This is an archive article published on January 4, 2017
Premium

High principle, dubious law

SC’s reading of the Representation of People Act could turn a large chunk of democratic mobilisation illegal.

Written by: Pratap Bhanu Mehta
7 min readJan 4, 2017 12:00 AM IST First published on: Jan 4, 2017 at 12:00 AM IST
supreme court, hinsutva judgement, ban religion campaign, elections, people act, Representation of people act, constitution, indian legal history, RPA, RPA meaning, what is RPA, hindutva case, indian express column, column, india newsurt, Supreme court on corporate, Chief Justice T S Thakur , corporate debts, debt recovery tribunals, indian express news The principle will be anchored to the Constitution or a statute. But the Court will claim to give the relevant text a new and revolutionary meaning, invoking a methodological approach like purposive interpretation.

The pattern is disarmingly familiar. The Supreme Court, with all its majesty, will enunciate a grand, even utopian principle. The aspiration will be undeniably correct. The principle will have a kind of populist appeal: It will promise to cure an ailing democracy of many of its greatest infirmities. The principle will be anchored to the Constitution or a statute. But the Court will claim to give the relevant text a new and revolutionary meaning, invoking a methodological approach like purposive interpretation. But the net result will be greater and almost unimplementable uncertainty in the law, a likely violation of legal integrity, and almost certain expansion of the Court’s powers. And oddly, the judgment will answer, every question other than the one it was supposed to.

This is exemplified in the majority judgment Abhiram Singh v/s C.D. Comachen (dead) by Lrs and Ors. The majority judgment has been rightly taken to task in one of the more brilliant dissents in Indian legal history, by Justice D.Y. Chandrachud. The issue is the interpretation of Section 123(3) of the Representation of People’s Act (RPA). Appeals to religion, caste etc have always been prohibited.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments