This is an archive article published on November 22, 2021
Report on Data Protection Bill: Congress MP Jairam Ramesh submits dissent note
Jairam Ramesh has objected to a clause in the Personal Data Protection Bill that allows the Centre to exempt any agency under its purview from the law.
Ramesh chairs the Standing Committee on Science & Technology, Environment & Forests.(Express File Photo by Pradip Das)
As the Joint Committee of Parliament meets Monday to adopt its report on the Personal Data Protection Bill, Congress Rajya Sabha member in the panel Jairam Ramesh has submitted a dissent note. His objection primarily is to a clause that allows the Centre to exempt any agency under its purview from the law.
In his note, which he posted on his Twitter handle, Ramesh said he had suggested amendments to Section 35 and Section 12 of the Bill. “The JCP gave me a patient hearing but I was unable to convince it of the merits of my arguments. The general consensus in the JCP appeared to be in favour of not accepting my amendments and I did not want to force the issue beyond a point,” he said in his note to Chairman of the Panel P P Chaudhuri.
Today, the Joint Parliamentary Committee on Personal Data Protection Bill 2019 will adopt its report. I’m compelled to submit a detailed dissent note. But that should not detract from the democratic manner in which the Committee has functioned. Now, for the debate in Parliament. pic.twitter.com/tavBnF9y5B
He said the design of the Bill assumes that the constitutional right to privacy arises only where operations and activities of private companies are concerned. “Government and government agencies are treated as a separate privileged class whose operations and activities are always in the public interest and individual privacy considerations are secondary,” he noted.
Ramesh said, “Section 35 gives unbridled powers to the central government to exempt any agency from the entire Act itself. Under the amendment, I had suggested that the central government will have to get Parliamentary approval for exempting any of its agencies from the purview of the law. Even then, the government must always comply with the Bill’s requirement of fair and reasonable processing and implementing the necessary security safeguards.”
“I was willing to compromise provided the JCP had recommended that the reasons for exemption that would be recorded in writing as provided for in the Bill would be tabled in both Houses of Parliament. This would bring greater accountability and transparency, but even that was not found acceptable,” he said.
He said Section 12 (a) (i) creates certain exceptions for governments and government agencies from the provisions of consent.
“While fully understanding the logic for such exemptions in a number of circumstances, I had suggested some changes to make this exemption less sweeping and less automatic. The JCPs report allows a period of two years for private companies to migrate to the new data protection regime but government and government agencies have no such stipulation,” Ramesh said in his note.
Manoj C G currently serves as the Chief of National Political Bureau at The Indian Express. A veteran journalist with a career spanning nearly two decades, he plays a pivotal role in shaping the publication's coverage of India's political landscape.
Experience & Career: Manoj has built a robust career in political journalism, marked by a transition from wire service reporting to in-depth newspaper analysis.
The Indian Express (2008 – Present): He joined the organization in 2008 and has risen to lead the National Political Bureau, overseeing key political coverage.
Press Trust of India (PTI): Prior to his tenure at The Indian Express, Manoj worked with India’s premier news agency, PTI, honing his skills in breaking news and accurate reporting.
Expertise & Focus Areas: As a seasoned political observer, Manoj focuses on the nuances of governance and party dynamics.
National Politics: extensive reporting on the central government, parliamentary affairs, and national elections.
Political Strategy: Deep analysis of party structures, coalition politics, and the shifting ideologies within the Indian political spectrum.
Bureau Leadership: directing a team of reporters to cover the most critical developments in the nation's capital.
Authoritativeness & Trust: Manoj’s authoritativeness is grounded in his nearly 20 years of field experience and his leadership role at a legacy newspaper. His long-standing association with The Indian Express underscores a reputation for consistency, editorial integrity, and rigorous reporting standards required of a Bureau Chief.
Find all stories by Manoj C G here. ... Read More
3 min read
