Premium
This is an archive article published on July 5, 2002

Controversy over credits: Tilonia gives award back

Bunker Roy, director of the Barefoot College in Tilonia, has decided to return the coveted Aga Khan award for architecture presented last ye...

.

Bunker Roy, director of the Barefoot College in Tilonia, has decided to return the coveted Aga Khan award for architecture presented last year.

Disagreeing with the Aga Khan Foundation’s decision to revise the citation of the award by including Delhi-based architect Neehar Raina in it—as reported in The Indian Express— Roy said: ‘‘we are compelled by unfortunate and regrettable circumstances to return the $ 50,000 award.’’ He added that ‘‘it is both a protest and a question of ethics.’’ This is the first time that someone has returned the award, which is given after a laborious process of three years of nominations, short-listing and individual visits by experts.

The award was given to ‘‘barefoot architects’’, essentially locals without formal education, ‘‘for their contribution in building rainwater harvesting structures’’, houses for the homeless and the main campus building of the college, earlier called the Social Work and Research Centre meant for promoting rural skills.

Story continues below this ad

However, three months after the award was presented, Raina lodged a protest with the foundation, claiming he had prepared the project’s architectural design.

After investigating the matter, the foundation accredited Raina for ‘‘preparing the architectural layout and the barefoot architects for the construction of the buildings’’.

‘‘We disagree with the revised decision of the foundation and are unable to accept the claims made by Raina,’’ said Roy, insisting that Raina was only a ‘‘designer’’ who prepared the initial concepts and not the ‘‘architect’’.

‘‘Raina’s contribution was only towards helping to prepare an initial layout of the Barefoot College campus by vastly benefitting from the knowledge and wisdom of local people, including rural women,’’ claimed Roy.

Story continues below this ad

In an official statement, Roy said he felt that the ideology of the Barefoot College has been misunderstood and misrepresented. Following Roy’s decision to return the award, the Council for Architecture is slated to meet shortly and present their views on the matter.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement