Follow Us:
Saturday, July 02, 2022

Town and gown

Academic education and employability are not the same thing. Our universities need to stop pretending they are....

Written by Meeta Sengupta |
July 31, 2010 2:50:09 am

Our higher education institutions are in trouble. A few thousand of them churn out half a million graduates every year,operating on a larger scale than in most other places. But many of these graduates are rated as unemployable without further training,the blame for which is squarely set on the shoulders of the universities. Recent work from the Confederation of Indian Industries estimated that only between 40 and 50 per cent of graduates and diploma holders are employable,on average.

This is not merely a crisis of scale,nor is this just a story of ineffectual behemoths. The truth is that India’s universities are suffering through a deep and fundamental identity crisis. This is a case of irrelevance,of lost purpose and one of misdirected effort.

Academic higher education is designed for intellectual life,not for employability. Professional and vocational education are both clearly designed to create direct economic value in an economy — hence employability. When higher education institutions seek to deliver employability while retaining academic structures,they find themselves at a loss. Such institutions need to today make a choice between academic and professional structures. They each need to know clearly where they are headed. The trauma of rocking between academia and vocational education is damaging our ability to deliver any sensible education to our students.

Consider management education. Managing resources is a skill,not a science,and as such does not require an academic degree. It falls in the same category as other professional qualifications such as accountancy,law and,dare I say,medicine. In terms of pedagogy required,management education is closer to vocational training which is learnt by doing — rather than merely reading up on precedent or literature in the area. A sad (though perhaps necessary,at the time) effort to glamorise management education saw it classified as higher education. This might not have damaged management education,but its success has led to a near-identity crisis in higher education institutions.

Best of Express Premium
Udaipur killing on video | ‘Do something spectacular’: Man from Pak told ...Premium
In village of fauji dreams, second thoughts, insecurity over AgnipathPremium
Delhi HC recently struck down powers of Banks Board Bureau; new body to s...Premium
Explained: Concise companion to a bestselling treatisePremium

The questions I hear from educators in universities range from the issue of teaching qualifications,to purpose,to employability,to values and ethics. What I do not hear is the question of value addition. I hear discussions on quality and have yet to see a single native measure of this quality. In this lies the rub: employability of candidates is a key target of professional education,which implies metrics and measurement of the target,and all systems must be geared to that. Higher education that is academic is geared to creating people who will think and create a better world — which implies that they must have depth of knowledge and the freedom to explore. This is the antithesis of a metric-oriented pedagogy.

Is it not possible for an academic university to deliver on both professional and academic value? Of course it is,but it must be designed for that purpose. In spite of the conflict in pedagogy,there is much synergy between the resources required for both types of education. The problem is that,in seeking credibility from academic models,institutions tend to replicate them in areas of professional education. This will naturally confuse the purpose and process of teaching and learning. More importantly,the expectations from teachers and learners are diametrically opposed to each other.

The structures and practices in our universities are frequently called antiquated. While that is often undeniable,these institutions carry a host of burdens. From political interference to a lack of transparency in operations to a sluggish and restrictive legal system,they are trapped in a quagmire that is not all of their own making.

Sadly,even students have contributed to the downfall of universities. We often choose courses not because we are passionate about the subject but because we think of them as “prestigious”. Many who would prosper in vocations and professions tend to go through three years of academic conditioning. This skews the demand for courses and the clearing system delivers faulty results. Once within an institution,one’s lack of aptitude and interest skews the learning process.

With their supply structure confused as to its purpose,demand skewed due to societal mores and pressures and their governance processes sadly manipulated,is it a wonder that our universities are floundering?

The ones that are doing well,or are seeking to introduce new ways of doing things,are also unable to manage their stakeholders. The University of Delhi recently tried to introduce the semester system,which admittedly does have some advantages — but met with strong opposition from within. An attempt has been made to make undergraduate degrees more flexible by allowing students to pick and choose units of equivalent value from across various traditional disciplines. This liberal approach is yet to find a significant response.

To prosper,our higher education institutions need greater clarity of purpose and process. They are all trying too hard to be everything for everybody.

The writer is an education strategist

UPSC KEY Have you seen our section dedicated to helping USPC aspirants decode daily news in the context of their exams?

📣 Join our Telegram channel (The Indian Express) for the latest news and updates

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App.

  • Newsguard
  • The Indian Express website has been rated GREEN for its credibility and trustworthiness by Newsguard, a global service that rates news sources for their journalistic standards.
  • Newsguard
0 Comment(s) *
* The moderation of comments is automated and not cleared manually by