Written by Malish C M
A Nepali student’s death by suicide at a private university is a tragedy that also presents a significant setback for India’s “Study in India” (SII) initiative. The way the university administration has dealt with the issue is not an aberration. It is only the latest manifestation of a deep-rooted system of inequality, subjugation and domination in higher education.
The country’s aspiration to become a “Vishwa Guru” (global teacher) and to develop an “inclusive and equitable quality of education for all” remains a policy rhetoric as the discrimination and distress faced by a diverse student body remain unaddressed. The article examines the inadequacies of the existing regulatory mechanisms to deal with student diversity and calls for developing effective institutional mechanisms and cadres of empathetic leaders, teachers, staff, and trained professionals to promote and honour student diversity.
Internationalisation of higher education
Internationalisation provides an opportunity to integrate international, intercultural and global dimensions into the purpose, functions or delivery of higher education. Cross-border student mobility is crucial in promoting students with a global outlook and intercultural competencies, which are heavily valued in today’s world and workplace. Another form is “internationalisation at home”, which demands restructuring courses and curricula on par with global standards. For instance, introducing the liberal arts model of four-year degree programmes.
Study in India scheme
The Ministry of Education and regulatory bodies introduced various measures to change India’s status from “sending country” to “destination country”. The Study in India (SII) scheme was launched in 2018 to attract foreign students by offering scholarships and fee waiver schemes. Growth in the number of foreign students is crucial to achieving the “Vishwa Guru” status. As per the latest All India Survey of Higher Education (AISHE) 2021-22, the total number of foreign students enrolled in India is 46,878. These foreign students have come from 170 different countries. Compared to the overall enrolment of 43.3 million (4.33 crores), foreign student’s enrolment is negligible.
In 2021-22, the highest share of international students was from Nepal (28 per cent), followed by Afghanistan (6.7 per cent), the United States (6.2 per cent), Bangladesh (5.6 per cent), UAE (4.9 per cent), and Bhutan (3.3 per cent). Of the total number of foreign students, 64.7 per cent come from 10 countries. While total enrollment has grown from 3 crore in 2012-13 to 4.33 crore in 2021-22, the number of foreign students increased from 34, 774 to 46, 878.
Diversity and discrimination
The foreign students are heterogeneous in terms of nationality, cultural, linguistic and schooling backgrounds. This heterogeneous student population enters colleges and universities already occupied by a diverse student body. India’s student diversity, in terms of caste, class, language, schooling, physical ability, and gender, has no parallels anywhere in the world. Policymakers need to understand this changing context of diversity thoroughly.
Empirical studies have consistently observed that caste, ethnicity and gender-based discrimination continue to persist in varying forms in colleges and universities. The latest incident of death by suicide also hints that those from vulnerable backgrounds are largely the ones facing distress and discriminatory behaviour and actions from peers, teachers and institutional leaders. In other words, the problem is the deep-rooted social structure built on the assumption that some are inferior to others.
Ineffective institutional mechanisms
There are many institution-level bodies to promote the well-being of students. Some of those mechanisms include Scheduled Caste (SC) and Scheduled Tribe (ST) cell, Gender Cell, Equal Opportunity Office and Student’s Grievance Redressal Committee. The UGC “Guidelines to Provide Equitable Opportunity for the Socio-Economically Disadvantaged Groups” (SEDGs), released in 2024, mandate all institutions to establish an additional SEDG cell. Faculty members head all those campus-level committees. Some premier institutes appoint the Deans of Student Affairs and International Relations. However, these cells are not supported by professionals trained in student affairs except for counselling cells. Institutions comply with regulations by constituting a committee. Thus, such mechanisms largely remain only on paper.
The way forward
An effective mechanism (national/state/institution level) for periodically collecting student feedback on social and academic experience in classrooms and campuses would be an immediate first step for developing effective strategies for promoting student diversity and preventing distress and discrimination. There is an urgent need to create a cadre of student affairs professionals and a mechanism for mandatory training to develop culturally sensitive institutional leaders, teachers, staff and members of campus-level committees and cells. Faculty members’ involvement in student affairs and welfare must be adequately acknowledged and incentivised.
The structure and process of higher education that evolved to serve elite classes and castes by leaders and teachers of the same group conflict with the current system of higher education characterised by the increasing presence of hitherto under-represented castes and classes and foreign nationals, primarily from the least developed countries. The apathy of institutional mechanisms and leaders towards the issues of diversity, equity and inclusion is merely a manifestation of the same. Radical institutional restructuring is required to envisage an inclusive curriculum, classroom and campus that nurture the talents and aspirations of a diverse student body from India and abroad.
The writer is an Assistant Professor at Ashank Desai Centre for Policy Studies (ADCPS), IIT Bombay. Views expressed are personal
