Sale of Mumbai mill land illegal, rules HC

The Bombay High Court today ruled that the Rs 20,000 crore redevelopment across 600 acres of defunct-mill land was against existing laws and...

The Bombay High Court today ruled that the Rs 20,000 crore redevelopment across 600 acres of defunct-mill land was against existing laws and had been done without prior clearance.

Upholding a PIL filed by Bombay Environmental Action Group, the judgment by Justices S Radhakrishnan and S Dharmadhikari means that redevelopment now underway in central Mumbai’s sprawling mill lands will have to be shared three-way with government organisations for public housing and public open spaces.

More than 20 redevelopment projects of multi-crore apartment towers and office complexes are now on hold.

Story continues below this ad

The judgment said: ‘‘All the constructions carried out by various developers are clearly in violation of EIA (Environmental Impact Assessment) Notification as amended on July 7, 2004, as admittedly none of them have obtained clearance from Ministry of Environment and Forests.’’

They also ruled that National Textile Corporation’s auction of five nationalised mill lands—buyers included big developers like Shiv Sena leaders Raj Thackeray and Manohar Joshi, together paying Rs 2,000 crore —is illegal since it violates a Supreme Court approved revival plan. The projects, many financed by institutions like HDFC and ICICI, are already in an advanced stage of development.

‘‘The Supreme Court must take this up on an urgent basis,’’ HDFC Chairman Deepak Parekh told The Indian Express.

While mill owners, the NTC and private developers will challenge the judgment in the Supreme Court, planners and environmentalists were euphoric.

Story continues below this ad

The Paper Trail

		THE RULE: As per Development Control Regulation (58)—it was upheld on Monday— bankrupt mills could be redeveloped, provided two-thirds of the land was shared for open spaces and public housing. There were few takers THE AMENDMENT: In 2001, then chief minister Vilasrao Deshmukh altered DCR 58 to exclude all built-up area in a mill complex, thus allowing mill-owners to keep most of the land, sparking a real-estate rush WHAT’S AT STAKE: 58 defunct textile mills; 600 acres, or nine Nariman Points; redevelopment potential of Rs 20,000 crore VOID: THE BIG SALES These mills were auctioned by the National Textile Corporation since March in violation of a Supreme Court-approved revival plan: • Jupiter mills, PAREL (11 acres): Rs 276 crore, sold to India Bulls • Mumbai mills, PAREL (18 acres): Rs 702 crore, sold to DLF • Apollo Mills, ELPHINSTONE (8 acres): Rs 180 crore, sold to Lodha Builders • Elphinstone Mills, ELPHINSTONE (8 acres): Rs 460 crore, sold to India Bulls • Kohinoor mills, DADAR (5 acres): Rs 421 crore, sold to Matoshree Realtors and Kohinoor Group

India, US yet to find ‘landing ground’ for trade talks, our red lines must be respected: Jaishankar

India, US yet to find landing ground, our red lines must be respected: Jaishankar on talks

India50 min ago

Underlining that “there are things you can negotiate and there are things you can’t”, External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar said Sunday that India has been in talks with the US for “a trade understanding” where “our bottom lines and red lines are respected”. He reassured Quad is active, and India aims to go beyond defending interests and catch up in manufacturing.

View all shorts

Live Blog

PHOTOS