Thomas Cup 2024 Highlights: HS Prannoy the sole winner, Satwik-Chirag lose thriller; India to face China in quarterfinals

BWF Thomas & Uber Cup 2024 Highlights: India went down 1-4 against Indonesia in a rematch of the 2022 final.

Written by Vinayakk Mohanarangan
Updated: May 1, 2024 10:44 PM IST
Thomas and Uber Cup 2024 Live: Catch all the live updates of Thomas and Uber Cup 2024 from Chengdu in ChinaThomas and Uber Cup 2024 Live: Satwik-Chirag on left and HS Prannoy on right. (FILE)

Thomas Cup 2024, India vs Indonesia, Group C Live Updates: Defending champions went down 1-4 against Indonesia in a Thomas Cup Group C thriller in Chengdu on Wednesday. Both teams have qualified for the quarterfinals after winning their first two matches, India finished second as a result of this defeat. And now, they have been drawn to face top seeds China in the quarterfinal on Thursday.

HS Prannoy was the solitary winner, as he came back from a game down against Anthony Ginting. Satwiksairaj Rankireddy and Chirag Shetty saved 12 match points but went down fighting against Muhammad Shohibul Fikri – Bagas Maulana. Lakshya Sen took Jonatan Christie to the distance but lost in three Sai Pratheek replaced MR Arjun to partner Dhruv Kapila and the scratch pairing went down in straight games against Leo Rolly Carnando – Daniel Marthin to give Indonesia the decisive advantage. In a dead rubbber, Srikanth lost against Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo.

Story continues below this ad

India vs Indonesia Group C lineup

MS1: HS Prannoy 13-21 21-12 21-12 Anthony Sinisuka Ginting
MD1: Satwiksairaj Rankireddy – Chirag Shetty 22-24 24-22 19-21 Muhammad Shohibul Fikri – Bagas Maulana
MS2: Lakshya Sen 18-21 21-16 17-21 Jonatan Christie
MD2: Dhruv Kapila – Sai Pratheek 20-22 11-21 Leo Rolly Carnando – Daniel Marthin
MS3: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19 22-24 14-21 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

On Thursday, Indian women will take on Japan in the Uber Cup quarterfinals. Read more about their match against China here.

Thomas Cup 2024, India vs Indonesia, Group C recap below: 

Live Blog

Thomas and Uber Cup 2024 Live Updates: Catch all the live updates of India's men's and women's badminton teams from Chengdu in China

22:38 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-4 Indonesia,Group C: Watch highlights

22:37 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas and Uber Cup 2024: Unlucky 13



Not one, not two, not even 10... Satwiksairaj Rankireddy and Chirag Shetty saved as many as 12 match points against Muhammad Shohibul Fikri - Bagas Maulana in the Thomas Cup group-stage clash against Indonesia. Eventually, it was unlucky 13 for the Indians as their recent nemesis prevailed.

Satwik-Chirag were a game and 14-20 down. At that point, it seemed as if the match was as good as over. But on Satwik's serve, the Indians started to claw their way back. They have done this before, just earlier this year. But those were not match points, but game points at the Malaysia Open. But here, every one of those points were potential match-enders. But the Indians reeled off 6 straight points, targeting mostly Maulana. Then from 20-20, they saved two more to force a decider.

In Game 3, they trailed 15-20. Surely not again? Once again on Satwik's serve, they got to 19-20. But what could have been the greatest heist in Indian badminton history fell just short when Fikri, fittingly, closed it out. 

 
21:49 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas and Uber Cup 2024: Quarterfinals lineup

Confirmed, both of India's quarterfinals on Thursday:

Uber Cup, India vs Japan: 7 am IST
Thomas Cup, India vs China: 2.30 pm IST 

Unfortunate how it worked out for the Indian men's team, who finished a marathon match today and have to play again tomorrow. China meanwhile come into this with a rest day today.

21:32 (IST)01 May 2024

Uber Cup: Meanwhile, the lineup has been confirmed for India vs Japan.

Uber Cup quarterfinals. 7.00 am IST on Thursday.


No Akane Yamaguchi for Japan, Ashmita Chaliha vs Aya Ohori to start off in an all-left clash. 


WS1: Aya Ohori vs Ashmita Chaliha
WD1: Nami Matsuyama - Chiharu Shida vs Priya Konjengbam - Shruti Mishra
WS2: Nozomi Okuhara vs Isharani Baruah
WD2: Rena Miyaura - Ayako Sakuramoto vs Simran Singhi - Ritika Thaker
WS3: Tomoka Miyazaki vs Tanvi Sharma

21:15 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-4 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Quarterfinals lineup confirmed!

China vs India

Japan vs Malaysia

Indonesia vs Korea

Denmark vs Chinese Taipei 

21:03 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-4 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Quarterfinals draw

Seed 1: China

Seed 2: Denmark 

Seed 3: Indonesia

Seed 4: Japan 

20:59 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-4 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Quarterfinals draw

India's possible opponents: China or Denmark or Japan. The draw ceremony is about to begin. 

20:46 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-4 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Stick around, the QF lineup will be confirmed soon

A fantastic, marathon tie comes to an end. India could have easily reversed that scoreline. SatChi could've won, Lakshya could've won, Srikanth could've won. In the end though, Indonesia prevail & top the group. Stick around for a bit, we should know our quarterfinals lineup and schedule soon. 
 

20:43 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-4 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 22-24 14-21 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Chico wins, Indonesia clinch the tie 4-1: The scoreline is slightly harsh on India but of course, numbers don't lie. Srikanth had two match points in Game 2 but is unable to convert. 

20:41 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 22-24 13-20 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Seven match points for Chico. 

20:39 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 22-24 12-19 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Shivani Naik: There's no Srikanth match if there's no decider with drama built in. 8-14 behind now. It's so wild even the commentator goes from 'good shot' to 'bad shot' in 10 seconds flat. The fifth rubber lament continues. But you can't peel your eyes away from this for hopes of an impossible comeback. Wry smiles.

20:39 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 22-24 10-18 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

This is now heading to a swift conclusion. Not much left to fight for. 

20:35 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 22-24 8-13 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

As we cross the 6-hour mark in the tie, Srikanth's winning streak in THomas Cup that started in Bangkok could be about to end. 

20:33 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 22-24 6-11 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

As Gill Clark points out, it is 11-6 in favour of Chico in all three games so far! Some coincidence that. Srikanth closed the gap in the 2nd half on both occasions. Does he have enough gas in the tank to do it again here? 

20:29 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 22-24 3-8 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

The errors are flowing from Srikanth's racket here. His perennial foe. 

20:28 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 22-24 2-6 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

A massive dive forward from Chico to return the shuttle, he gets back up and dives again on the turn and Srikanth has missed an easy winner. That is terrific from the Indonesian and equally poor from Sri. The court needs some heavy mopping now! So much sweat. 

20:25 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 22-24 0-3 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Strong start from Chico to the decider. We are nearing six hours since the tie started. 

20:22 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 22-24 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

CHICO TAKES IT TO THE DECIDER: Srikanth misses the sideline with his smash, he is the kind of player who doesn't really know to play safe. High risk game and there it didn't pay off.

20:20 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 22-23 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Chico saves another match point and now has another game point of his own, set up by a nice inside-out smash. 

20:20 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 22-22 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Shivani Naik: The Kidambi Srikanth rollercoaster continues. One moment his serve return is swell getting Kashyap and Gopichand to high five for 19-19. Next he errs and scrunches his eyes for 19-20.  Moments later he has blitzed to net for match point. Then his backhand return is in net. And next Chico sends it long.  Back to match point. ALL This in no context fifth rubber. Only because it's Srikanth.

20:19 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 22-21 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Srikanth has a match point but squanders it with an error. But a second match point coming soon for the Indian as Chico makes a futile review. 

20:18 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 20-20 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Shivani Naik: Wonder if there's enough in Materials Chemistry to figure out a shoe sole that remains flat bottomed but doesn't slip as easily on sweat dripped badminton courts? Making the courts anti-slip is the obvious way forward... But surely the shoe sole can get a look in

20:17 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 20-20 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Srikanth makes it 19-all but then pushes the shuttle long to give Chico a game point. And wow, what a save! Srikanth with a Matrix dodge to see the shuttle go long on his side and it's 20-20. 

20:14 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 18-19 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Srikanth edges ahead but Chico levels it now and then go into the lead as Srikanth nets a backhand. 

20:14 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 17-17 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

And once again, Srikanth fights back in the game. Back level. 

20:11 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 14-16 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Shivani Naik: That was Srikanth running rings around Chico who had to jump not quite hoops, but ad boards. The Indonesian defended well but Srikanth got in 3 outrageous placements. Chico chasing them went rabbitting out of bounds.

