September 11, 2020 6:04:54 pm
A Delhi-based rapper has alleged that this year’s Indian Premier League (IPL) anthem ‘Aayenge Hum Wapas’ has been copied from his track, an allegation that has been dismissed by the composer of the recently released song.
Rapper Krishna Kaul aka KRSNA claims the track has been lifted from his song “Dekh Kaun Aaya Waapas” but composer Pranav Ajayrao Malpe said it is his original work and he even has a certificate from Music Composers Association of India (MCAI).
My song “Dekh Kaun Aaya Wapas” has been plagiarised by @DisneyPlusHS @Hotstarusa to make this years @IPL anthem “Aayenge Hum Wapas” without my consent or credit. #iplanthemcopied For context, here is a comparison video: https://t.co/FUDf2Xse4Q pic.twitter.com/tHZveSGOec
— KR$NA (@realkrsna) September 9, 2020
KRSNA told PTI that his team, including the independent hip-hop label Kalamkaar, will take the legal route and approach Disney+Hotstar, which commissioned the song.
“Disney+Hotstar have left no option for us but to seek legal recourse and our label is going to fight this unfair and scandalous plagiarisation,” KRSNA said.
Malpe said four MCAI panelists, including musician Leslee Lewis, independently assessed both the songs and did not find any similarity.
“MCAI is an institution of repute and the experts on the panel have a lot of experience. I feel we should respect the experts’ views and put this debate to rest,” Malpe told PTI.
The composer said the thought behind the track, released on September 6, was to express the struggle everyone was going through during the pandemic “and to give them hope of a comeback.”
“Nagpur has a small but budding hip-hop and rap scene which I’m a part of. I’m proud that this track has been liked and that I’ve been able to put a spotlight on the Nagpur hip-hop scene,” he added.
A company that sues anyone at the drop of a hat for anything that resembles MickeyMouse ears @DisneyPlusHS has no qualms producing a plagiarised version of my song for the @IPL. Double standards? Disrespect to Indian artists? #IplAnthemCopied #DisneyDisrespectsIndianArtists https://t.co/DbYrrPqkYI pic.twitter.com/Kd3ANMjN7t
— KR$NA (@realkrsna) September 10, 2020
IPL 2020 will be held in the UAE from September 19 to November 10.
In its assessment, the MCAI said other than being of the same genre, the two songs have no similarity melodically, harmonically or rhythmically.
“A genre or rap style however is not copyrightable and doesn’t constitute plagiarisation. Hence the panel is of the opinion that there exists substantial difference between the compositions of both the tracks,” the statement from MCAI read.
KRSNA, however, said MCAI has no legal standing in the matter and has shown a “shocking lack of understanding” of the genre.
“The MCAI statement is a serious attack on musicians and composers everywhere because their claim that a genre like hip hop cannot be differentiated means everyone is free to copy everybody else – hook, line and sinker,” he claimed.
📣 The Indian Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel (@indianexpress) and stay updated with the latest headlines
- The Indian Express website has been rated GREEN for its credibility and trustworthiness by Newsguard, a global service that rates news sources for their journalistic standards.