Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Highlights: ‘PM Modi should apologise to people for misleading them by ‘twisting’ Nehru’s letter to states,’ says Mallikarjun Kharge in RS

Parliament Winter Session Highlights: Concluding the debate in Lok Sabha on Saturday, PM Modi said the Constitutional amendments introduced by his government were not aimed at consolidating power, unlike those made by the Congress.

Leader of Opposition in Rajya Sabha Mallikarjun Kharge while speaking in the Rajya Sabha on Monday. (screengrab)

Winter session of Parliament Day 17 Highlights: In a session of the Rajya Sabha on Monday, Leader of the Opposition Mallikarjun Kharge sharply criticised Prime Minister Narendra Modi for allegedly misleading the public. Kharge accused Modi of distorting a historical letter from Jawaharlal Nehru to state governments. He said that the Prime Minister is “living in the past” and suggested it would have been more beneficial for Modi to speak of the contemporary achievements that have reinforced democracy. Kharge also condemned the BJP for using empty rhetoric to deceive the citizens.

PM Modi’s Remarks in Lok Sabha Debate During the conclusion of the Lok Sabha debate on Saturday, Prime Minister Narendra Modi defended his government’s constitutional amendments, and said they are not aimed at consolidating power, unlike those made by the Congress party. His comments triggered an uproar among the opposition, particularly when he referenced the Emergency period under former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi. Earlier, Opposition leader Rahul Gandhi criticised the Modi administration, claiming it is metaphorically “cutting off the right thumb” of disadvantaged youth, akin to Dronacharya’s actions against Eklavya.

Story continues below this ad

Postponement of One Nation One Election Bills The government has announced a delay in the introduction of two bills aimed at facilitating simultaneous elections for the Lok Sabha and state assemblies. Initially scheduled for Monday, sources indicated that the introduction of these “One Nation One Election” bills in the Lok Sabha has been postponed until later this week.

Live Updates

20:52 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Sibal warns of political pollution, calls for protection of democratic institutions

Rajya Sabha MP Kapil Sibal on Monday raised serious concerns about the "state of Indian democracy", criticising the current political landscape and warning about potential threats from global technological powers.

Speaking in the Upper House during a debate to commemorate 75 years of the Indian Constitution, Sibal highlighted what he described as systemic failures in the country's democratic framework.

"India is not about one man, India is about people of this country," he said, taking apparent aim at the current political leadership.

The veteran politician outlined multiple challenges facing the nation's democratic institutions. He pointed to economic disparities, stating that one per cent of the population owns 40-50 per cent of the country's wealth. Sibal also raised concerns about social justice, referencing incidents of violence against dalits and ongoing civil unrest. - PTI

20:41 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: Six newly elected Rajya Sabha MPs take oath

Six newly elected Rajya Sabha MPs, including former National Commission for Women chairperson Rekha Sharma and industrialist Sana Sathish Babu, took oath as members of the Upper House of Parliament on Monday.

BJP's Sharma and Telugu Desam Party's (TDP) Babu were elected unopposed to the Rajya Sabha from Haryana and Andhra Pradesh respectively last week.

TDP's Beeda Mastan Rao and BJP's Ryaga Krishnaiah were also among those who took oath on Monday. Both of them were elected unopposed from Andhra Pradesh.

BJP's Sujeet Kumar and TMC's Ritabrata Banerjee, who was elected from West Bengal, also took oath.

The newly elected MPs signed the members' register and greeted Chairman Jagdeep Dhankhar. - PTI

20:39 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: Emergency in 1975 a mistake but no time limit for undeclared emergency in country today, says Singhvi

Admitting that the Emergency in 1975 was a "mistake", Congress leader Abhishek Singhvi said on Monday that while it lasted for 18 months, there is no time limit for the "undeclared emergency" in the country today.

Participating in a debate on the 75-year glorious journey of the Constitution in the Rajya Sabha, he termed the Emergency period in 1975 as a constitutional distortion for a specific time frame while noting that the current undeclared emergency has no time limit and goes on unabated.

"Speaking for the emergency, there were mistakes committed, I mean it and Congress has also said it before. Now 90 per cent of speeches start from the first amendment in 1950. What about the distortions which have creeped in today... what is the answer? If Nehru committed a mistake, we will also do it, is this the way? It is not logical," Singhvi said. PTI

19:57 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: Why changed approach towards partners after becoming CM, says Cong MP asks Omar Abdullah

Congress MP Manickam Tagore on Monday hit out at Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Omar Abdullah over his remarks on EVMs, asking why he had changed his approach towards INDIA bloc partners after becoming the Jammu and Kashmir chief minister.

He said parties such as the Samajwadi Party (SP), Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) and the Shiv Sena (UBT) have also spoken against electronic voting machines (EVMs).

In an exclusive interview with PTI, the NC leader dismissed the objections to EVMs, saying it cannot be that the Congress celebrates its win in polls held through the machines and then raises questions on their reliability when it loses.

18:10 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: Cong raises conflict of interest allegations against SEBI chief in LS, asks why govt did not act

He allTIeged it is a government "by Adani, of Adani, for Adani". P ns against the SEBI chairperson Madhabi Buch and claimed that Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman's "failure" to act decisively on it has not only tarnished the credibility of the government but also jeopardised the financial governance framework.

Attacking the government over the Adani issue during the discussion on the supplementary demands for grants in Lok Sabha, Congress MP K C Venugopal said a joint parliamentary committee must probe the entire matter.

He alleged it is a government "by Adani, of Adani, for Adani". PTI

18:07 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: Cong MPs stage protest in Parliament premises over atrocities against Hindus in Bangladesh

Several Congress MPs led by Priyanka Gandhi Vadra staged a protest in the Parliament premises on Monday, demanding justice for Hindus facing atrocities in Bangladesh and the alleged removal of a photo of Pakistan surrendering to India from the Army headquarters.

Priyanka Gandhi said she had given a notice to talk about Vijay Diwas in the Lok Sabha. The Wayanad MP claimed that after initial approval, she was allegedly told that she could not talk on it as the government would.

"Till then, they did not remember and I guess then they gave a chance to Nishikant Dubey who raised the issue and said something. Then I spoke. I was raising only two issues. First, I wanted to pay tributes to all the martyred soldiers and the people who stood by the Army," she told reporters in the Parliament premises.

"I also wanted to remember Indira Gandhi because of her ability to act decisively. Under her leadership, we fought the war and won," she said.

Priyanka Gandhi also raised the issue of atrocities against minorities in Bangladesh.

"The fight that we had fought (in 1971) was about principles, for democracy, against the atrocities that were being committed. These principles made India great. Our independence struggle was also based on these principles. We were alone at that time.

"She (Indira Gandhi) travelled across the globe, saying this atrocity must be stopped. Nobody stood up but our country did. Indira ji did, our army did and our people stood up," she said. - PTI

16:24 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: Here's what Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Priyanka Chaturvedi says on opposition's EVM tampering charge

"Even when Hemant Soren was forming govt, he said he could have won more seats if EVM was not there. Akhilesh Yadav said today that even if he wins all 80 seats (in UP), he will continue to oppose the EVM. BJP is not openly celebrating after the Maharashtra poll results, that makes it evident that people believe that the EC is not conducting free and fair elections...," says Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Priyanka Chaturvedi on Opposition's EVM tampering charge. PTI

16:22 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: Photo of Pakistan surrendering before India removed from Army HQ, says Priyanka Gandhi in LS

Congress MP Priyanka Gandhi Vadra on Monday claimed in Lok Saba that a photograph of Pakistan surrendering before India has been removed from the Army headquarters.

In her Zero Hour reference, Priyanka Gandhi said the picture has been removed on Monday, which also happens to be Vijay Diwas.

"Today, that picture has been removed from the Army headquarters where the Pakistan Army is surrendering before the Indian Army," she said.

The Wayanad MP remembered the role of soldiers and martyrs who fought the war of 1971 between India and Pakistan.

Vijay Diwas is celebrated every year on December 16 to commemorate India's victory over Pakistan in the 1971 war. The war also resulted in the liberation of Bangladesh.

16:07 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: Priyanka responds to Palestine' bag criticism

Responding to the BJP criticism of her carrying a 'Palestine' bag," Congress MP Priyanka Gandhi Vadra said, "Tell them to do something over the atrocities on Hindus in Bangladesh, talk to Bangladesh government, and not say stupid things..."

15:54 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: Those who doubt EVMs should speak to EC, says BJP leader Saumitra Khan

BJP leader Saumitra Khan seconds TMC leader Abhishek Banerjee on EVM issue, he says, "Congress thinks that EVM is not up to mark, I want to say to them that they think that EVM is alright when they win, and it is not when they lose. Abhishek Banerjee is a senior politician. It is also a big thing, who will be leading the INDIA bloc, Mamata Banerjee or Rahul Gandhi? If anybody is having a doubt on EVM, they should rather talk to the Election Commission. What Abhishek Banerjee has said is correct."

15:24 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: Here's what Azad Samaj Party MP Chandra Shekhar Azad has to say on J&K CM Omar Abdullah's comments on EVM

There have always been concerns about electronic products, and these issues will continue. Many have questioned the fairness of electronic voting machines (EVMs), with irregularities and even re-elections in some places. Machines can get damaged, replaced, or even disappear, raising doubts. The real concern is that the government should take responsibility. If BJP, RSS, and Modi Ji keep winning, they should prove the fairness of elections by conducting a ballot paper election and demonstrate that they win based on their work," Azad Samaj Party MP Chandra Shekhar Azad on J&K CM Omar Abdullah's comments on EVM.

14:36 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: Indian Constitution has stood the test of time: FM Nirmala Sitharaman in Rajya Sabha

Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, addressing the Rajya Sabha on Monday, asserted that the Constitution of India has stood the test of time in the last 75 years since it came into existence, even as over 50 countries that had their Constitution written at the same time had to change their entire features.

She began the discussion on the ‘Glorious Journey of 75 Years of the Constitution of India’ in the Rajya Sabha, by paying homage to the 389 members of the Constituent Assembly, including 15 women, who, “in less than 3 years, together, took up the arduous challenge and prepared, in a very challenging environment, the Constitution for India, which has stood the test of time.”

Marking the historic occasion, Sitharaman said, “It is time, I think, to reaffirm our commitment to build India, that is Bharat, that shall uphold the spirit enshrined in this sacred document.” Read More

14:09 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: 'Our government will implement women’s reservation more swiftly than the BJP' says Mallikarjun Kharge

Mallikarjun Kharge alleged in the Rajya Sabha on Monday that our government will implement women’s reservation more swiftly than the BJP, which opposes reservation and, for this reason, is against the caste census.

13:12 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: 'BJP is not interested in solving basic issues' says Mallikarjun Kharge

Opposition leader Mallikarjun Kharge in the Rajya Sabha, questioned the BJP's intentions, asking whether the party truly supports the Constitution. He also accused the BJP of lacking interest in solving basic issues.

12:51 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: Oppn leader Mallikarjun Kharge urges BJP to draw inspiration from Indira Gandhi on Bangladesh Liberation Day

Leader of Opposition in the Rajya Sabha, Mallikarjun Kharge, speaking in the House on Monday, remarked, “Today is the Bangladesh Liberation Day. Late Prime Minister Indira Gandhi saved our nation, she has been the Iron Lady, maybe the BJP leaders can be motivated by her to help the minorities there.”

12:36 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: 'Congress failed to introduce the GST amendment themselves' says Nirmala Sitharaman in Rajya Sabha

Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman in her debate in Rajya Sabha alleged that the Congress failed to introduce the GST amendment themselves, “and now, when we implement it, this is how they choose to shout about it."

12:24 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: 'Accusing others of lying seems ingrained in the Congress DNA' says Nirmala Sitharaman

Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman has called for a written apology from Congress MP Jairam Ramesh after he accused her of "lying," a charge she firmly denied, stating, "I never lie." She further remarked, "Accusing others of lying seems ingrained in the Congress DNA." Speaking in the Rajya Sabha, Sitharaman highlighted that Maharashtra, under Congress rule, had opposed certain provisions of the GST. "They failed to introduce the GST amendment themselves, and now, when we implement it, this is how they choose to shout about it," she said.

12:21 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: Majrooh Sultanpuri and Balraj Sahni jailed in 1949 for anti-Nehru poem, says Nirmala Sitharaman

Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, speaking in the Rajya Sabha, stated that poet Majrooh Sultanpuri and actor Balraj Sahni were both imprisoned in 1949. She explained "during one of the meetings organized for the mill workers in 1949, Majrooh Sultanpuri recited a poem that was written against Jawaharlal Nehru and therefore he had to go to jail. He refused to render an apology for the same and was jailed."

12:10 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: Opposition uproar in RS as Sitharaman initiates debate, slams Congress’s ‘disregard for constitutional processes, principles’

Initiating the debate on the Constitution in the Rajya Sabha on Monday, Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman criticised the Congress for its amendments to the Constitution, calling the process invalid and aimed at protecting those in power rather than strengthening democracy. She remarked, “The amendments were not about strengthening democracy but about protecting those in power.” She accused the Congress of using these changes to consolidate familial power and highlighted that the party had once jailed the entire opposition.

12:03 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: Nirmala Sitharaman leads debate in RS, slams Congress's 'disregard for constitutional processes, principles'

Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, during a debate on the Constitution in the Rajya Sabha on Monday, criticised the Congress for its amendments to the Constitution, calling the process invalid and aimed at protecting those in power rather than strengthening democracy. She accused Congress of using these changes to consolidate familial power and highlighted that the party had once jailed the entire opposition.

11:45 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: 'Indian Constitution has stood the test of time' says Nirmala Sitharaman

Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman initiated the debate on the Constitution in the Rajya Sabha on Monday with special recognition to its 15 women members. Highlighting the resilience of the Indian Constitution, she noted that “Post Second World War, over 50 countries had become independent and had their Constitution written. But many have changed their Constitutions, not just amended them but literally changed the entire feature of their Constitution. But our Constitution has stood the test of time, of course, yielded itself to very many amendments”

11:43 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: 'The first constitutional was brought in by the Congress to "curb the freedom of speech' says Nirmala Sitharaman

Nirmala Sitharaman on Monday in Rajya Sabha said that "within one year of the adoption of the Constitution, the first constitutional was brought in by the Congress to "curb the freedom of speech."

11:40 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: The Union Finance Minister outlined four key criteria to evaluate any amendment

Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman initiated the debate on the Constitution in the Rajya Sabha on Monday. Sitharaman outlined four key criteria to evaluate any amendment:

1. Whether the social intent behind the amendment was genuine, resulting in an equally genuine outcome.

2. Whether the economic intent and outcome of the amendment have benefited society at large.

3. The process followed in enacting the amendment.

4. The alignment of the amendment with the constitutional spirit.

11:14 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: Newly elected members begin taking oath

Both Houses resumed proceedings on Monday, with the newly elected members of the Rajya Sabha taking their oaths.

11:02 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: Bill on 'One Nation, One Election' to be Introduced in Parliament on Tuesday

A constitutional amendment bill for simultaneous Lok Sabha and state assembly elections, referred to as the Constitution (One Hundred and Twenty-Ninth Amendment) Bill, 2024, is set to be introduced in Parliament on Tuesday. Union Law Minister Arjun Ram Meghwal will introduce the bill, which is expected to be referred to a joint parliamentary committee for further consultations. The committee will be constituted based on the proportional strength of MPs from different parties, with the BJP likely to chair it. This move follows the Union Cabinet's approval of the proposal, which aims to reinstate the practice of simultaneous elections last held between 1951 and 1967. (PTI)

10:08 (IST) 16 Dec 2024

Parliament Winter Session Day 17 Live: Both Houses set to resume; Amit Shah to lead Constitution debate in Rajya Sabha

With both Houses resuming proceedings for the week, Union Home Minister Amit Shah is likely to initiate the same in the Rajya Sabha today. As per the list of business of the Upper House, there will be a “discussion on the glorious journey of the 75 years of the Constitution of India”. This follows the two-day high-octane debate that took place in the Lok Sabha last week with Congress MPs Priyanka Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi speaking from the Opposition and Prime Minister Narendra Modi concluding the discussion on behalf of the government on Saturday.

Stay updated with the latest - Click here to follow us on Instagram