Premium
This is an archive article published on December 13, 2005

Lions in exchange for tigers: The Gujarat-MP face-off

It is the battle for the big cats in Madhya Pradesh, called the tiger state of India, and Gujarat, home to the Asiatic lion. Madhya Pradesh ...

.

It is the battle for the big cats in Madhya Pradesh, called the tiger state of India, and Gujarat, home to the Asiatic lion. Madhya Pradesh wants lions and Gujarat doesn’t have any tiger. ‘‘Tigers for lions,’’ prescribes Dr M K Ranjit Singh, a wildlife expert, who hails from Gujarat but worked in Madhya Pradesh as the forest secretary and later with the government of India. He feels this will fulfil the aspirations of both states.

However, Gujarat, fiercely proud of its heritage, has refused numerous requests for parting with a few lions to be relocated at Palpur-Kuno sanctuary in Madhya Pradesh, specially created as a second home to the Gir lion at an enormous cost. The central Indian state seems to have given up. ‘‘We are not going to beg for lions anymore,’’ says PCCF (Wildlife) Dr P B Gandopadhyaya. ‘‘Our stand on the issue is very clear,’’ retorts his counterpart in Gujarat Pradeep Khanna.

Outside zoos, the last tiger in Gujarat was spotted in 1997, and three years later, the count came down to nought. When Project Tiger was launched in 1973, the state barely had eight tigers. On the other hand, the last census of Asiatic lions showed the population going up from 327 to 359 in five years.

Story continues below this ad

‘‘We have no reason to shift the lion anywhere, we have already expanded the sanctuary area,’’ a proud Narendra Modi had declared.

‘‘Gujarat is the only political entity which had both lions and tigers. The tiger has become extinct in Gujarat but it can be re-established in the Dangs forest,’’ says Singh.

According to P R Sinha, director of the Wildlife Institute of India, Dehra Dun, there should be no problems in the ‘exchange’. Adds Dr Singh: ‘‘The habitat suitability will have to be studied keeping in view the World Conservation Union (IUCN) guidelines, protocol and procedures.’’

Singh has discussed the exchange with Gujarat government officials and their counterparts in Madhya Pradesh. Neither government is ruling out the possibility of a discussion, but the question is who will take the initiative given that the lion relocation project in Gujarat has come a cropper so far.

Story continues below this ad

‘‘Let them come with a proposal, we will examine and study it. I can’t say ‘yes’ or ‘no’ off hand,’’ says Khanna. ‘‘There is no proposal from their side. We are ready if they approach us,’’ says Dr Gangopadhyaya. This, when the same political party is ruling both the states. ‘‘The answers could come when both the states regard this as a challenge rather than a problem,’’ concludes Singh.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement