Premium
This is an archive article published on October 3, 2002

Grateful or not, Cong calls it a Freudian slip

This bloomer in a Department of Audio-Visual Publicity (DAVP) ad couldn’t have turned up at a worse place or on a worse day. A Gandhi J...

.

This bloomer in a Department of Audio-Visual Publicity (DAVP) ad couldn’t have turned up at a worse place or on a worse day. A Gandhi Jayanti remembrance ad in Gujarati that appeared in many newspapers across the Mahatma’s home state had his sketch, and below it, in large typesize, the words: ‘An ungrateful nation pays homage to the Father of the Nation on his 133rd birth anniversary’.

The blunder owes to the similar-sounding opposites krutagnya, meaning grateful, and krutaghna, meaning ungrateful.

The ad errs disastrously: it uses the word krutaghna.

The Congress has already found a political handle in the slip. The slip, the Gujarat unit of the party says, is Freudian. A statement from Gujarat Pradesh Congress Committee vice-president and spokesman Hasmukh Patel says the slip ‘‘gives away the deep-rooted ungratefulness of the Sangh Parivar to Mahatma Gandhi.’’

Story continues below this ad

The press note implies that the error could have only got past the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)-led coalition at the Centre (DAVP is a central agency) and the BJP government in Gujarat.

To rub it in, the Congress highlights the difference in the two words by quoting from the Brihad Shabdakosh, a standard reference dictionary of Gujarati written by philologist K.K. Shastri, a Vishwa Hindu Parishad stalwart sympathetic to the BJP.

Wags, however, may describe this inversion as a rare example of truthfulness, so beloved of the Mahatma, in a nation that seems to have forgotten his ideals.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement