Follow Us:
Sunday, April 18, 2021

Make amends

Climbdown by Kathmandu on new constitution offers India an opportunity to undo the bitterness in relations with Nepal.

By: Express News Service |
Updated: December 23, 2015 12:02:57 am
Ethnic Madhesi protesters throw stones and bricks at Nepalese policemen in Birgunj, a town on the border with India, Nepal, Monday, Nov. 2, 2015. Ethnic protesters demonstrating against the new constitution clashed with police in south Nepal Monday which left at least one person killed and several more injured, officials said. (AP Photo/Jiyalal Sah) Ethnic Madhesi protesters throw stones and bricks at Nepalese policemen in Birgunj. (Source: AP)

Nepal’s government agreed on Monday to amend its new constitution, in the hope of meeting the demands of protesters in the country’s plains who have blockaded its border with India for more than three months, setting off violence that has claimed over 50 lives. The proposals appear to meet the two core demands of Nepal’s Madhesi parties — granting population-based proportional representation in government and changes in constituency delimitation. New Delhi has endorsed the proposals, calling them “positive steps” towards ending a crisis that has crippled the country’s economy and left its people reeling under shortages in the midst of the harsh winter. The Indian ministry of external affairs urged “all Nepali political forces to now demonstrate the necessary maturity and flexibility to find a satisfactory solution”, a message that appeared to be directed at the Madhesi parties. However, the Madhesi parties have rejected the government’s offer, saying the amendments are vaguely worded and don’t go far enough towards meeting their demands.

For Delhi, the looming impasse offers a real opportunity to undo the bitterness created by policies many in Nepal — correctly or otherwise — see as partisan Indian interference. Linked by ethnicity and kinship to Bihar, the Madhesis enjoyed considerable support from the Indian government when their agitation began in September. It seemed that the BJP saw backing them as a means to enhancing its electoral prospects in Bihar; India was accused of colluding with the protesters to aid the blockade, which inflicted great hardships on the hills. That same influence should now be used to ensure the Madhesi parties work with the government to resolve the situation, rather than perpetuate the stand-off. This would provide the Nepal government an incentive to continue with accommodation, and discourage maximalist posturing by Madhesi leaders and parties.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi can draw lessons from history on the strategic consequences of failing to act with great wisdom. In 1989, then PM Rajiv Gandhi blockaded Nepal after its government decided to build a second highway to China and purchase munitions from Beijing. His blockade devastated Nepal, and brought down its monarchy. The blockade, though, also had unintended consequences: It entrenched public suspicion of India and Nepal’s leaders, aware of the fate of Birendra, became even more energetic in their pursuit of access to China. The growth of the economy in China’s Xinjiang and Beijing’s success in pushing railway lines into the region make a deepening of Nepal’s eastern relationship inexorable. Delhi’s best interests lie in creative diplomacy that leverages India’s strengths — not crude displays of its coercive resources.

📣 The Indian Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel (@indianexpress) and stay updated with the latest headlines

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App.

  • The Indian Express website has been rated GREEN for its credibility and trustworthiness by Newsguard, a global service that rates news sources for their journalistic standards.
0 Comment(s) *
* The moderation of comments is automated and not cleared manually by