This is an archive article published on November 2, 2023
Shinde Sena says didn’t receive any whip from party in July 2022
On Monday, the Supreme Court had given a deadline of December 31 for adjudication of the disqualification pleas.
During the hearing, both the sides argued over whether the whip was issued to Shinde Sena MLAs.
While the Shinde camp claimed that no such whip was received by them, the Uddhav Thackeray-led Sena UBT clarified that the whip was issued by MLA Sunil Prabhu and sent on the official email ids of the MLAs which was on record in the party’s legislature office. (File)
Listen to this article
Shinde Sena says didn’t receive any whip from party in July 2022
x
00:00
1x1.5x1.8x
Maharashtra Assembly Speaker Rahul Narwekar held a hearing of disqualification pleas of Shiv Sena MLAs Thursday during which the Chief Minister Eknath Shinde-led Shiv Sena claimed that their MLAs did not receive any whip from the party over the election of a Speaker and vote of confidence in July 2022.
On Monday, the Supreme Court had given a deadline of December 31 for adjudication of the disqualification pleas.
During the hearing, both the sides argued over whether the whip was issued to Shinde Sena MLAs.
While the Shinde camp claimed that no such whip was received by them, the Uddhav Thackeray-led Sena UBT clarified that the whip was issued by MLA Sunil Prabhu and sent on the official email ids of the MLAs which was on record in the party’s legislature office.
“The Shinde faction’s lawyers, however, denied the Sena UBT’s claim saying that that the email on which the whip was sent was not theirs and that since they have not received any whip there is no question of violating it,” an official said.
Sena UBT Rajya Sabha MP Anil Desai said that the whip was issued via email on the official ids of the MLAs.
The Sena UBT has urged the tribunal to allow them to present evidence to prove that the whip were issued.
“The whips were issued on July 2 and also on July 4, 2022. While one whip was issued asking MLAs to vote for Rajan Salvi who was our candidate for the post of Speaker, the second one was to vote for the party in the vote of confidence. They (Shinde led group) have violated both these whips and they have incurred disqualification. There was an argument over this. The SC has also asked to submit a common compilation of admission and denial, so that was accepted,” Desai said.
Story continues below this ad
“The Speaker has said that he will take a decision on holding day to day hearings and has said that a decision will take before December 31. The Speaker also said that like here in Mumbai, hearings can also be taken in Nagpur,” Desai said.
After the arguments from both the sides, the hearing was adjourned and next hearing will take place on November 21.
The tribunal headed by Narwekar asked both the factions to submit “common convince compilation” documents and evidence by November 6 and 16 respectively.
After the SC instructions, Narwekar will now hold more hearings over the next few weeks instead of the earlier planned one hearing per week and even curtail the procedure to finish the proceedings on time.
The Sena UBT demanded an hearing on daily basis to meet the deadline and give decision before the SC order.
Narwekar, however, is yet to give the fresh timetable.
Vallabh Ozarkar is a Senior Correspondent with The Indian Express' Mumbai bureau, recognized as an authoritative and deeply knowledgeable voice on the politics, governance, and infrastructure of Maharashtra. With more than nine years of experience in major news organizations, his reporting delivers high standards of Expertise and Trustworthiness.
Expertise & Authority
Current Role: Senior Correspondent, The Indian Express, Mumbai bureau.
Geographical Specialization: Provides exclusive and detailed coverage of Maharashtra politics and governance, operating at the epicenter of the state's decision-making in Mumbai.
Core Authority: His reporting demonstrates deep Expertise across critical and often complex state matters, including:
Political Dynamics: In-depth analysis of the ruling coalition (Mahayuti) and opposition (MVA), internal party conflicts, and crucial election updates, including local body polls and municipal corporation tussles.
Governance & Policy: Focused coverage on significant state policies, such as the overhaul of Mumbai's 'pagdi system' (rent control for old buildings) and social welfare schemes (e.g., Ladki Bahin Yojana accountability).
Infrastructure & Development: Reports on major urban and regional infrastructure projects, including the Mumbai Water Metro, Uttan-Virar Sea Link, and Thane Metro development.
Administrative Oversight: Follows legislative actions, cabinet decisions, and reports on issues of accountability and alleged fraud within state departments.
Experience
Current Role: His role at The Indian Express—a leading national daily—validates the credibility and standard of his reporting.
Career Foundation: Prior to The Indian Express, Vallabh contributed to other major metropolitan news outlets, including the Mumbai Mirror and DNA - Daily News & Analysis, providing a solid foundation in rigorous urban and political journalism.
Evidence of Impact: His work consistently breaks down complex political developments and administrative failures, such as exposing discrepancies in government welfare schemes, cementing his reputation as a trusted source for ground-level, impactful news from Maharashtra.
He tweets @Ozarkarvallabh ... Read More
3 min read
