This is an archive article published on November 2, 2022
Premium

Arif Mohammad Khan is overreaching in his role as governor

In seeking resignation of Kerala minister, governor Arif Mohammad Khan has exceeded his remit. Real powers in a parliamentary democracy vest in the elected government, governor has to be a nominal head.

Governor Khan’s letter hints at a dangerous trend where governors may become entrenched sparring political actors in the politics of the state.(Illustration by C R Sasikumar)Governor Khan’s letter hints at a dangerous trend where governors may become entrenched sparring political actors in the politics of the state.(Illustration by C R Sasikumar)
7 min readNov 2, 2022 05:04 PM IST First published on: Nov 2, 2022 at 04:00 AM IST

The good governor should have a broken leg and keep at home,” said Miguel de Cervantes. These were the ideals under which the governor had a faint presence, like a full moon on a mid-day. His primary role as a sagacious counsellor was “to be consulted, to warn and to encourage”. He has to be above politics. But India’s experience with governors has been disappointing: The governor’s office signifies an assault on parliamentary democracy at its best and constitutional despotism at its worst. In NCT Delhi v. Union of India (2017), the Supreme Court had stated that the real powers must vest in the elected representatives as we are a “representative democracy”.

Kerala Governor Arif Mohammad Khan is a veteran parliamentarian who has been a minister in several governments. He is an intellectual of high stature and widely respected for his independent and bold views, particularly on Muslim Personal Law. Hence, it was shocking to see his communiqué to the Kerala Chief Minister seeking dismissal of the state’s finance minister for expressing his opinion on the security given to a vice chancelor in UP — which the governor, in his wisdom, equated with the violation of the Constitution and as threatening cordial relations between states. Governor Khan blamed the minister for “violating [his] oath” and in an unprecedented manner, and probably without consulting any constitutional law expert, conveyed to CM Pinarayi Vijayan that the minister had “ceased to enjoy [the Governor’s] pleasure”. The letter threw many constitutional experts into a tizzy as the exercise of discretionary powers by a governor is significantly restricted by provisions of the Constitution and well-established constitutional conventions. It seems the governor has gone against his oath of preserving, protecting and upholding the Constitution.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments