Updated: March 22, 2021 2:43:13 pm
The Left parties in Tamil Nadu, the CPI and the CPM, were shocked when they drew a blank in the 2016 Assembly polls in the state. Together they got around 1.5 per cent of the vote in an alliance led by Vijayakanth’s DMDK – which, on paper, looked like a formidable alliance.
However, given the polarisation of voters between the two dominant fronts in the state, the DMK and the AIADMK, the DMDK led third front collapsed. From 1957 to 2016, the Left has always had their members in the assembly.
The 2016 Assembly poll debacle of the Left parties came about when they failed to find a place in either the DMK or the AIADMK alliance. Emboldened by the 2014 parliamentary poll performance in Tamil Nadu, J Jayalalithaa wanted to contest most of the Assembly seats, and there was no place for the Left. With the DMK, however, they had been opposing the party during the UPA regime and it was not time yet for a rapprochement.
The 2016 Assembly poll was also a landmark election in the state for smaller parties like the Left. Given the growing polarisation of the voters between the DMK and the AIADMK, smaller parties had nowhere to go, and faced political extinction without being part of the dominant alliances. Secondly, electioneering has become so expensive that smaller parties had literally no skin in the game.
Thirdly, 2016 proved that smaller parties like the Left parties with a committed vote base could not hold on to their voters if they were not part of a dominant or winning alliance. Also, they were not able to transfer votes to other parties in the third front. And when they contested as part of a third front, they lacked credibility and were considered unviable from the word go. Their relevance depended on them being part of any one of the dominant alliances.
This is surprising enough because Left leaders like Nallakannu are considered as role models for probity in public life in Tamil Nadu and Left legislators have a good track record of being responsive to needs of the constituencies.
This time in the 2021 assembly polls, they have been given six seats each in the DMK alliance, which they accepted after much heartburn. Even in 2011 and 2006, they contested around 22 seats in leading alliances. When the conditions are favourable to their alliance both of them together win around five per cent of the popular vote. The united Communist Party of India during the 1957 and 1962 polls got around 7.5 per cent of the popular vote.
The Left, CPI and CPM mostly travel together in Tamil Nadu, and were in the same front together during 2016, 2011, 2006 and 2001 Assembly polls. However, they keep changing their loyalties between the DMK and the AIADMK. While in 2016, they were in the Vijaykanth led alliance, in 2011 they were with the Jayalalitha-led AIADMK alliance and in 2006 were with the DMK alliance, and in 2001 Assembly polls they were with the AIADMK alliance.
They only take care not to be seen in an alliance with the BJP, and naturally gravitate towards a non-BJP front. They are comfortable aligning with either the DMK or AIADMK.
It is not that they have always been together. The last time they parted ways was in 1996 when the CPI was in the DMK alliance and the CPM tried its luck in the Vaiko-led MDMK alliance. In 1989, CPI was in the alliance led by the Jayalalitha faction of the AIADMK while the CPM was in the DMK front.
Such repeated oscillation between the Dravidian parties has led to Left parties losing their sheen, and a slow decline in their political influence and clout.
While in 2016, they drew a blank, they together won 19 seats in 2011, 15 seats in 2006 and 11 seats in 2001. Their most impressive performance in number of seats won, was in 1980 when as part of the MGR-led AIADMK alliance they won around 20 seats.
Over a period of time, the Left in Tamil Nadu has adjusted itself to the realities of Dravidian politics. Now, their influence is restricted to four parliamentary constituencies in the state, in Kanyakumari district, in Nagapattinam and Thanjavur districts, some parts of Coimbatore district and some pockets in cities like Tiruchirapalli, north Chennai and Madurai. They have a presence in urban unionised workers, peasants and agricultural labourers in Thanjavur and Nagapattinam regions and in Kanyakumari district.
The Left parties have certain uses for the Dravidian parties, apart from the votes they bring into the alliance. They have some sheen of respectability, and are known in Tamil Nadu for a certain amount of political integrity. Their legislators have not had allegations of corruption against them and their MLAs are not known to throw their weight around in local communities. Dravidian parties see them as the most useful and the least harmless of all allies.
They also add value to an alliance by converting themselves as the ideological spearhead of whichever alliance they are in, providing the ideological climate and halo for the political battle. It could be anti-corruption at one time, fight against highhandedness another time, or anti-communalism as the case might be.
While the 2016 Assembly polls saw them draw a blank, and 2021 is when they are contesting the lowest number of seats for the state assembly, it shows a sure and steady decline of their influence and relevance in electoral politics in the state.
📣 The Indian Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel (@indianexpress) and stay updated with the latest headlines
- The Indian Express website has been rated GREEN for its credibility and trustworthiness by Newsguard, a global service that rates news sources for their journalistic standards.