May 29, 2009 11:07:34 pm
With extraordinary speed,China has morphed from a diffident player in international finance into an impatient table-banger. The Chinese are pumping almost $40 billion into a new East Asian version of the IMF,browbeating trading partners into using the yuan,and floating fantastical ideas about a new international reserve currency. Visiting Beijing last week,Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva picked up on his hosts changed mood. Calling for a new economic order, he suggested that it was time to stop denominating trade in dollars.
Its great that China is speaking up. The country accounts for a large share of the worlds savings and much of its growth; if a stable economic order is to emerge from this crisis,it will need Chinese buy-in. But theres a not-so-great side to Chinas transformation,too: Its contribution to the global debate is mostly muddled.
Why have the Chinese found their voice? Put simply,they have bought so much of the international system that they can no longer be indifferent to it. By running colossal trade surpluses,they have accumulated vast holdings of bonds and shares denominated in dollars,the currency at the core of global finance. If the greenback declines,Chinas government stands to lose a fortune.
The political backlash from such a loss could be brutal. Already,Chinese bloggers have ripped into the officials who invested $3 billion in the US private equity group Blackstone,only to see the stock plummet. They are worse than wartime traitors, one online chatter fumed,according to the Financial Times. A large fall in the dollar would make the Blackstone loss look like a picnic.
So Chinese authorities are searching for a way to reduce their exposure to the greenback. The surest method would be to stop buying so many US Treasury bonds; but that would mean allowing the Chinese currency to rise against the dollar,which would hurt Chinese exporters when they are already suffering. So the government is scrabbling around for something anything that can spring it from the dollar trap without driving up its currency.
Chinas ideas come in two categories. The wackiest popped up unexpectedly on the Web site of the Chinese central bank itself a stunning sign of the nations ambitions to shape the new order. It proposed that the IMF greatly expand its issuance of special drawing rights, the multilateral quasi-currency it dreamed up in the late 1960s. The notion is that the IMF would trade these SDRs for some of Chinas dollars,and presto!, Chinas dollar exposure would go down. But the hitch is that either the IMF or one of its member governments would be left holding the bag. The idea is a non-starter. Chinas other approach is to promote the global use of its own currency. Its central bank has offered yuan to Indonesia and Argentina in return for rupiah and pesos. It hopes more trade will be denominated in yuan. Its contribution to the new IMF-like East Asian reserve fund may one day mean that a crisis-prone country in the region borrows partly in yuan. As an escape from Chinas dollar trap,it is laughable. The idea is that once the yuan goes international,foreigners may be willing to borrow in it. That way,China can keep running a trade surplus and exporting capital,but instead of accumulating bonds denominated in dollars it would be able to accumulate bonds denominated in yuan.But the hitch is the same as with the IMF idea: The currency risk would be transferred,in this case to Chinas borrowers. Given that the yuan is artificially held down by Chinese policy and will almost certainly rise,a foreigner would have to be desperate (or intimidated) to help China out of its impasse by borrowing in its currency.
To make the dilemma more painful,Chinas determination to control the appreciation of its currency forces it to buy billions more in dollar assets every month. Like an addict at a slot machine,China is adding to its hopeless bet,ensuring that its eventual losses will be even heavier.
📣 The Indian Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel (@indianexpress) and stay updated with the latest headlines
- The Indian Express website has been rated GREEN for its credibility and trustworthiness by Newsguard, a global service that rates news sources for their journalistic standards.