This is an archive article published on September 14, 2015
Premium

Silencing A Tradition

Refusal to respect diverse readings of the Ramayana is cultural vandalism

Written by: Amrith Lal
5 min readSep 14, 2015 12:15 AM IST First published on: Sep 14, 2015 at 12:15 AM IST
Hindutva, M.M. Basheer, Ramayana, Basheer Ramayana, bhakti movement, Ayodhya, iecolumnist, Amrith Lal, The Indian Express M M Basheer

The Hindutva activists in Kozhikode who forced academic M.M. Basheer to stop writing on the Ramayana argued that there could be no criticism of Lord Ram (even by Valmiki) and that Basheer, being a non-Hindu, should not write on a “Hindu text”. They reveal a colossal ignorance of the Ramayana tradition in Malayalam. Their success in silencing a well-respected teacher and critic indicates the emergence of a new hate politics in Kerala.

The Ramayana tradition in Malayalam, as in most Indian languages, includes numerous retellings and interpretations of the Rama katha across genres. Some of these are soaked in bhakti, while a few others offer different points of view, including criticism of Rama and his ethical universe. The tradition has been richer and more complex for the diverse readings. Basheer was not the first, or the only, non-Hindu to write on the Ramayana — Basheer himself has written nearly 50 essays on the epic.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments