Is breaking An Se-young’s zonal-defense, the silver bullet for PV Sindhu?

Till 17-19 in the first set of her 21-17, 21-14 loss at Singapore Open, Sindhu attacked Se-young's rear corner backhand like a guided missile. 11 of her 17 winners came from there.

It would be foolhardy to think that Sindhu is getting closer to beating Se-young, or that there's a serious resurgence. (BAI/Badminton Photo)It would be foolhardy to think that Sindhu is getting closer to beating Se-young, or that there's a serious resurgence. (BAI/Badminton Photo)

An Se-young, the Olympic champion, the most dominant women’s singles shuttler of this era, is credited with wiping out the golden generation that came together circa 2013. PV Sindhu was just one amongst 8 top names that the Korean 24-year-old flicked out of the nucleus of greatness, like a carrom striker. Sindhu has now won just the solitary set against the win-machine, and the head-to-head reached 0-9 after Friday’s loss for the Indian at the Super 750 Singapore Open.

Sindhu, or for that matter anybody else, is not winning any title unless they go past Se-young. The Korean has lost only one match – the All England final – against Wang Zhi Yi in 2026. And the 21-17, 21-14 scoreline will gather dust in the archives of Se-young’s supreme dominance. Except, for 20-odd minutes, Sindhu had Se-young under the pump. And the way Se-young celebrated the win after 48 minutes and grimaced through the first set, pointed to a vulnerability that a sturdier Sindhu could’ve once exposed to turn the knife in.

It would be foolhardy to think that Sindhu is getting closer to beating Se-young, or that there’s a serious resurgence, vis-a-vis winning titles, even as she enters Top 10 again. But with Indonesian Irwansyah arming her with necessary tools, Sindhu has a blueprint to push the Korean.

The 21-17 first set scoreline can be broken down into phases – the good, the (good sort of) ugly and the rank bad, where Sindhu couldn’t push for a win.

It’s the early part – 7-11 that held pointers for a future plotting which ranks as good, the 13-14 to 16-18 part that is ugly but on a good way, and then the implosion to 17-21 where Sindhu was far from good enough, and unraveled that counts as the bad or poor phase. The second set loss was inevitable thereafter.

The smart ploy involves breaking down Se-young’s zone defense. It’s unclear if it’s a hangover of a past injury or more likely, Sindhu really acing the precision attack, but the Indian targeted a particular zone through the first set: Se-young’s backhand sideline. The Korean was reluctant to go across her body and pick the flank shots. Were the badminton half-court to be divided into four corner rectangles, it was the rear backhand block where Sindhu wreaked maximum damage.

Till 17-19, Sindhu had 7 down the line straight smashes to that zone, all unretrieved smashes, all winners. These came from stick smashes and even round the head straights, that Sindhu’s tall power enable. What’s more, three other crosscourts were also pinged to the same zone, which would require Se-young to play the torso-contorting imbalanced backhand — the reluctance for which saw the Korean World No 1 bleed nearly 60 percent of her points. A flick after a fast exchange and a cross hit after a 40+ shot rally, both flashed on the same zonal radar, making it 11 of her 17 points scored breaking Se-young’s renowned defense.

ALSO READ | Why HS Prannoy looked at the roof during his loss to Loh Kean Yew

Story continues below this ad

There’s myriad ways to beat Sindhu, and Se-young used the simplest ones. Making her twist and turn on both flanks, testing her reduced agility. And with Korean coaches continually telling her to keep the shuttle down, and make the tall Sindhu bend.

But at 17-19, Sindhu gave yet another display of why she has slipped from the top bracket, where merely making Top 10 becomes cause for celebration for someone who’s played 3 World Championships finals. It could’ve been 18-19 – and then, who knows? – had Sindhu sent the easiest of cutaway smashes within lines, because once again, it was in that zone and Se-young was on the other side of the court. But Sindhu sprayed it wide. 17-20.

Post that it was clear lack of belief as she sent a clear loose and long, when precision was demanded.

Having beaten World No 5 Putri Kusuma Wardini, if Sindhu reckoned the job was done for this week, then the ambition needs levelling up. The second set started 0-6, stuttered to 7-11 and was finished 14-21, with no sign of a fightback.

Story continues below this ad

An Se-young offers very few chances. And Sindhu might be one of the few contemporary players who can use her power, speed and general drive to prove a point, to get that ASY-win. Irwansyah was on point when he said Se-young would have to be beaten at some point to win a title. There was no way around it. At age 30 with her fitness, that is likelier to happen early in a tournament – in first 3 days – than in semis or finals.

It’s why Sindhu should look forward to playing An Se-young early in the week, for she has the means to set fire to one quarter zone of Se-young’s defensive reach. Though her endgame lacks belief and finishing is shoddy, Sindhu has the power game to annoy the Korean.

Shivani Naik is a senior sports journalist and Assistant Editor at The Indian Express. She is widely considered one of the leading voices in Indian Olympic sports journalism, particularly known for her deep expertise in badminton, wrestling, and basketball. Professional Profile Role: Assistant Editor and Columnist at The Indian Express. Specialization: While she covers a variety of sports, she is the primary authority on badminton for the publication. She also writes extensively about tennis, track and field, wrestling, and gymnastics. Writing Style: Her work is characterized by "technical storytelling"—breaking down the biomechanics, tactics, and psychological grit of athletes. She often provides "long reads" that explore the personal journeys of athletes beyond the podium. Key Topics & Recent Coverage (Late 2025) Shivani Naik’s recent articles (as of December 2025) focus on the evolving landscape of Indian sports as athletes prepare for the 2026 Asian Games and beyond: Indian Badminton's "Hulks": She has recently written about a new generation of Indian shuttlers characterized by power and physicality, such as Ayush Shetty and Sathish Karunakaran, marking a shift from the traditionally finesse-based Indian style. PV Sindhu’s Resurgence: A significant portion of her late-2025 work tracks PV Sindhu’s tactical shifts under new coaching, focusing on her "sparkle" and technical tweaks to break out of career slumps. The "Group of Death": In December 2025, she provided detailed tactical previews for Satwiksairaj Rankireddy and Chirag Shetty’s campaign in the BWF World Tour Finals. Tactical Deep Dives: She frequently explores technical trends, such as the rise of "backhand deception" in modern badminton and the importance of court drift management in international arenas. Legacy and History: She often revisits the careers of legends like Saina Nehwal and Syed Modi, providing historical context to current Indian successes. Notable Recent Articles BWF World Tour Finals: Satwik-Chirag have it all to do to get through proverbial Group of Death. (Dec 2025) The age of Hulks in Indian badminton is here. (Dec 2025) Treadmill, Yoganidra and building endurance: The themes that defined the resurgence of Gayatri and Treesa. (Dec 2025) Ayush Shetty beats Kodai Naraoka: Will 20-year-old be the headline act in 2026? (Nov 2025) Modern Cinderella tale – featuring An Se-young and a shoe that fits snugly. (Nov 2025) Other Sports Interests Beyond the court, Shivani is a passionate follower of South African cricket, sometimes writing emotional columns about her irrational support for the Proteas, which started because of love for Graeme Smith's dour and doughty Test playing style despite being a left-hander, and sustained over curiosity over their heartbreaking habit of losing ICC knockouts. You can follow her detailed analysis and columns on her official Indian Express profile page. ... Read More

 

Advertisement
Loading Recommendations...
Advertisement
Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments