Full access at just Rs 3/day

Journalism of Courage

Election Result LIVE


Steady, soft, firm: Why BJP is standing by Bhupendra Patel for CM if it wins Gujarat

State chief C R Paatil's statement saying so follows a year where the first-time MLA and surprise CM choice has kept BJP ship steady, made few mistakes, avoided rows

Gujarat Chief Minister Bhupendra Patel. (File)

At an event hosted by channel TV9 on Saturday, BJP state chief C R Paatil said that Bhupendra Patel will remain the Chief Minister should the party come back to power in Gujarat and that Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Union Minister for Home Amit Shah will decide “all” the tickets for the coming Assembly elections in the state.

While the reshuffle of the entire Vijay Rupani Cabinet last year was a surprise, and the choice of Patel to replace him as CM even more so, BJP sources said Paatil’s statement was not unexpected. Having taken over on September 13 last year, Patel has managed to remain away from the spotlight, shun controversy and, largely, get the work done – in other words, prove the man the party wanted him to be in the run-up to the elections.

After 24 years of uninterrupted BJP governments in Gujarat, 12 of which had Modi as CM, there is “a system in place”, say party leaders, for appointing CMs and running governments in the state, suggesting that Patel had to do little except not make mistakes. With the theme of the BJP campaign in states lately being “double engine ki sarkar”, the promise to voters anyway is development powered right from the top, at the Centre, should they choose a BJP government.

“What did he (Patel) have to do anyway, except maintain the status quo?” said a BJP leader, adding that the first-time MLA from Ghatlodia in Ahmedabad, thrust into the CM post, had done that appreciatively.

Subscriber Only Stories

A Kadva Patidar like Patel, the leader pointed out that Rupani, brought in mid-term as a replacement for Anandiben Patel, had been retained as CM too when the BJP came back to power in 2017.

However, the fact also is that the BJP does not want to shake up things too much, with elections so near. Party leaders admit that while the Rupani change was smooth, there were several ruffled feathers. A leader said the BJP high command “would like to give a semblance of stability” by repeating Patel.

Incidentally, before Paatil’s statement of faith in Patel, Rupani was moved out the way, getting an assignment after a year of waiting which will see him away from Gujarat as in-charge of faraway Punjab and Chandigarh. Just days before Paatil’s TV9 interaction, Rupani had told The Indian Express in an interview that he didn’t know till the night before that he was going to be dropped, and that he thought he had fulfilled most, if not all, the goals required of him as CM.


Patel’s year long tenure has not been devoid of crises, including floods, with parts of Saurashtra going under water. The government has had to retract a controversial stray cattle control Bill following protests, been questioned over a hooch tragedy that left 42 dead in the dry state, seen a haul of 3,000 kg heroin at the Mundra port that has been mired in controversy, faced agitations by government employees, and encountered blowback over remission of life sentences of 11 convicts in the 2002 Bilkis Bano gangrape case.

More recently, two of Patel’s cabinet ministers, Rajendra Trivedi and Purnesh Modi, were stripped of their key portfolios following complaints of “inefficiency”. Patel now holds these portfolios – Revenue, and Roads and Buildings. Paatil said in the interview to TV9 that the decision to strip the portfolios was taken in view of the coming elections.

The high points of Patel’s tenure include the Narmada waters reaching the farthest end of Kutch, the signing up of a contract with Vedanta-Foxconn for a prestigious semiconductor facility, Gujarat winning the bid to host the National Games for the first time, and getting to host the Defence Expo — all seen as having the blessings of the Modi government at the Centre.


Even as the BJP-ruled Maharashtra wrung its hands over the lost Vedanta-Foxconn project, “stability” was cited by the companies as one of the reasons to shift to Gujarat.

Under Patel’s leadership, the BJP has also performed commendably in the two elections it faced: to the Gandhinagar Municipal Corporation and close to 9,000 gram panchayats. While the BJP won 41 of the 44 seats in the Gandhinagar corporation, it is estimated to have bagged more than 70% of the gram panchayat seats, which are not fought on party symbols.

While the coming Gujarat elections pose a challenge in the shape of the Aam Aadmi Party, Patel will have the mighty Modi-Shah duo to see him through the polls.

Patel’s dexterity in holding the ship steady despite being a first-time MLA running a ministry of 24, of mostly first-time ministers, has not gone unnoticed. A senior party office-bearer described the CM as a man who takes decisions slowly but steadily, keeping to his “limitations”. “I do not think that the Bhupendra Patel government was appointed with the hope that it will perform a miracle. The brief was clear; not to commit any major mistake. And the government has stuck by that… It is true that Patel has not had to take any major decisions, but this too was not expected. Given his lack of experience in the top post and the prevailing difficult times, one must give him credit for not taking any wrong decision. And whenever some mistakes were made (like the non-appointment of an OBC Commission in time to meet a court condition, or the cattle Bill), the damage control was done very swiftly.”

The leader also cited lack of dissent as another point in favour of Patel. “Even the taking away of portfolios of the two senior ministers saw no protests from their supporters.”


A Leuva Patidar BJP leader from Saurashtra said: “One does not know what will happen after the elections. But generally speaking, there has been no major agitation like the Patidar reservation, the unreserved (general) classes are also happy… Leuva and Kadva Patidars are more or less united now, everyone wants samajik samrasta (social harmony).”

A man of few words, dressed in shirts and trousers unlike most of his Gujarat counterparts, Patel has also not let his government be bogged down by unnecessary rows usually associated with the BJP, and triggered often by its affiliated outfits. One of Patel’s strongest public statements was that his government “had no problem with what anyone ate”, at the peak of protests by some BJP leaders against against non-veg food being sold on the streets.


There were no untoward statements or celebrations by BJP ranks following the arrest of activist Teesta Setalvad or the release of the Bilkis accused.

Leaders say if Patel enjoys the trust of Amit Shah, Modi too appreciates these qualities in the CM. He is known to describe Bhupendra Patel as “mrudu ane makkam (soft and firm)”.

First published on: 02-10-2022 at 10:16:36 pm
Next Story

‘We ran like dogs, didn’t stop during monsoons, storms – we just practised day in and out’

Next Story