal. Shawar did not respond to requests for a comment.

9 http://www.mpmirror.com (Rs 11.3 lakh) — Pawan Devalia, “sanchalak/editor”. News posts carry no dates. Devalia said he had sold the web site.

Story continues below this ad

10 http://www.metromirror.com (Rs 11 lakh) — Brain Power Media India Pvt Ltd, involved in media consultancy, publishing and advertising. “I have been running this web site for the last 15 years, and we are still getting advertisements,” said Shiv Harsh Suhalkha, the editor.

11 http://www.madhyamat.com (Rs 10.8 lakh) – Relatives of Gireesh Upadhyay, a freelance journalist who worked with the Hindi daily Nai Dunia. ‘About Us’ and ‘Contact Us’ lead to blank pages. “I have been running it for four years. Now, we do not get government advertisements regularly,” said Upadhyay.

12 http://www.shabddeep.com (Rs 9 lakh) — Shabddeep Samiti, Bhopal. The samiti is run by journalist Atul Purohit, Bhopal bureau chief of Hindi daily Dainik Chhattisgarh. “Shabddeep Samiti has been running the web site from 2009. It’s a genuine web site,” said Purohit.

13 http://www.bigbreaking.com (Rs 8.75 lakh) — Raja Sharma, who works with CNBC. Sharma said, “The web site is being run from Indore since 2008. The government has stopped giving advertisements.”

Story continues below this ad

14 http://www.newsroom24x7.com (Rs 8.65 lakh) — Lalit Shashtri, a retired journalist. “I have been running the site for the last four years and have employed staff. It is a news web site and I don’t do PR for the government,” he said.

15 http://www.mpbusinessline.com (Rs 8.50 lakh) — Suhir Singh, a former journalist. “I started the web site four years ago because there was a need for a business web site. I am still getting advertisements,” Singh said.

16 http://www.sabkikhabar.com (Rs 8.50 lakh) — Ravindra Jain, who works with the local Hindi daily Agniban. “I started this web site when I was unemployed, and got some advertisements. I shut it down after getting employment,” said Jain.

17 http://www.ekhabartoday.com (Rs 8.45 lakh) — Tushar Kothari of Ratlam who works for the Univarta Hindi news agency. “My web site is a substitute for news agencies in this region. I get advertisements sometimes,” said Kothari.

Story continues below this ad

18 http://www.newzviews.com (Rs 8.25 lakh) — Pramod Bhardwaj, editor of Hindi daily Haribhoomi in Bhopal. “My wife has been running the web site for five years. “We do not get government advertisements regularly,” said Bhardwaj.

19 http://www.thebhopalpost.com (Rs 8.25 lakh) — Rajkumar Keswani, a journalist known for his reports on the Bhopal gas tragedy. Most posts are related to the disaster. “My web site has been running from June 2010, and I got advertisements for only one year. After that, I did not submit any bills,” said Keswani.

20 (Rs 8 lakh) — Rashmi Pande, wife of Rishi Pande, a journalist who worked with Nai Dunia earlier. “I started it in 2012. Now I have no other work but for this web site,” said Rishi Pande.

21 http://www.khojkhabarnews.com (Rs. 7.85 lakh) — Ataullah Faizan, son of Muslim Saleem, a former journalist who is now with the PR Department of the state government. “I do not work for any other organisation,” said Faizan.

Story continues below this ad

22 (Rs 7.25 lakh) — Rajendra Dhanotia, who has worked with Bhopal-based Hindi dailies. Dhanotia confirmed that he ran the web site.

23 http://www.dailyhindinews.com (Rs 7.25 lakh) — Sanjay Kumar Kareer, who works with Hindi daily Patrika at Bengaluru. “The web site is being run from Sagar, where I use to go regularly. A group of journalists are behind it,” said Kareer.

24 (Rs 7 lakh) — Mukta Pathak, who works with local Hindi daily Dabang Dunia. “My web site is still working but I am not getting advertisements now,” said Pathak.

WATCH INDIAN EXPRESS VIDEOS HERE

Shyamlal Yadav is one of the pioneers of the effective use of RTI for investigative reporting. He is a member of the Investigative Team. His reporting on polluted rivers, foreign travel of public servants, MPs appointing relatives as assistants, fake journals, LIC’s lapsed policies, Honorary doctorates conferred to politicians and officials, Bank officials putting their own money into Jan Dhan accounts and more has made a huge impact. He is member of the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ). He has been part of global investigations like Paradise Papers, Fincen Files, Pandora Papers, Uber Files and Hidden Treasures. After his investigation in March 2023 the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York returned 16 antiquities to India. Besides investigative work, he keeps writing on social and political issues. ... Read More

Stay updated with the latest - Click here to follow us on Instagram

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Loading Taboola...
Advertisement