Follow Us:
Saturday, April 04, 2020

Watch: Debate rages as bowler gives Mankad warning in tense finish

England's Katherine Brunt opted not to run out South Africa's Sune Luus at the non-striker's end during a tense finish to the Women's T20 World Cup league match, before South Africa claimed an upset win over England.

By: Sports Desk | Updated: February 25, 2020 11:02:00 am
Katherine Brunt gives Sune Luus a Mankad warning in the tense final moments of the Women’s T20 World Cup match on Monday (Screengrab)

England’s Katherine Brunt opted not to Mankad South Africa’s Sune Luus during a tense finish to the Women’s T20 World Cup league match on Monday, creating a debate on social media.

Brunt decided to give the non-striker a warning to stay inside her crease instead of running her out with 7 needed off 4 balls, moments before Mignon du Preez hit a six and a four off the following two deliveries to seal a 124-run chase and pull off an upset win for South Africa.

The ‘Mankad’ is a legitimate dismissal under cricket’s laws, and a bowler is not required to give a batsman a warning before attempting it. But it is seen by some as against the spirit of cricket, and even ICC’s Twitter handle quoted the video of the incident with a caption: “What do you think?”

Brunt had herself received a Mankad warning in the England innings. In the 17th over of the first innings, South Africa’s Ayabonga Khaka pulled out of her delivery stride when Brunt was backing up at the non-striker’s end.

READ | Poonam Yadav heroics inspire India to decimate Australia

“I think it was Brunt that got one herself – a warning when she was batting, backing up. Nothing wrong with that at all,” commentator Nasser Hussain said. Meanwhile, a few cricketers featuring in the T20 World Cup also joined the Mankad debate post the incident.

“She was never going to run her out, a bit of drama, isn’t it? I know that none of our team would ever do that. It’s just part of the game, isn’t it?” asked Nat Sciver

“Ayabonga Khaka did exactly the same while Katherine Brunt was batting, fair play from both teams,” said South Africa’s Marizanne Kapp.

“Personally, I wouldn’t do that. I would probably give the batter a warning. Even then if the batter does it, then I’ll think about it, but I wouldn’t do it,” said Shikha Pandey of India.

“If batters are going a little bit early, it’s not fair. So that is the rule in cricket. So we can take that opportunity. So we can tell one time don’t go, like that, so don’t play unfair. If she plays unfair, we can get a wicket,” felt Chamari Atapattu.

Given the circumstances of Brunt’s decision not to Mankad, there have been fierce opinions from across the ‘spirit of cricket’ divide.

The victory was South Africa’s maiden T20 World Cup win against England.

📣 The Indian Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel (@indianexpress) and stay updated with the latest headlines

For all the latest Sports News, download Indian Express App.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement