Updated: June 13, 2019 11:01:26 am
KL Rahul at No.4 had looked too good a tenant, settling in without fuss, subletting it to Hardik Pandya and even making dashing three-ball cameos when pushed down the order. With his performance, he had mocked all the sweat, fret, and ether-mumblings on social media. It almost felt a bit of anti-climax.
However, with Rahul about to take the injured opener Shikhar Dhawan’s slot at the top, the No.4 question is staring at Indian cricket again. Will it be Ambati Rayudu’s 3-D glass provider Vijay Shankar? Or would they turn to Dinesh Kartik or Kedar Jadav? But one gets the sense that it might be either MS Dhoni or Pandya, depending on how well the top three do their jobs and the match situation.
In the end, No. 4 could be the greatest trick India has pulled off this tournament. The lack of a specialist at the spot gives Dhoni the luxury of time in the middle, allowing him to manoeuvre the middle overs, something he likes doing. Not long ago, Rohit Sharma had spoken about Dhoni being his ideal No.4. The only thing going against it, ironically, is Dhoni’s IPL form. He biffed the bowlers, enough to perhaps make the team-management think that he could still be the big-hitting finisher and can be sent later. It’s still worth, though, trying him at No.4 for a game to see how he goes. By the look of things, India might well use him at No,4 occasionally, depending on match situation – and that perhaps isn’t a bad way to go about it.
While Dhawan’s absence might not be as big a disaster as feared, it can throw up a few interesting side-effects on the line-up. Not just the pressure on the top 3 to score consistently but also perhaps on the way they bat. Until they find some confidence in the middle order, Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma might not attempt to break free in the middle overs.
A washout will harm India more than Kiwis
Pandya took off that pressure from Kohli in the last game against Australia, allowing him to bat on with a steady and consistent tempo. He didn’t have to shift gears at all. Kohli did admit later that there was temptation to go for it, try to accelerate, but he resisted the urge after watching Pandya go. Also, when Pandya suggested that he likes batting with Kohli holding one end up. It allowed Pandya to do his thing. But the last game was almost the ideal game for India – the wickets didn’t fall, Pandya soared, and Dhoni flexed his muscles – and Kohli could do his thing.
India will have to choose their No 4 wisely to ensure that the one of the top three who is the set batsman by then, doesn’t feel inhibited and forced to slow down. The other extreme too isn’t ideal where they are forced to accelerate when they don’t yet want to. Considering all this, it won’t be a surprise if India go with either established players already in the team at No.4 instead of trying out Vijay Shankar there.
But all this hand-wringing is unnecessary when you speak to non-India fans. There is such an overwhelming feeling in England, Australia, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka fans sprinkled across this country that India are so dominant — they say they laugh at the Indian fans and media’s obsession with No. 4. In some ways, even more than the parochial Indian fans, there is more respect and admiration in the others.
A washed-out game against New Zealand though won’t help India. Not because of the points accrued, but they would prefer the match practice to fine-tune their new batting order. It allows them to see what Dhoni does at No. 4 if India lose a couple of wickets for not too many and need consolidation. 100/2, say, when batting first. Would he, as some fear, bat too slow at the start? There is not much empirical evidence of it, yet, as he hasn’t batted at No 4 in the recent times and it’s better to find out now, at this stage in the tournament, than later.
The Indian players couldn’t hold a proper net session at Nottingham, a day ahead of the game. It drizzled, not too heavy but enough to make them discard any attempt at bowling. The batsmen faced knockdowns, with the net bowlers standing and throwing the ball them. The weather remains a threat on match day. New Zealand have a pretty good bowling attack with the left-handed Trent Boult as its leader and Ferguson who can crank up the pace. And in Mitchell Santner they have a pretty decent left-arm spinner who can peg away steadily. India will be New Zealand’s first big test in the tournament. They did have a few tight moments against Bangladesh but Kane Williamson and Ross Taylor, their main batsmen, have helped them get three straight wins. They would fight hard but India should win this.
📣 The Indian Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel (@indianexpress) and stay updated with the latest headlines
- The Indian Express website has been rated GREEN for its credibility and trustworthiness by Newsguard, a global service that rates news sources for their journalistic standards.