This is an archive article published on May 21, 2021
Premium

Why citizen-led fact-finding missions have a role in democracy

Around the world, as well as India, investigative reports by such missions have a long history of empowering citizens and enriching judicial process.

There has been a surge in the number of independent citizen groups-led fact-finding investigations in the last few decades.There has been a surge in the number of independent citizen groups-led fact-finding investigations in the last few decades.
Written by: Ankita Pandey
6 min readMay 21, 2021 09:07 AM IST First published on: May 21, 2021 at 03:05 AM IST

The solicitor-general of India challenged five fact-finding reports conducted on the riots in Northeast Delhi in 2020 in the Delhi High Court on February 24. He argued that the citizen groups, which conducted the fact-finding, were examples of a self-constituted, extra-constitutional, “parallel judicial system”, that did not have any authority in law. They could not be relied upon by any formal judicial forum. He said that people cannot have their own fact-finding committees, they must go to a competent authority.

However, even a cursory look at our past shows that fact-finding investigations are a well-established practice in India since the movement for independence. Worldwide, fact-finding is at the heart of rights advocacy. The first Gandhian experiment, the Champaran satyagraha of 1917, started as an extensive fact-finding exercise. In Champaran, the peasants were forced to grow indigo on their lands as a condition of tenancy and were required to pay an illegal cess on it and exorbitant rent to local landlords. In his autobiography, Gandhi writes that he decided to visit Champaran “to enquire into the conditions of” the indigo planters when he was informed of their distress and the lack of appropriate response by the colonial administration. Gandhi carried out a detailed investigation with a team of volunteers and recorded the statements of peasants. To make these statements credible, the peasants signed or put thumb impressions on them, and these were recorded in the presence of an officer from the Criminal Investigation Department (CID). This exercise forced the Lieutenant Governor of Bihar, Sir Edward Gait, to set up a formal enquiry committee with Gandhi as one of its members.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments