Thursday, Oct 06, 2022

PPP and Baby B

In Pakistan,conspiracy theories are often less surprising than the truth

In Pakistan,conspiracy theories are often less surprising than the truth

I crossed the border from Lahore to Amritsar on foot last week to have my Bhrigu Shastra horoscope read by an astrologer in Hoshiarpur. (Bet you never thought a Pakistani would say that.) Unfortunately,after the effort of making it across militarised borders and Amritsar’s suburban traffic,I was told that they couldn’t locate my exact horoscope that day and I should return in a few months. Obviously I was disappointed,like when I first saw the building of the Bhrigu Shastra astrologer’s office,and realised it looked less “ancient mystical site” and more “Baby Gap”. However,I did discover two things: The first is that I am on my final incarnation,have achieved moksha or “salvation”,and am now free from the repetitive cycles of life (and,one hopes,death),which is an unexpected relief. The second was how very big Bilawal Bhutto is in India.

Newspapers were filled with juicy,operatic articles about how Baby Bhutto had “fled to Dubai” after a “passionate fight” with his father and aunt over the failures of the PPP government while in office. From the way the fight was described,Baby Bhutto was single-handedly defending the honour of country he loves against the sad truth that it is his family that has been running it. Poor Baby B,so alone,so idealistic,so committed to truth that he’s prepared to turn against his own father to help the nation out. My heart aches,like,real bad.

I was surprised to read the story in such detail in Indian papers,mainly because the item didn’t get nearly as much traction in Pakistan. Why would it though? We have historic transitional elections (only took us 66 years. Stay tuned for free healthcare by 2080),Imran Khan,monochromatic Tahir-ul-Qadri,and crises in taxation and British aid. To say nothing of the reverse Spanish Inquisition that’s going on to disqualify candidates from contesting elections for not knowing some Quranic verses well enough (because our elected officials breaking into scriptural Arabic is totally what’s going to win us negotiations at the UN). The point is you have to up your game if you want to crack the local news cycle.

Subscriber Only Stories
Remembering Indian tennis great, Naresh Kumar, who passed away on Septemb...Premium
How Carlsen would need to cheat just once in a game of chess to be invinc...Premium
IAS officer’s initiative scales up students’ learning level in Sangli sch...Premium
Rising rates after four repo hikes: Turbulent times ahead for home loan s...Premium

The opera continued into Act Two: Asif Ali Zardari himself hopped on a plane to Dubai to patch things up with the prodigal son,to pacify his concerns and by extension the nation’s. Less is known about the dialogue of this scene but things are generally believed to have gone swimmingly. By the time I returned to Lahore,Act Three had begun; there were reports that the dynasty was secure and that Baby B would be coming home to reaffirm his commitment to his country and cause. I love a story with closure.

The last time Bilawal was so in the papers was when the absurd but infectious rumor spread that he was having “an affair” with our erstwhile foreign minister — she of the pearls — Hina Rabbani Khar. That story too did the rounds in India,but for what its worth I don’t think anyone really believed it. It’s more likely that someone was trying desperately to link up the only star members of the PPP who are not geriatrics with bald patches in an effort to sell papers. The fascination India has with Bilawal is palpable. I imagine he’s seen to be for Pakistan what Rahul Gandhi is for India. No one saw Bilawal in Pakistan while he was growing up,and even now he seems transplanted here; unfamiliar with the language,the customs,fickle public opinion and bureaucratic maze that must be negotiated by anyone in politics. His first speech in Urdu recently wasn’t exactly fluent,but considering he’s spent his entire life abroad (and the memory of Benazir’s Urdu still makes for good one-liners),it was quite impressive.

But don’t be fooled. Think: why is it that a story about Bilawal fighting with his father is making the rounds now,so close to elections? If you buy into the drama as truth,you are probably left with a feeling that young Bilawal is not aligned with his father,shares everyone’s strong reservations about how the PPP have done things during their term in power and will act differently if he is ever in power. I suspect that is exactly what you are expected to think. This circus (and elections are nothing if not an elaborate show with fire breathers and carnivorous predators) was performed to distance Baby B from his father’s regime,and on a grander,more long-term level,to try and distance the future of the PPP from its present legacy. After all,if one doesn’t offer a change,how else would one be elected?


Pakistanis are famous for th-eir cynicism and conspiracy theories. We know that about ourselves. But in a land where conspiracy theories are often less surprising than the truth,I think we can be forgiven this tendency. Perhaps I’m wrong and the fight was real and not a showy PR move. Maybe I’m just another cynical Pakistani. Then again,as a soul in my last incarnation before nirvana,maybe I’ve just seen it all before.

Aijazuddin in an artist and writer based in Lahore

First published on: 09-04-2013 at 12:26:59 am
Next Story

How India can become a startup nation

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments