Follow Us:
Saturday, August 20, 2022

Who are the middle class in India?

Bibek Debroy<br> Using income,one way of defining middle class is in terms of how much of income is left over for discretionary expenditure,after paying for food and shelter.

The ‘middle class’ is an over-used expression and difficult to pin down,since it is defined not just in terms of income,but also as values,cultural affinities,lifestyles,educational attainments and service sector employment. Using income,one way of defining middle class is in terms of how much of income is left over for discretionary expenditure,after paying for food and shelter. If more than one-third is left,that qualifies one for inclusion in the ‘middle class’.

This is the way the Economist recently defined middle class,and quoted Surjit Bhalla’s forthcoming work (The Middle Class Kingdoms of India and China) to the effect that a third wave of middle-class emergence is currently under way globally. The first was in nineteenth century Western Europe,the second was in the baby boomer (1950-80) generation in developed countries,and the third is the consequence of income growth in countries like India and China.

When India opened up in the early 1990s,the middle class was often cited to sell the attractiveness of India’s domestic market. Figures of 300 million were bandied about,but producers realized to their chagrin that this market was elusive and did not,in fact,exist. Depending on the product,the market might very well be 30 million.

In part,the problem arises from using income as the criterion in defining middle class,ignoring heterogeneity beyond income categories. But let’s ignore that story,which has been told very well by Rama Bijapurkar (We are like that only).

Subscriber Only Stories
Jobs to roads to sports university — the many projects on Sisodia’s platePremium
Delhi Confidential: British High Commissioner to India trolls Manchester ...Premium
As chip shortage bites, companies cut down features to reduce delayPremium
Independence Day’s end: The mystery of the files missing from Tripura Pol...Premium

For two different reasons,30 million is now approaching 300 million.

One,income distributions are positively skewed. Therefore,once the thick part of a distribution passes above the threshold,suddenly there is a disproportionately high increase in the numbers of the ‘middle class’.

Two,a disproportionate distribution of income growth can raise the numbers of the middle class. When income growth occurs,the share of the middle class in the total population increases to more than 50%. The Economist quotes NCAER to tell us that the middle-class share in India’s population will increase from 5% in 2005 to 20% in 2015 and more than 40% in 2025.

But there is yet another feature of being middle class that we need to flag — one which has been apparent in every country that has developed. The middle class no longer wants subsidies and hand-holding from the state,and is content to pay taxes,so that cross-subsidization to poorer sections can happen. The middle class gives up demanding from the government. That hasn’t happened in India yet,and the middle class is still described as the “common man”.

First published on: 24-03-2009 at 03:32:02 pm
Next Story

Indian Pusillanimous League

0 Comment(s) *
* The moderation of comments is automated and not cleared manually by

Featured Stories