UPSC Essays Simplified | How to write Philosophical essays?

From last 4 weeks, we have started to devote one article to each of the dimensions of essay topics and go into the details of the themes, so that you never run out of content while writing an essay on any topic. In past we have discussed spiritual essays , temporal essays, ethical essays and psychological essays. Today, let’s talk about essays with philosophical dimensions.

Q. How are the philosophical essays of UPSC different from pure academic ones?

Essay topics in the UPSC Mains exam often require candidates to delve into deep philosophical debates. Such topics expect an aspirant to explore abstract concepts such as free will, reality, mind and matter, and the nature of existence. But how are these UPSC philosophical essays different from pure academic ones?

It is important to highlight that, unlike typical academic philosophy, these essays should resonate with a broader audience. One of the important elements of such essays is to demonstrate the ability to apply philosophical insights to real-world issues and contemporary societal challenges.

Q. So, how should an aspirant prepare for philosophical essays for UPSC?

Let’s answer this question in ways using the methods we have adopted in our previous article. Analysing previous year’s questions and relevant content ideas will help. To begin with, here are some key philosophical themes that frequently appear in UPSC essay topics, along with content ideas to help you develop well-rounded responses.

Key themes and Content ideas

1. Free Will vs. Determinism

Example Topic: “Freedom of Will is a Mirage: Discuss in the Context of Social and Political Realities.”

Content Ideas:

• Conceptual Clarity: Begin by defining free will and determinism. Free will suggests that individuals have the autonomy to make their own choices, while determinism argues that all events, including human actions, are determined by preceding causes.
• Philosophical Debate: Reference classical debates, such as those between philosophers like Immanuel Kant, who supported free will, and Baruch Spinoza, who leaned towards determinism.
• Real-World Application: Discuss how free will can be a myth in the context of societal structures, such as caste, class, and economic constraints, which heavily influence individual choices in India. Analyze how laws and policies attempt to balance free will with societal norms.
• Contemporary Relevance: Relate this debate to current issues, such as the debate over privacy and surveillance, where the freedom to choose is increasingly under threat.

2. The Nature of Reality

Example Topic: “Reality is Merely an Illusion: Critically Analyze the Statement.”

Content Ideas:

• Philosophical Foundations: Introduce the concept of reality from both Eastern and Western perspectives. Discuss the idea of “Maya” in Indian philosophy, which considers the physical world as an illusion, and contrast it with the Western materialist view.
• Philosophy and Science: Explore how quantum physics has challenged classical notions of reality, with concepts like the observer effect and superposition suggesting that reality is not as concrete as it seems.
• Practical Implications: Reflect on how the perception of reality shapes social behavior and policy-making. Discuss how media, propaganda, and digital technology can manipulate perceptions of reality, influencing public opinion and political decisions.
• Example: Refer to Plato’s Allegory of the Cave, where prisoners perceive shadows on the wall as reality, drawing parallels with how media can shape our perception of the world.

3. Mind vs. Matter

Example Topic: “Mind Over Matter: A Philosophical Exploration of Consciousness and Materialism.”

Content Ideas:

• Dualism vs. Materialism: Start by explaining the philosophical debate between dualism (the belief that mind and body are separate) and materialism (the belief that only physical matter exists). Reference thinkers like René Descartes (dualism) and Thomas Hobbes (materialism).
• Contemporary Relevance: Discuss how this debate influences modern issues like mental health, artificial intelligence, and neuroscience. For instance, how does understanding consciousness impact the development of AI? How do materialist approaches affect our healthcare systems?
• Case Study: Use examples from Indian philosophy, such as the Sankhya school, which posits a dualistic interpretation of existence, contrasting it with contemporary neuroscientific views that see consciousness as a product of brain activity.
• Current Issues: Consider the implications of this debate in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic, where mental health issues have taken center stage, challenging the traditional materialist focus on physical health alone.

4. The Paradox of Freedom and Authority

Example Topic: “Absolute Freedom is a Myth: Analyze the Role of Authority in Shaping Societal Norms.”

Content Ideas:

• Philosophical Foundations: Discuss the balance between individual freedom and societal authority. Reference social contract theories, particularly those of Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau, which explore the origins and limits of authority in society.
• Practical Applications: Analyze how this balance plays out in democratic societies, especially in India, where the Constitution guarantees fundamental rights, but also imposes reasonable restrictions in the interest of public order, morality, and national security.
• Case Studies: Examine contemporary debates on freedom of expression versus national security, particularly in the context of the internet and social media regulation.
• Examples: Consider the ongoing debate over freedom of speech in India, such as the challenges posed by sedition laws and the right to dissent.

5. The Search for Meaning and Purpose

Example Topic: “The Pursuit of Happiness: Is It a Fundamental Human Right or a Social Construct?”

Content Ideas:

• Philosophical Perspectives: Explore the concept of happiness through the lenses of different philosophies. Discuss Aristotle’s idea of eudaimonia (flourishing), the hedonistic approach, and the Buddhist concept of nirvana as the cessation of suffering.
• Contemporary Relevance: Analyze how the pursuit of happiness is framed in modern society—whether through consumerism, personal success, or social relationships. How do government policies, like the Gross National Happiness Index in Bhutan, attempt to measure and promote happiness?
• Ethical Considerations: Reflect on the ethical implications of pursuing happiness at the expense of others, and the role of social structures in defining what happiness means in different cultural contexts.
• Example: Refer to the UN’s World Happiness Report and discuss how different countries interpret and prioritize happiness, contrasting it with the Indian context.

Q. The other important aspect of writing a good essay is its structure. An aspirant may find it not very easy to structure philosophical essays…

To effectively tackle philosophical essay topics in UPSC Mains, it’s essential to maintain a clear and coherent structure:

1. Introduction:

Begin with a thought-provoking statement or question related to the topic. Briefly outline the philosophical concepts involved and their relevance to contemporary issues.

2. Main Body:

Philosophical Insights: Discuss the key philosophical ideas relevant to the topic. Incorporate both Indian and Western perspectives where applicable.

Real-World Applications: Illustrate how these philosophical ideas manifest in current societal, political, or ethical issues. Use relevant examples, case studies, and data to support your arguments.

Critical Analysis: Engage critically with the topic, evaluating different viewpoints and acknowledging the complexities involved.

3. Conclusion:

Summarise the key points discussed and reflect on the broader implications of the philosophical debate.

End with a statement that ties the philosophical insights back to the practical challenges facing society today, suggesting potential paths forward.

Q. Since philosophical essays have become very frequent in UPSC, what would you suggest to aspirants?

Preparing for philosophical essay topics in the UPSC Mains requires a balanced approach. An aspirant must combine a solid understanding of philosophical concepts with the ability to apply these ideas to real-world issues.

Remember, the key to success in these essays lies in demonstrating how abstract philosophical ideas can illuminate and inform the practical issues we face in everyday life.

Subscribe to our UPSC newsletter and stay updated with the news cues from the past week.

The UPSC articles of Indian Express is now on Telegram. Join our Telegram channel- Indian Express UPSC Hub and stay updated with the latest Updates.

For your answers, queries and suggestions write at manas.srivastava@indianexpress.com.