What is Brexit about? Is it about Britain leaving the European Union? Is it about the disruption this has caused in the world economy? Is it about hyper-nationalism and the fear of immigrants in general and Islam in particular?
It is, of course, all this, but Brexit is primarily about too much democracy. That might sound like a terrible thing to say yet recent events show us that when democracy is given full rein, the results are often disastrous.
Who were the people who voted for Britain to leave EU? The voting pattern shows that many of them came from the depressed North East of England, its industrial centres, plus many smaller cities. It also shows that a large proportion of the “Leave” voters were older people. Those voting to “Remain” were predominantly young, plus those in the large cities, notably London. The world’s most powerful politicians and a large number of UK’s intellectuals, all wanted the country to remain in the EU. It wasn’t quite white collar versus blue collar, but the vote does suggest that those who saw the bigger picture and the more important issues involved, wanted to remain, while those bothered by the issues that affected them personally, opted to leave. The “Leave” faction was also influenced by the inflammatory rhetoric by people who stoked fears of unchecked immigration. In the end, when people were given the option to vote on a vital matter, their decision was ruled by emotion and not by logic.
If popular referendums were held in India on some of our most important issues, what would be the likely results? To start with, India would cease to be a secular country; it would be a Hindu Rashtra, which would probably treat its minorities rather roughly. A referendum in Kashmir? We know where that would go. Similarly, if you jog your memory a bit, there was a time (in the 1960s) when a large number of Tamilians felt so alienated from the rest of the country that there was open talk of Tamil Nadu seceding.
Hold a referendum on the death penalty, and it’s likely that the majority would be for it. Most people would probably want castration as the punishment for rape. As the vast majority on Twitter and other social media, and vicious individuals like Subramanian Swamy, constantly show, democracy and unfettered free speech results in the expression of the worst side of human nature. Give these forces a direct role in policy making, and the world will inexorably descend to the depths.
That is precisely why a democracy installs institutions, some directly elected (parliament), some not (the judiciary, the executive, the media) to take rational decisions on important issues. Members of directly elected institutions are, of course, influenced hugely by populist sentiment, or often stir up base instincts of the electorate for their own selfish ends. But they are controlled by a system of checks and balances: First of all, there is an elected opposition in Parliament, and secondly, the judiciary, the executive and the media ensure that illegal and unethical policies are rejected.
Nothing illustrates the notion of “too much democracy” than the rise and rise of Donald Trump. He has risen to this position by exploiting the worst fears of Americans, and by letting loose the base instincts of racism and hyper-nationalism. Is democracy dangerous, then? It is, if those who have risen to positions of responsibility abdicate that responsibility, or do not confront and defeat the evil genies who occasionally escape from the bottle.
To end, here is a sad irony: If a referendum were to be held in our country asking people to choose between a benevolent dictator and our parliamentary system, they would choose the former. This is how too much democracy defeats democracy itself.
- Slow and steady loses the race
Congress and other Opposition parties are up against a regime whose leaders have a 24x7 commitment to electoral politics. Their time for 2024 starts now..
- Re-enforcing that There Is No Alternative to PM Modi is part of BJP’s campaign strategy
NOTA is not an option; the option really is this: Better not the devil we know than the devil we don’t, because the latter may…
- Captain Uncool
Someone should calm Virat Kohli down and make him study the situation instead of screaming at it..