Hours after The Indian Express investigation on the conflict within the Election Commission raised a political storm, Leader of the Opposition in Lok Sabha, Rahul Gandhi, accused the ruling BJP and the poll panel of treason.
An investigation by The Indian Express has found that critical questions over the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of voter lists were raised from within the three-member Election Commission.
Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi formally objected, on record, at least 14 times over the past 10 months to decisions taken by the poll panel, the investigation found.
Reacting to the scoop, the Congress said Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar was running the poll panel at his whim. “We have been saying – Modi has captured the Election Commission. Gyanesh Kumar is Modi’s puppet,” the Congress said on X, levelling serious accusations against the poll panel chief and the Prime Minister.
The Congress, led by Gandhi, has been running a ‘vote chori’ campaign against the Election Commission, accusing it of large-scale poll irregularities and working in cahoots with the ruling BJP. The poll panel and the ruling party have rubbished these allegations.
Gandhi has earlier addressed press conferences and claimed irregularities in voter lists.
Story continues below this ad
He has also accused the Election Commission of working against the Opposition parties, most recently when the poll panel froze the name and symbol of the Mamata Banerjee-led Trinamool Congress.
In fact, the Congress is now likely to launch a two-pronged attack on the government, plugging in the ‘vote chori’ charge alongside Gandhi’s Chhatron ki Goonj campaign to mobilise support among students and youngsters in the aftermath of paper leaks.
‘Chief Election Commissioner an internal bulldozer’
In a press meet in the national capital, Congress leader Singhvi said the issue highlighted in the Express investigation is “extremely serious”.
“It can be fatal for ours and any democracy. It is an example of double bulldozer government where there is an external bulldozer… which assaults all major institutions of India… Apart from that external bulldozer, we have an internal bulldozer – the CEC, which has bulldozed his own organisation, his colleagues… He runs it like a feudal lord not answerable to any authority.”
Story continues below this ad
“The BJP has opened an office for the murder of democracy. On one end, they have posted the CEC, and on the other hand, is the Home Ministry. I will establish this theme. This is a serious matter and is fatal for our republic.
“I will start from the report in The Indian Express, which is a widely known newspaper. I want to congratulate it. It shows journalism of courage and also of analysis and research. It is a lesson for godi media’s sections. It is a peak showing that if you have been given the category of the fourth pillar of democracy, then how you can deliver,” said Singhvi.
“The first point: many years ago in 1995, the Supreme Court had made it clear that the ECI is a majority body. You would remember that during TN Seshan’s tenure, this legal question was raised. That the CEC is the top authority. The ECs don’t have equal power or status. This question was answered that all ECs are equal, that the CEC is not higher and is just first among equals.”
“Today’s revelation shows that the CEC not just misled the country, but also misled his colleagues. He hijacked the ECI, and made the ECs not serve in the ECI. He hijacked his ECs. This is the example of the internal bulldozer. This is disgusting for a Constitutional body,” the Rajya Sabha member said.
Targeting Gyanesh Kumar, Singhvi said he has no right to continue in his position. The Congress MP said the party demands that all these dissent notes should be shared with the country. “Don’t tell us we should seek them in RTIs. We know what will happen,” said Singhvi.
Story continues below this ad
‘If elections are unfair…’: Priyanka Gandhi’s warning
Wayanad MP and Congress leader Priyanka Gandhi, too, said a treason had been committed.
She said, “This is an extremely serious issue for our democracy. If there are no elections, then where is democracy? If elections are unfair and rigged in any manner, then the Election Commission is assisting in that. If the Election Commissioner is not only aware of it but also allowing it to happen, then it is a very serious assault on democracy. It is an act of treason.”
She called for a free and fair official investigation into the matter by an independent body. She said the official investigation must be made transparent to the entire country.
Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge said the government was taking over India’s democracy and its institutions and questions are being raised about their independence and impartiality.
“For several years now, the Congress Party and many opposition parties have been raising questions about the fairness of elections held in the country. We have consistently viewed the role of the Election Commission with suspicion. When we raised questions, they were dismissed as a joke. The doors of the Commission were shut,” Kharge alleged in a post on X.
‘Illegal, unauthorised’: Election Commissioners objected to Form 6 change
The section itself was not marked mandatory, but applicants could not proceed to submit the form without answering it.
Read the full story →
What Election Commission rift reveals: Cloud over its conduct
There has been dissent within the Election Commission earlier but this one is very different.
Read the full story →
'ECs knocked on Cabinet Secretary’s door over voter software integrity
Over ten months, from November to August, the two Commissioners said so repeatedly and in writing
Read the full story →
14 times in 10 months, two Election Commissioners objected on record to poll panel steps
From keeping them in the dark to adding new voters, deleting names, ECs Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi flagged "unauthorised, illegal" moves.
Read the full story →