HC slams Haryana Power Utilities for snubbing tug-of-war athletes

The Punjab and Haryana High Court directed that a decision on reimbursing travel expenses of employees who represented India at a global tug-of-war competition be taken within two months.

The court directed the utilities to consider the athletes’ representation of July 15, 2025, and pass a reasoned order after hearing them. The court directed the utilities to consider the athletes’ representation of July 15, 2025, and pass a reasoned order after hearing them. (File)

The Punjab and Haryana High Court has directed Haryana Power Utilities to consider reimbursing the travel expenses of employees who represented India at the International Tug of War World Outdoor Championship in Germany last year, criticising the utilities’ “whimsical” conduct and its inconsistency with the state’s duty to promote sports.

Disposing of a petition filed by Kanval Deep and others, Justice Harpreet Singh Brar on September 24 ordered a “speaking decision” within two months, after finding merit in the athletes’ grievance that they had been assured reimbursement before a sudden reversal.

The petitioners, employees of Haryana Power Utilities, sought travel allowance of Rs 3.13 lakh each for the Mannheim championship in September 2024. They pointed out that the Haryana Power Sports Group initially sanctioned the amount and issued a no-objection certificate, but withdrew support after a change of committee, reinstating participation only with the rider that no expenditure would be borne.

Story continues below this ad

Their counsel argued this created a “legitimate expectation” of reimbursement. The court noted that one of the utilities, Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited (UHBVNL), had in fact reimbursed its employees for the same event, underlining arbitrary treatment.

Justice Brar observed that the petitioners could not be expected to abandon their plans “to justify the whimsical approach taken… in the eleventh hour.” He called the denial “antithetical” to national sports promotion, citing constitutional directives and government initiatives like Khelo India and Fit India.

“The State has made significant efforts in promotion of sports to not only promote public health but also foster national pride,” the order said, while lamenting systemic gaps such as “inadequate coaching, delayed stipends and bureaucratic obstructions.”

The court directed the utilities to consider the athletes’ representation of July 15, 2025, and pass a reasoned order after hearing them. If found entitled, reimbursement must follow “forthwith”, it added.

Stay updated with the latest - Click here to follow us on Instagram

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Loading Taboola...
Advertisement