Journalism of Courage
Premium

We can’t prevent Parliament from passing a bill: SC

The SC has refused to entertain a PIL challenging the reported move to withdraw certain benefits,like commission,to 30 lakh LIC agents in the country.

Advertisement

Maintaining that it cannot pass any direction to Parliament on a pending bill,the Supreme Court on Friday refused to entertain a PIL challenging the reported move to withdraw certain benefits,like commission,to 30 lakh LIC agents in the country.

“You are challenging a Bill? How can you challenge a Bill? You cannot file this type of petition. We will ask you to pay cost. How can we say Parliament should not pass the Bill,” a bench headed by the Chief Justice K G Balakrishnan,Justices B S Chauhan and K S Radhakrishna,fumed at the counsel.

The apex court said it was “rubbish” that a responsible organisation had chosen to file the PIL and threatened to impose cost,upon which the counsel Chava Badrinath Babu withdrew the petition.

The PIL filed by Rajhamundry Division Council of LIC agents Association had urged the apex court to quash two bills — Insurance Laws (Amendment) Bill,2008 and the Life Insurance Corporation (Amendment) Bill,2009.

According to the petitioner,the first bill has proposed to withdraw the commission benefits enjoyed by 30 lakh-odd insurance agents and instead put the onus on the agents to collect fees from the policy holders.

The petition claimed that if the bill is passed,it would sound the death knell for the insurance agents and their families as no policy holder would come forward to insure by paying fees to the agents.

Besides,it said that commission enjoyed by the agents was a major source of their livelihood,most of whom are otherwise unemployed,self-employed persons and coming from poor and rural backgrounds.

Story continues below this ad

The counsel submitted that the bill also proposed to eliminate the “earned renewable commission,and hereditary renewable commission,” presently enjoyed by the agents.

The other bill – Life Insurance Corporation (LIC) Amendment Bill 2009 – seeks to withdraw the “sovereign guarantee” offered by the Government to the policy holders,the petition alleged.

However,the apex court was not impressed with the argument of the petition and rejected it.

Stay updated with the latest - Click here to follow us on Instagram

Tags:
  • LIC supreme court
Edition
Install the Express App for
a better experience
Featured
Trending Topics
News
Multimedia
Follow Us
Express ExclusiveAIIMS study: 6 in 10 top Indian doctors not trained to certify brain death, hurting organ donation
X