Stay updated with the latest - Click here to follow us on Instagram
Allahabad High Court Building (Express Archives)
A special three-judge bench, comprising Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud, and Justices Dilip Gupta and Yashwant Verma, also quashed the amendments brought in the state education department’s rules through which the shiksha mitras were being regularized. The bench passed the order while hearing a bunch of nearly three dozen petitions, the lead petition being that of Shivam Rajan and three others.
Counsel for Shivam Rajan, Agnihotri Kumar Tripathi said: “The court has declared the decision of the state government as ultra vires and set aside the government order under challenge, as well as all other consequential orders. It was of the opinion that the appointment of shiksha mitras was not against sanctioned posts. Also reservation rules were not followed. However, the court did not pass any opinion on the shikha mitras getting training for BTC (Basic Teaching Certificate).”
[related-post]
Confirming the development, Additional Advocate General C B Yadav, who represented the state, said: “The court has said that shiksha mitras will not be assimilated as assistant teachers. Even those, who have got training of BTC will continue to remain shiksha mitras”.
He added that the state government was already in the process of recruiting those having passed the Teachers’ Eligibility Test (TET).
After the government took the decision to assimilate shiksha mitras as assistant teachers in May 2014, a large number of petitions were filed —- at the Lucknow Bench and at the Main bench here in Allahabad – by those holding BEd degree, BTC and having qualified TET.
Finally, following an order of the Supreme Court in the matter, a three-judge bench, led by the Chief Justice, was constituted to hear all the matters together. “The Supreme Court had passed the order on July 27, directing that all matters be heard and disposed within two months,” said Tripathi.
Shiksha mitras, who were supposed to have minimum qualification of intermediate, were appointed during the previous BSP rule through a government order (GO) in 1999. They were supposed to help out the villagers in getting their children enrolled in schools and raise awareness about the need for education.
In 2010, the National Council Teachers’ Education (NCTE) ruled that only those qualify Teachers’ Eligibility Test (TET) will be appointed as teacher from the primary level upwards. However, it had given an exemption of five years to those who were already teachers.
In 2011, the government got permission from the NCTE to provide shiksha mitras the two-year BTC. Many batches were sent for training since 2011 and some are being trained even now; the total number, thus, reaching to nearly 1.72 lakh.
In 2012, the newly-elected Samajwadi Party government initiated the populist measure of regularizing the shiksha mitras. In May 2014, the government amended the teaching rules, which were implemented after the introduction of Right to Education Act, in which it was said that the shiksha mitras would not require to qualify the TET. It then passed the GO announcing their assimilation as assistant teachers. Nearly 59,000 shikha mitras were regularized in the first phase in June, 2014 followed by another 73,000 in the second phase in June this year
The third phase was put on hold after the Supreme Court stayed the same and asked the High Court to take a final decision on the matter.
“The court was of the view that shiksha mitras were not appointed as teachers in the first place,” said Tripathi.
Stay updated with the latest - Click here to follow us on Instagram