Premium
This is an archive article published on June 6, 2011

Nitin Garg’s murder was result of immaturity: Defence lawyer

A 16-year-old boy had stabbed 21-year-old Garg as he walked to work through a park in January last year.

The lawyer of a 16-year-old boy,who has pleaded guilty to killing Indian student Nitin Garg,told a court here that the murder was a result of immaturity of his client believed to be the youngest person in Victorian state of Australia to commit the crime.

At a plea hearing in the Victorian Supreme Court,Defence lawyer Marcus Dempsey told the Supreme court “At 15 and a half it seems (he) is one of the youngest people in this state to commit the offence of felony murder.” He said his client comes from a “much loved” background.

The lawyer said that despite phone intercepts recording the boy boasting the killing,there was remorse and the unintentional murder was a result of his immaturity and a spontaneous attempted robbery of Nitin Garg’s mobile phone.

Story continues below this ad

Prosecutors have told the court that he discussed a potential alibi with his parents before his arrest.

Justice Paul Coughlan described the case as “desperately sad.” He will be sentenced at a later date.

“It’s a desperately sad case from everyone’s point of view,” Justice Paul Coghlan said adding,”How a young man of this background finds himself here is just sad really.” The boy,whose identity has not been revealed,pleaded guilty to murder in April and is facing a maximum sentence of life in prison.

He stabbed the 21-year-old Garg as he walked to work through a park in Yarraville in January last year.

Garg’s murder sparked outrage in India.

Story continues below this ad

Justice Coghlan said he understood the boy would deny the crime when questioned by police.

“He’s a kid,he did what any of us would have done (at his age)… I grew up in a very,very helpful and loving family but I wasn’t necessarily always just a good boy.”

Prosecutor Amanda Forrester said there is “no evidence of any racial motivation in this crime”.

“This was a pointless act of violence… the offender went out of his house armed with a very serious weapon.”

Story continues below this ad

Justice Coghlan said the propensity of young people to carry knives was a significant concern.

“If he didn’t have the knife it wouldn’t have occurred.”

“Sentencing you is not going to be easy,I must say,” Justice Coghlan said.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement