This is an archive article published on April 14, 2015
Premium

A prize for bad behaviour

The international community must create a viable alternative to the Lausanne deal with Iran

Written by: Daniel Carmon
6 min readApr 14, 2015 03:21 PM IST First published on: Apr 14, 2015 at 12:35 AM IST
From left, Head of Mission of People's Republic of China to the European Union Hailong Wu, French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius, German Foreign Minister Frank Walter Steinmeier, European Union High Representative Federica Mogherini, Iranian Foreign Minister Javad Zarifat, Russian Deputy Political Director Alexey Karpov, British Foreign Secretary Philip Hammond and US Secretary of State John Kerry arrive,  at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, or Ecole Polytechnique Federale De Lausanne,  in Lausanne, Switzerland, Thursday, April 2, 2015, after Iran nuclear program talks finished with extended sessions. (AP Photo) From left, Head of Mission of People’s Republic of China to the European Union Hailong Wu, French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius, German Foreign Minister Frank Walter Steinmeier, European Union High Representative Federica Mogherini, Iranian Foreign Minister Javad Zarifat, Russian Deputy Political Director Alexey Karpov, British Foreign Secretary Philip Hammond and US Secretary of State John Kerry arrive, at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, or Ecole Polytechnique Federale De Lausanne, in Lausanne, Switzerland, Thursday, April 2, 2015, after Iran nuclear program talks finished with extended sessions. (AP Photo)

As the dust starts to settle after the Lausanne understanding between Iran and the P5+1, we can examine more clearly the possible outcomes of this framework agreement. What is clear is that these understandings allow Iran to maintain substantial nuclear capabilities while lifting existing sanctions. Many have described the agreement, even here in India, as “a great diplomatic achievement” that will prevent Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons. They overlook the basics of the agreement, mainly that these will, in fact, enable Iran to continue its quest for military nuclear capabilities and will lead to a bad and dangerous deal that is more likely to pave Iran’s path to the bomb.

Among what are being described as “achievements”, we should note that no Iranian nuclear facility will be shut, Iran will still retain over 6,000 centrifuges, and any materials or centrifuges removed would not be destroyed but rather be available for rapid installation by Iran in case of a breach of the agreement. The framework agreement is vague on the issue of “possible military dimensions of the programme” (PMD) and has no mention of the issues of weaponisation and development of ballistic missile capabilities — two key aspects, needed only for the creation of nuclear weapons.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments