Follow Us:
Wednesday, January 26, 2022

A ‘Lakshman rekha’ was breached at opening of Kashi-Vishwanath Corridor

Yashwant Sinha writes: PM’s use of religion for political gains is a matter of great concern. But of greater concern is the more difficult battle of the 2024 general elections

Written by Yashwant Sinha |
Updated: December 22, 2021 9:27:59 am
PM Narendra Modi offers prayers at the Kashi Vishwanath Temple. (PTI Photo)

The recent inauguration of a municipal road in Kashi, the Lok Sabha constituency of the prime minister, was converted by him into a grand show of devotion to the Hindu religion — like the inauguration or foundation-laying functions of earlier projects at Ayodhya, Badrinath, Kedarnath and other Hindu religious places, all at a considerable cost to the government exchequer. These events have raised many questions of propriety in a secular democracy. In an earlier article, I had talked about the crossing of the “Lakshman rekha” by the PM, when I noticed that he was freely using government functions organised at government cost to lambast his political opponents, especially in Uttar Pradesh. That is a fine line of democratic behaviour that many of our worthies in politics have often violated but I was shocked when it came from no less a person than the PM. But that is nothing compared to the recent show at Kashi, all dedicated to the glory of the Hindu religion, spread over two days and covered live by all media channels and comprehensively by the entire print media. “Is India a secular democracy anymore?” is a question on many people’s lips, while the majority celebrate it as the final revenge of history taken by the present prime minister for all the wrongs done by the Muslim invaders in the past.

As I understand it, India is still a secular state, which means that the state has no religion and is bound by the Constitution to treat all religions as equal and make no distinction between the followers of one as compared to the other. I have been in positions of power and authority myself, first in administration and later in politics, almost all my life. Nobody taught me to be secular but I was secular naturally and, therefore, had no difficulty in treating the followers of all faiths equally. I was and continue to be a devout Hindu. Apart from doing my prayers on a daily basis, going to temples and the places of pilgrimage, I have walked barefoot a hundred kilometres from Sultanganj in Bihar to Baba Dham (Deoghar) now in Jharkhand, carrying a ‘Kanwar’ with the holy Ganga water to be offered to Lord Shiva for five years running. But it was always a personal pursuit, as it should be. I even persuaded the great socialist leader Karpoori Thakur, who was chief minister of Bihar then, to create adequate facilities for the pilgrims on the 100 km route, like clean dharamshalas, drinking water facilities, toilets, etc. at government cost. I still remember the lively debate we had in the largely socialist Bihar cabinet then about whether the government should spend money on a purpose like this. The issue was settled in favour of doing so on the grounds that it served a larger public purpose. But neither Karpoori Thakur nor any of his cabinet colleagues, who included representatives of the then Jan Sangh, made a song and dance about it. There were no grand foundation-laying or inaugural functions. I shudder to imagine what would have happened if such a project had been undertaken today.

Milking religion, caste, language, region or any other identity for personal and political gain is not unknown in electoral politics in our country, as indeed the world over. But it has been muted and not done as openly and shamelessly as it is being done today. The present prime minister is not the first BJP prime minister of India. Atal Bihari Vajpayee had preceded him in that post and while I shall not judge Narendra Modi by the standards of Jawaharlal Nehru, I am well within my rights to judge him by the standards set by Vajpayee. And knowing him as I do, I have no hesitation in saying that Vajpayee would never have done any of those hundreds of things Modi has done to violate the spirit of the Constitution, including the grand show in Kashi the other day. “Raj Dharma” can be consigned to the dustbin.

For the prime minister in our democracy, as indeed for all the other functionaries, religion should be a strictly private affair. Then, why is Modi making such a show of it? The simple and obvious answer is that UP elections are approaching and Yogi Adityanath’s performance has been so poor that the only hope the BJP has of coming anywhere near the majority mark is through a well-executed communal divide. So, that is the game in UP and the same formula will again be tried in the Lok Sabha elections in 2024.

After all, Modi became the darling of fundamentalist Hindus after the horrible Gujarat riots and kept winning subsequent elections by exploiting Hindu sentiments and, if that was not sufficient, bringing “Mian Musharraf” in the picture. I only hope that the communal virus thus generated does not get out of hand. The Opposition parties should not fall into the BJP’s trap by starting to respond to its agenda. There are a host of secular issues like unemployment, price rise, misgovernance and mismanagement, especially of Covid, safety of women and collapsing law and order generally on which it must concentrate and force the BJP and its government to respond. Half the battle in politics is won if you succeed in setting the agenda. You have lost the battle already if you start responding to the other’s agenda. Will the Opposition allow the UP elections to be fought on the issue of Jinnah, Pakistan, Abba Jan, Aurangzeb, etc. or the real issues on the ground?

But the UP elections are only a semi-colon, important but not the ultimate. The main battle will be fought in 2024. The elections then will decide whether the idea of India, as we have known it, will survive in this country or not. Will India remain a secular democracy or become a Hindu Pakistan? Will the corporate, militaristic, fundamentalist and pseudo-nationalist interests take over the country and drive it to perdition? What happened in Kashi is a matter of great concern. But of greater concern is the more difficult battle which lies ahead.

In the meanwhile, a very important question is: Does Prime Minister Modi go anywhere without a photographer?

TThis column first appeared in the print edition on December 22, 2021 under the title ‘The Kashi echo’. The writer is a former Union minister and currently, vice-president, All-India Trinamool Congress

📣 The Indian Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel (@indianexpress) and stay updated with the latest headlines

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App.

  • Newsguard
  • The Indian Express website has been rated GREEN for its credibility and trustworthiness by Newsguard, a global service that rates news sources for their journalistic standards.
  • Newsguard
0 Comment(s) *
* The moderation of comments is automated and not cleared manually by