Premium
This is an archive article published on May 23, 2004

Where146;s the Magic? Or the Realism?

This debut novel set in 1920s India comes highly recommended 8212; 8220;cut with a dash of magical realism8221;; 8220;a magical piece of...

.

This debut novel set in 1920s India comes highly recommended 8212; 8220;cut with a dash of magical realism8221;; 8220;a magical piece of storytelling8221; 8212; but, sigh, that doesn8217;t quite impart magic to the realism of The Last Song of Dusk. One of the best practitioners of the craft once said, 8220;There8217;s not a single line in my books which is not based on reality.8221; That8217;s where LSD slips: the characters, some swathed in unimaginable beauty, others in acute melancholy, are improbable, leading glitzy, unreal P3 lives.

The premise is rich 8212; a story of love and loss and the essential loneliness of being 8212; but it doesn8217;t quite live up to its promise, the lyrical snatches of prose notwithstanding.

We meet Anuradha Patwardhan as she8217;s leaving Udaipur for Bombay robed in a cobalt-blue sari with a gold leaf border to marry a man she has not met in the 21 years of her existence. And her mother, in a true Bollywood-like gesture, clutches Anuradha8217;s lovely hand and whispers: 8220;In this life, my darling, there is no mercy.8221;

Anuradha will discover the small mercies of life 8212; a saving grace 8212; but first the story. Anuradha who has a gift of Song, and loves to read from the pages of Sarat Chandra Devdas, falls in love with doctor Vardhmaan Gandharva who has a gift of storytelling. And together they set about having a beautiful, albeit stylized, life in a beautiful home 8212; waltzing to Schumann 8212; but for a scary window and a scarier mother-in-law who doesn8217;t have eyelashes but has a maniacal parrot spouting her ugly thoughts.

The Vardhmaans soon give birth to a 8220;ridiculously lovely8221; son, Mohan, who also has a gift for Song and a love for the violin but who is lost in one tragic sweep. Much like our movies, happy moments are set up only to be upstaged by unendurable sad ones.

They will have another son, the silent one, Shloka, whom they will have to give up so that he may live. By then they would have moved to the house by the sea which a melodramatic flashback tells us is where an Englishman died waiting for his Indian Maharaja. Like ma-in-law Divi-bai, Dariya Mahal is malign, casting an ugly eye on the Vardhmaans, tripping up anyone who dares to scent happiness.

Poor Anuradha. 8220;Seductress to the Gods8221; whose hair is 8220;a poem in itself8221;, whose presence is like a 8220;hymn wrapped in a sari8221;, she struggles through the novel to live up to such lavish metaphorical praise.

Story continues below this ad

Though the novel is set in Bombay in colonial times, the city seems to live in the times of Bollywood. With artists and film stars, models and celebrities 8212; the well-heeled vodkarati, as the writer tells us 8212; the Page 3 people as we know them. There8217;s no colonial fervour despite the fact that 8220;bald and beautiful8221; Gandhi does put in an appearance. The Englishmen too seem more taken up with India8217;s exotica. Two fall in love with painter, Muse and body beautiful Nandini, who deserts both on her way to Paris.

Shanghvi8217;s prose is enchanting in parts 8212; 8220;He the baby came on the wings of a song8221;. And extravagant 8212; 8220;the street slang of life was one word alone: irony8221;. And erotic, laden as it is with descriptions of love-making. But it8217;s not enough. So, though Anuradha will be overwhelmed by the small mercies of life, her songs, for example, you won8217;t be too sad to find Shloka, with a genius for melancholy, driving away into the 8220;kind, kind mist8221;.

 

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement