Premium
This is an archive article published on June 13, 2004

The Wright Stuff?

WITH the axe hanging over his head, Stephen Constantine needs some time off to write a long letter. A letter that John Wright had written al...

.

WITH the axe hanging over his head, Stephen Constantine needs some time off to write a long letter. A letter that John Wright had written almost three years ago when faced with a similar crisis on the cricket field. That letter to BCCI chief Jagmohan Dalmiya didn8217;t just save his job, it changed the face of Indian cricket.

Comparing the two sports in the Indian context would be totally out of place but Constantine is today more or less in the same boat as was Wright. But for the football coach the tide is harsher. For Wright, a functional cricket setup was in place: what was missing was the professional touch. In Indian football, it8217;s tough to say what8217;s missing, tough to know where to start.

And certainly tough to say how much of the fault lies with Constantine, if indeed any at all.

If Constantine needed help, it8217;s come from no less an institution than the Asian Football Confederation, which earlier this month released its Vision India report. It dealt in pretty blunt terms about a lack of vision and called for drastic changes in the way Indian football is run:

8216;8216;The transition to professional football was unplanned and has not been successful. There is no development plan and change does not seem to be on the agenda8217;8217;

8216;8216;In some states, football development is a priority, but lack of resources and a planned approach have hindered success. In other states there is no focus on development and no resources available.8217;8217;

One example from last week8217;s match against Japan offers enough illustration. While the top football teams travel with a support staff of about 20, the Indian coach had the bare minimum assistance. Keeping him company on the bench were an assistant coach, a goalkeeping coach, a doctor and a physio. And the only one with a permanent job was Constantine himself.

Story continues below this ad

It8217;s an ad-hocism that needs to change, admits AIFF secretary Alberto Colaco. 8216;8216;Not just the support staff, even the coaches of the junior teams, which provide Constantine vital inputs on the talent available, are also not permanent. Our coach has pointed this to me and I agree it needs to be changed,8217;8217; he told The Sunday Express.

Colaco was ready with Constantine8217;s Pressing Problem No.2: a 8216;8216;hectic domestic calendar8217;8217;. While Indian cricketers are blamed for neglecting the domestic game it is exactly the opposite in football. At times 8216;India games8217; suffer because of club commitments. When India played Oman in the World Cup qualifier early this year the East Bengal players in the squad had their minds elsewhere. Ten days before and after the game they were to represent their club in the AFC Clubs8217; Cup.

Constantine would have preferred them fresh and so would the AIFF but it was, says Colaco, a Catch-22 situation. 8216;8216;If we had withdrawn the top players from East Bengal they wouldn8217;t have sent a team for the AFC tournament. That would have meant a huge embarrassment for the AIFF,8217;8217; he said. Clearly a case of confused priorities.

Back to Oman. When Mahindra United beat Oman8217;s Dhoffar Club at home in an AFC Cup match early this February, there was general jubilation. It was believed that the upcoming World Cup match between the two countries would have a similar scoreline. But few bothered to notice that Dhoffar were playing with a depleted squad since most of their top players were in the national camp.

Story continues below this ad

So when Oman played India in the World Cup, it was a resounding win for the former. While India, again, had opted for club, for Oman it was country first. 8216;8216;Constantine called us up to point this out but we are helpless,8217;8217; says Colaco.

Wright8217;s revolution has resulted in reforms percolating deeper than they8217;d ever been before. While it obviously leaves much to be desired, there are talent spotters, selectors and specialist coaches at various levels, and his philosophy is being taken up suo motu at the grassroots level.

That8217;s an infrastructure Constantine would kill for. The selection process 8212; and all it involves 8212; begins and ends with the national coach. And, defying the laws of space and time, he does manage to fit in most NFL matches 8212; even so, is it enough? Colaco speaks of one school of thought 8212; which he doesn8217;t necessarily agree with 8212; about there being better players in Kolkata8217;s local league than the NFL. This certainly is debatable but considering India8217;s geography there might be areas which are certainly untapped.

This is just the tip of the iceberg. Wright sent Dalmiya a 10-page letter; maybe, Constantine needs to write a book.

THE SLIDE

 

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement