This is an archive article published on July 15, 2019
Premium

The punishing state

It is necessary to critique its tendency to over and under-punish sexual violence.

Written by: Neetika Vishwanath
6 min readJul 15, 2019 03:03 AM IST First published on: Jul 15, 2019 at 03:03 AM IST
Delhi, Delhi news, delhi court, ‘Victim’ fails to show up, delhi court acquits man in accident case, Embassy of Kazakhstan, Indian Express The judge said the prosecution proved beyond a reasonable doubt that Yadav and Karnawat hatched a conspiracy to procure minor girls for prostitution and earned money from the business. (Representative Image)

The Bombay High Court in the Shakti Mills case upheld the constitutionality of Section 376E of the IPC that provides for life imprisonment till the end of natural life or death sentence for the repeat offence of rape. A legacy of the criminal amendments after the 2012 Delhi gang rape, the provision brings into focus once again the complex and uncertain relationship between punishment and sexual violence. This remains an under-explored area for feminist legal thought in India, which is simultaneously sceptical of increased state power and also has a deep interest in fixing criminal responsibility for sexual violence.

While the Bombay High Court leaves open the question as to whether Section 376 is applicable in the Shakti Mills case, the judgment is yet another ringing endorsement for harsher punishment for sexual violence. This legislative trend is evident across the 2013 and 2018 criminal law amendments and has occurred in a context where there has been very little guidance from the feminist movement on approaches to punishment for sexual violence.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments