Premium
This is an archive article published on May 29, 1998

The vision thing

Now for the bad news. The Economic Survey for 1997-1998 confirms all the apprehensions about the economy. The growth rate is down to 5 perce...

.

Now for the bad news. The Economic Survey for 1997-1998 confirms all the apprehensions about the economy. The growth rate is down to 5 percent from 7.5 only a year before. The fiscal deficit has overshot the target of 4.5 percent of GDP by over 1.5 percent. Grain output is down 5 million tonnes. Exports are barely limping along at 2.6 percent, imports not doing much better at under 7 percent. Industrial growth is down well into the single digits. The government’s revenue collections are sharply down. The capital markets are depressed. Poor investment in infrastructure has emerged as a big impediment to growth as the benefits of removing existing slack taper off. The symptoms of a troubled economy are much in evidence.

There are redeeming features. As the Survey proclaims, the economic fundamentals are generally in better shape than elsewhere in Asia, though that is not saying very much just at the moment. External debt is down to a relatively respectable 24 percent, the savings and investment rates arehealthy. The current-account deficit, set to touch 1.5 per cent of GDP, is well under control and can safely be allowed to increase by another percentage point in the cause of speeding up investment. Low inflation may seem like the best part of it, but even that has a downside: it reflects a depressed economy rather than sound economic management, with the fiscal deficit spiralling and monetary policy having to remain tight at a time when the economy sorely needs a boost. Add to all this the yet-to-be-felt effect of economic sanctions against India and the outlook appears truly bleak.

Worse, there are no clear options to shake the economy out of its somnolence bar one. Finance Minister Yashwant Sinha’s early pronouncements fed the belief that he was all for pump-priming the economy with a strong dose of government spending. But better sense seems to have prevailed. The Survey itself concedes that the large fiscal deficit puts all the strain on monetary policy. But tight credit is as injurious to growth as alarge fiscal deficit. Yet the way, in fact, is clear if only the government can show the will: a visionary Budget that throws open the economy to investment from wherever it can be had. The government needs to open new sectors such as insurance to private investors if not yet to foreign ones, and others wider open to foreign investors. It would do well to resist temptation to selectively raise tariffs. A weaker rupee already is affording protection to domestic industry. Cheaper imports would encourage domestic competitiveness. All this will surely take guts. Though the government’s standing is high at the moment, so are noises for protection, natural at a time of economic pain and from a government sympathetic to the swadeshi idea. But the rewards would be well worth the boldness. It would have the dual benefit of partially offsetting the negative impact of sanctions and creating fresh impetus for investment and competition. India in principle stands to benefit as an investment destination in the wake of theAsian crisis, if it plays its cards right. In the longer run of course it needs another dose of reforms, the hardest ones left for the last, such as those in the labour market. But the immediate question is one of political will on the Budget.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement