This is an archive article published on July 31, 2015
Premium

Yakub Memon’s ghost

Aftermath of his hanging puts at risk presumptive legitimacy of institutions that mediate social division.

Written by: Pratap Bhanu Mehta
7 min readJul 31, 2015 08:01 AM IST First published on: Jul 31, 2015 at 12:00 AM IST
Yakub Memon, yakub memon hanged, yakub hanged, yakub memon execution, Yakub memon hanging, Yakub Supreme Court, Yakub death sentence, Supreme Court Yakub, Yakub memon judgment, supreme court, president rejects mercy plea, mercy plea rejected, mercy plea, india news In this Sept. 18, 1993 photo, Yakub Memon is taken back to a jail in a police vehicle after he was allowed to visit his Mahim residence in Mumbai. (Source: Indian Express Archive)

Indian democracy will suffer from the shadow of the debate generated by Yakub Memon’s death sentence. The debate exposed barely concealed faultlines. It is a warning about the brittleness of the social fabric, which may be one accident away from cracking. It revealed just how much of our identities as citizens is constituted by sediments of resentment, suspicion and frustration. It is almost as if anger is all there is left to our moral agency. It opened up the legitimacy deficit of our institutions. Instead of transcending differences, these institutions are judged entirely on partisan lines. No one is willing to grant them a presumption of good faith.

Full disclosure: I oppose the death penalty on moral and practical grounds. I hope one day we will have a government that abolishes it. Even if the statute exists on the books, the state would do well to minimise its exercise. But many of my co-citizens think differently. In defending our respective positions, we may come to think of each other as deeply misguided or immoral. I also think it might be possible that we have a good faith disagreement on particular cases. In fact, one of the casualties of Indian democracy is that argumentative integrity and nuance are no longer possible. As Shekhar Gupta wisely pointed out, we often have to disguise our opposition to the death penalty under the technical, procedural and legal doubts of a particular case; conversely, the desire for a strong state often rides roughshod over details in particular cases. These risks are inevitable in a democracy. But what we saw this week was something more ominous.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments