Journalism of Courage
Advertisement

Gastroenterologist rates popular Indian snacks based on gut health impact; this is where your favourite rank

Look for traditional small scale manufactures producing these snacks with a short shelf life. Since that alone doesn’t guarantee healthier alternative, read the label too.

snackWhere does your favourite snack fall? (Source: Freepik)

Gastroenterologist Dr Pal Manickam has shared his rankings for 10 Indian snacks based on their impact on gut health. From 10 to 1 (worst to best), he has ranked popular options like momos, bhujia, namkeen and pani puri, and we reached out to health experts to verify his claims. While it is hard to generalise the recommendations for everyone, here’s a more nuanced breakdown of these snacking options:

10. Pani Puri

“More than the fried puri, the underlying risk could be the water contamination for gut health. Although the spices in the pani have mild antimicrobial properties, it is not strong enough to protect from infections. If you have a sensitive gut, then ensure you get the pani puris from a reliable outlet,” said Meenu Balaji, chief nutritionist at Pragmatic Nutrition, Chennai. According to her, if the oil used for frying puri has been reused, then it can produce free radicals and aldehydes, which are harmful.

Healthier alternative: Make at home, adjust the spice level according to your tolerance.

9. Bhujia & Namkeen

CV Aishwarya, a clinical nutritionist and lecturer at Sri Ramachandra Institute of Higher Education and Research, Chennai, said that these crunchy munchies are loaded with emulsifiers, preservatives, and refined oils, which can disturb the gut microbiome and cause bloating or sluggish digestion. Best kept for rare indulgence.

Suggestion: Look for traditional small-scale manufacturers producing these snacks with a short shelf life. Since that alone doesn’t guarantee a healthier alternative, read the label too.

8. Pakoda

“Deep-fried delight, heavy digest. While gram flour has protein, deep frying increases fat oxidation, making it harder to digest and prone to cause bloating or acidity. Try air-fried or shallow-fried versions instead,” suggested Aishwarya, as Balaji added that pakoras are best enjoyed in moderation when made at home, to be sure of the cooking oil used.

7. Samosa

The outer crispy crust is made from maida, the refined flour which lacks fibre, slows digestion, and can cause abdominal discomfort. Deep fried samosas can cause bloating in people with SIBO (small intestinal bacterial overgrowth), gall bladder or motility related issues. “One easy way to have it would be to include more veggies in the stuffing. You can also bake samosas at home,” said Aishwarya.

Story continues below this ad
These crunchy munchies are loaded with emulsifiers, preservatives, and refined oils (Source: Freepik)

6. Pav Bhaji

“Pav is again made with refined flour, which is low in fibre. But when you eat it with lots of bhaji it makes up for the fibre intake. Interestingly, butter in itself is not the bad guy here. In fact it provides butyrate which is good for your gut. The quantity of butter is what you should be vary of,” explained Balaji.

5. Momos

Steamed momos are lighter and easier to digest. The stuffed vegetables are a addition of fibre. The spicy sauces, on the other hand can cause, acidity in some people, said both.

4. Khakhra

When made with whole wheat or millets and baked, khakra becomes a high-fibre, guilt-free snack. However, overdoing spicy or oily variants can upset sensitive guts. Moderation matters. However, very high temperature baking can produce acrylamides, just like any other dry heat cooking.

3. Corn with lemon and chilli

Corn with lemon and chilli can cause acidity or heartburn for some due to its high starch content. “Roasted corn with lemon and chilli is rich in fibre and supports gut motility. Eat slowly and chew well, said Aishwarya, adding that boiled corn is a better option in that case. Moreover, people with SIBO can experience bloating when they eat corn.

Story continues below this ad

2. Roasted Makhana

Makhanas are low in glycemic index and a good choice even for people with gut related issues, said Balaji. A low-fat, high-protein option that’s gentle on digestion and keeps full longer. Roast lightly and avoid sugary or overly salty coatings. “You can also roast makhana in a little ghee at home and add flavours of your choice,” suggested Balaji.

1. Sundal (Soaked & Cooked Legumes)

A traditional South Indian gem boiled legumes with coconut and spices make it rich in fibre, prebiotics, and plant protein. Great for digestion, satiety, and gut microbiome balance. But not all of them are able to digest it well. “Soak the chana overnight and pressure cook it. If you have digestive issues, eat lesser sundal or have it less frequently,” said Aishwarya.

DISCLAIMER: This article is based on information from the public domain and/or the experts we spoke to. Always consult your health practitioner before starting any routine.

From the homepage


📣 For more lifestyle news, click here to join our WhatsApp Channel and also follow us on Instagram
Tags:
  • Gut Health snack snacks
Edition
Install the Express App for
a better experience
Featured
Trending Topics
News
Multimedia
Follow Us
Tavleen Singh writesCongress is Bihar’s biggest loser
X