This is an archive article published on October 6, 2011
Premium

Errors of commission

Is the Planning Commission out of touch with the governance needs of the 21st century?

Written by: Pratap Bhanu Mehta
7 min readOct 6, 2011 03:29 AM IST First published on: Oct 6, 2011 at 03:29 AM IST

The Planning Commission is not an institution. It is a syndrome. It,often unconsciously,operates on assumptions that no longer have much plausibility. It has lost much of its credibility as an interlocutor in India’s debates. During the recent controversy over the poverty line,the commission was often accused of being “out of touch”. Much of the discussion focused on the poverty line,and the uses to which it should or should not be put. But it is also clear that the Planning Commission has ended up in a cul-de-sac because its institutional mission is incompatible with the governance requirements of the 21st century.

The Planning Commission has gifted individuals. There is no reason to doubt their commitment to India’s growth prospects and the well-being of the poor. But we need to ask: why has it lost authority? Part of the answer may require excavating a whole range of illusions it has fallen prey to. The Planning Commission has long been a victim of its own name. It has this illusion that it can neatly order India’s economy. It does so,but often as a kind of conjuring trick,where real credible objectives disappear under a set of entrenched assumptions.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments