Mirage movie review: Jeethu Joseph and Asif Ali test the limits of ‘how many twists are too many twists’
Mirage Movie Review & Rating: In the Asif Ali and Aparna Balamurali-starer, director Jeethu Joseph has tried to inflate a wafer-thin plot and an equally papery script by slipping in ineffectual twists very frequently.
Mirage Movie Review & Rating: Although the Asif Ali and Aparna Balamurali-starer is packed with "twists," none of them manage to take our breath away, primarily due to the unimpressive screenwriting. (Credit: Facebook/@JeethuJosephOnline)
Mirage Movie Review & Rating: Ok, guys, tell me: how many plot twists are too many plot twists? Well, if you ask director Jeethu Joseph this question, he might go all Jim Halpert (John Krasinski) and ask back, “Is there a limit?” If Jim can use “blood donation” as an excuse to dodge Michael Scott’s (Steve Carell) plans as often as he wants, then Jeethu too can drop in random twists at various junctures in his narrative, especially when the base material is almost hollow, right? Well, that’s pretty much what he has done in his crime thriller Mirage, where he has tried to inflate a wafer-thin plot and an equally papery script by slipping in twists very frequently. The only issue (or the biggest one), however, is that none of these twists quite manages to make our jaws drop. I am not even talking about Drishyam or Memories-level twists; the ones in Mirage are so dull and dreary that not a single one manages to elicit even the moderate-level excitement that the random Nayanthara cameo in Life of Josutty (2015) gave.
Following the death of her fiancé Kiran (Hakim Shahjahan) in a train accident, Abhirami (Aparna Balamurali) is left shattered. What adds to the heaviness in her chest is that the incident happened while he was on a journey somewhere without informing her, which, according to her, he has never done before. Meanwhile, Rajkumar, the owner of the company where they worked, and his henchman, Riyas, start hunting Abhirami, asking for the “hard disk”, containing sensitive information regarding the former’s wrongdoings, that they suspect Kiran gave to her. However, she asserts that she has no clue about it. With only her colleague-turned-friend Rithika (Hannah Reji Koshy) by her side, Abhirami sets out to get to the bottom of it all. Although SP Arumugham (Sampath Raj) offers them help, fearing Rajkumar, they decide against it. Meanwhile, Ashwin Kumar (Asif Ali), an online investigative journalist, also joins them, believing this would give him the exclusive story that his channel desperately needs. As they try to unravel the case, the three slowly realise they’re on quicksand, with danger lurking at every step.
You have exhausted your monthly limit of free stories.
Read more stories for free with an Express account.
“Fades as you get closer,” Mirage’s tagline says. Well, you can say, “the closer you look, the less you see” also; it’s the same. Either way, Mirage thrives on misdirection and suspense, keeping the audience in the dark until the director chooses to bring them into the light. However, what significantly affects the movie is the lack of intrigue in the script penned by Jeethu and Srinivas Abrol, based on Aparna R Tarakad’s story. Mirage is, in all honesty, packed with spoon-feeding through dialogues, and thus lack subtlety throughout.
Soon after the movie introduces its core plot, nearly every scene becomes dialogue-heavy, conveying all things verbally rather than visually. For instance, there’s a sequence early on, set at Abhirami’s house, where three conversations happen consecutively among different characters, with Abhirami being the only common link. It begins with her interaction with Rithika. Then Ashwin arrives, and they talk. After he and Rithika leave, Riyas shows up, leading to a heated exchange between them. Ashwin then reenters to speak with Abhirami before departing, leaving her to converse with Rithika, who has returned from work after learning that Riyas had come to threaten her.
Watch Mirage trailer here:
Unfortunately, the burden of conversations never truly leaves the movie, as everything is revealed through the lines delivered by various actors. The worst part is that almost all suspense reveals also occur through SP Arumugham’s dialogues, as if Jeethu was determined to invert the “show, don’t tell” technique.
Although Mirage is packed with “twists,” none of them manage to take our breath away, primarily due to the unimpressive screenwriting. The makers’ failure to elevate adept moments — both in writing and visually — and provide depth to those instances that could have enhanced the drama and tension is evident throughout. As a result, Mirage fails to capture the audience’s attention and interest, leaving viewers not care enough to whether the case is solved, let alone interested in the unravelling of the narrative’s knots. By having SP Arumugham appear sporadically and use him to dump new revelations about various characters on us — almost like a magician pulling a vanished bunny from his hat — without employing any visual storytelling techniques, Jeethu only weakens the film further. Worse still, do we even care about these suspense elements, which we weren’t even aware of before? Absolutely not.
If Arumugham’s job is to spit out secrets, Riyas’ only purpose in the movie is to walk in holding a pistol every now and then. While Rajkumar exists to look daggers at people and say, “I need that hard disk,” Rithika is the supposedly well-meaning but annoying friend. Abhirami, meanwhile, comes across as a distant cousin to Aparna Balamurali’s character, Diya, in Dhoomam (2023), with her only purpose in life being to ask others questions and make it evident that she doesn’t have any answers. Although the suspense elements in their respective arcs and the eventual revelations clarify why they had been behaving in certain ways, the lack of effort that has gone into meaningful characterisations leaves us like Guna (Samuthirakani) from Vada Chennai (2018), wondering about these flat characters, “Macha, yaaruda ivanunga? Enga irunthu vanthu irukango?”
Story continues below this ad
Although Asif Ali deserves credit for taking on a character like Ashwin, who has a chilling backstory, the fact that he’s made to simply exist in Mirage for about 140 minutes — with almost no opportunity to contribute meaningfully as an actor — until the climax makes one wonder if this was a price worth paying. Although Aparna shines in the intense moments, she too fails to soar beyond a point owing to the hollowness in Abhirami’s character. Hannah Reji Koshy, meanwhile, does some things with her face while uttering the lines, but to call that acting would be too much. Though Hakim Shahjahan is good in certain scenes, his overall performance isn’t worthy of praise.
Almost shamelessly, Jeethu uses crime against women as a plot device in Mirage as well. Here, however, it is to attempt to elevate a narrative that has already hit rock bottom by that point. Nonetheless, unlike in some of his earlier films — where stronger scripts made some viewers overlook this problematic choice — it becomes painfully clear in Mirage that the said incident was included purely for dramatic effect; with no real compassion for those who have experienced such trauma in real life.
If anything in Mirage is as poor as the writing and Jeethu’s direction, it’s Satheesh Kurup’s cinematography, marked by an overuse of weird camera angles. Vishnu Shyam’s music, while occasionally serviceable, ultimately fails to uplift the film in any meaningful way.
Mirage movie cast: Asif Ali, Aparna Balamurali, Hannah Reji Koshy, Hakim Shahjahan, Deepak Parambol Mirage movie director: Jeethu Joseph Mirage movie rating: 1.5 stars
Anandu Suresh is a Deputy Copy Editor at Indian Express Online. He specialises in Malayalam cinema, but doesn't limit himself to it and explores various aspects of the art form. He also pens a column titled Cinema Anatomy, where he delves extensively into the diverse layers and dimensions of cinema, aiming to uncover deeper meanings and foster continuous discourse. Anandu previously worked with The New Indian Express' news desk in Hyderabad, Telangana. You can follow him on Twitter @anandu_suresh_ and write (or send movie recommendations) to him at anandu.suresh@indianexpress.com. ... Read More