20:10 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 14-15 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

And Srikanth is closing in! The gap is down to 1 point, momentum on Sri's side.

20:10 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 10-14 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

20:06 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 8-12 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Funny moment there as Srikanth plays a stunning backhand block for a winner and Chico rushes to get to it, misses it and the momentum carries him into the next court.

20:02 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19, 6-11 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Chico is now starting to create some separation. The match has gone against the grain so far, with the far side player having more joy in the opening 2 games. A change in drift perhaps? Chico with a big lead into the interval. 

19:59 (IST)01 May 2024

Being Srikanth Kidambi...

There will be thrilling highs, there will be painfully excruciating lows. There will be a second where you feel why you ever got into this in the first place. But there will also be moments where you wouldn’t want it to end. When it is over, you will be glad to get out of it but also perhaps grateful for the experience of it all. Welcome aboard the Srikanth Kidambi rollercoaster.

Read more here.

19:53 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 21-19 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Game 1, Srikanth: What a fightback from Sri! He looked off the pace early on but finishes the game on a run of 4 straight points. The winner to set up match point was a sensational hold-and-flick to the backcourt that made Gopichand really happy! 

19:51 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 18-19 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Shivani Naik: That earlier point will be burnished in memory where Srikanth moved quickly to net for fast follow-up. And Prannoy applauded from sidelines. What legends these two have been for Indian men's singles badminton over the last 10 years. Giant kills. Titles. Gorgeous ruminating stylish games. Complete attacks. And all the frustrations. And heartbreaks on losses to be nursed 10 years later. Phases where Prannoy took out potential challengers to help Srikanth towards titles. Great team players. Thomas Cup champs. 
Don't know if they are thick friends. But Srikanth-Prannoy will be missed after they call it a day.

19:50 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 17-19 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Oh no what a miss that is from Srikanth! The backhand kill was there but the shuttle touches the frame of his racket and lands on his side. Could have drawn level there. 

19:49 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 17-18 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

What an effort from Chico. First a massive dive towards the net on the backhand side and then a massive dive to the other corner diagonally but this time Srikanth finds the winner. 

19:49 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 16-18 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

19:46 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 16-16 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

This is a nice little fightback from Srikanth, good to see he is not taking this lightly (pointless match but definitely good for momentum). The Indian veteran draws level with two lovely winners to Chico's backhand side 

19:40 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 10-13 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Like how Gill Clark likes to come up with fun facts here's one for you: Chico has a sibling who also plays badminton, Ester. And Ester Nurumi Tri Wardoyo is the third child, while Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo is the second child and hence the Tri and Dwi in their names. 

19:38 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 7-11 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

A run of SEVEN straight points as Srikanth's good start fizzled out. There is not much riding on it, but I imagine Srikanth would want to make sure he carries some confidence into the knockouts. 

19:37 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 6-8 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Chico into the lead now on a run of points. 

19:33 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi 4-2 Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

Shivani Naik: This fifth match seems superfluous, considering quarters tomorrow (or day after). But solely for tagline potential, Chico vs Chika (of Badminton) has a good ring to it. There's also the bonus of two timeless, elegant games if context doesn't matter.

19:29 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Srikanth Kidambi vs Chico Aura Dwi Wardoyo

If the match had come down to this, we could have had a really thrilling climax. (That's perhaps what SatChi and Lakshya are thinking too). As it is, this is a first meeting between world No 25 Srikanth and world No 29 Chico. 

19:26 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Looking ahead a little bit..

Shivani Naik's choice for India's quarterfinal opponents: 1.? ?Japan 2.? ?Denmark 3.? ?China.

What would be yours? 

19:25 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-3 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Dhruv-Sai 20-22 11-21 Carnando-Marthin

Match and tie sealed by Indonesia: There it is, the top spot confirmed for Indonesia in Group C. But Indian fans, looking for some positives, the team finished 2nd in the group in Bangkok too. So all is not lost. Let's wait and see who they draw now. 

19:21 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-2 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Dhruv-Sai 20-22 11-20 Carnando-Marthin

Match (and tie) points galore for the Indonesians. 

19:20 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-2 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Dhruv-Sai 20-22 9-18 Carnando-Marthin

'Possible we could see this matchup again on Saturday or even Sunday': Gill Clark Wouldn't that be brilliant? It's been a really fun tie once again between India and Indonesia.

19:18 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-2 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Dhruv-Sai 20-22 8-16 Carnando-Marthin

That first game... the Indians needed that. To put some scoreboard pressure on the Indonesians. Now it feels all too easy for them. Indonesia have all but clinched this. The Srikanth match is set to be academic. 

19:15 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-2 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Dhruv-Sai 20-22 7-13 Carnando-Marthin

And perhaps as expected, the gap is beginning to grow. The Indonesians in control now. Top spot in their grabs. 

19:12 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-2 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Dhruv-Sai 20-22 6-10 Carnando-Marthin

Shivani Naik: How many Indian badminton diehards, team tie tragics are beginning to get the queasy, ghost-seeing feeling already that starts with K and ends with H? Hopefully Dhruv-Pratheek can take this to 2-2. But even otherwise, the leadup to a Kidambi Srikanth match, the first beads of dread-sweat must have begun to form. The stylish player does full justice to the reverse idiom: "There's breakdown in beauty"

Our advice: Breathe.

19:11 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-2 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Dhruv-Sai 20-22 4-7 Carnando-Marthin

Sai Pratheek with a good put away at the net but the points are not coming easy for the Indians anymore and there is separation starting to form. 

19:09 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-2 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Dhruv-Sai 20-22 3-5 Carnando-Marthin

Shivani Naik: They might have lost today, but Satwik-Chirag's end points beast mentality puts them at a different level than the second pair. Experience matters, and like the women's team, Sai Pratheek will learn from those last two points of composure and sharp strokes under pressure

19:08 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-2 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Dhruv-Sai 20-22 3-3 Carnando-Marthin

If it was a case of perhaps getting used to the new Indian combination, maybe Marthin and Carnando will start pushing ahead now. But the Indians keeping it even in the early stages of. Game 2.

19:05 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-2 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Dhruv-Sai 20-22 Carnando-Marthin

Game 1, INA: Carnando with a great serve for their game point. And the error comes from the Indians as Indonesians take the lead. Close but no cigar for the Indian duo.  

19:03 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-2 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Dhruv-Sai 20-20 Carnando-Marthin

It's the Indians who have the first game point, good serve from Dhruv. But soon enough it's level again EXtra points needed. 

19:01 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-2 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Dhruv-Sai 19-19 Carnando-Marthin

Carnando with a super winner at the net, picking the shuttle from top of the tape. They lead now but an error and now we are back level. 

18:59 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-2 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Dhruv-Sai 18-17 Carnando-Marthin

Mathias Boe points to the forehead once more... the Indians sneak ahead again. 

18:58 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-2 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Dhruv-Sai 16-17 Carnando-Marthin

Oh some confusion in the Indian positioning there, problem with being a non-regular pair.

18:58 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-2 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Dhruv-Sai 16-16 Carnando-Marthin

The Indians are inching ahead, but the Indonesians keep pulling it back. Question of nerves from here on. 

18:57 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-2 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Dhruv-Sai 15-15 Carnando-Marthin

Staying in touch. Most doubles games get decided from this point onwards. There is some needle going on in this. Daniel told not to delay. 

18:55 (IST)01 May 2024

Thomas Cup 2024, India 1-2 Indonesia, Group C LIVE: Dhruv-Sai 14-14 Carnando-Marthin

If you, like me, thought it was a bridge too far for this scratch Indian doubles combination, then so far we will both be wrong. Solid fight from the Indians. 

Uber Cup 2024: Indian youngsters were outplayed by mighty China – but beyond 0-5 scoreline, here’s what we learned about NextGen

Isharani Baruah is No 83, Anmol Kharb is No 258 and Tanvi Sharma is No 589. Tanvi was also the youngest at the Uber Cup, at age 15. (BAI)

There were myriad technical shortcomings of hers that Isharani Baruah candidly reflected on after being shot out 21-12, 21-10 by Olympic champion Chen Yufei playing the Uber Cup group match. The pace of the rallies she could cope with, but Yufei’s lengths, her drops, variations, and all strokes going to the backcourt, mightily awed the 20-year-old. “And it was not comfortable. It was tough. I have to improve my strokes and variations,” she would state.

Then wide-eyed, guilelessly she would get to the crux of the only thing she could control: “..and she doesn’t make silly mistakes like me.” It was taking responsibility after being fielded as the No 1 singles player and being as realistic as someone thrown into the deep end could be. (Read more from Shivani Naik)

  • news-guard-logo
  • The Indian Express website has been rated GREEN for its credibility and trustworthiness by Newsguard, a global service that rates news sources for their journalistic standards.
  • news-guard-logo-with-title
Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments