Monday, Oct 03, 2022

Uncounted in Assam NRC final draft: School teacher, one of twins, MLA, B.Ed student, social worker in Delhi

In a state where history and geography have created multiple identities intertwined over the years, the NRC has cleaved open more than one fault line: cutting across ethnicity, language, religion.

Muslim women stand in a queue to check if their names are included in the National Register of Citizens at a draft center in Mayoung, about 55 kilometers (34 miles) east of Gauhati. (AP Photo/Anupam Nath)

BJP president Amit Shah framed the National Register of Citizens (NRC) as a filter to keep out “illegal” Bangla migrants — saying “Bharat ke koi bhi nagarik ko chinta karne ki zaroorat nahin hai (No citizen of India has any reason to be concerned).”

On the ground, however, it’s not so simple.

In a state where history and geography have created multiple identities intertwined over the years, the NRC has cleaved open more than one fault line: cutting across ethnicity, language, religion. Over 40 lakh — Hindu and Muslim, young and old, rural and urban — find themselves among the uncounted.

To understand the fear and uncertainty that’s gripping an entire state in the wake of this exercise, The Indian Express tracked down those who slipped through the cracks — from a 72-year-old retired school teacher in Guwahati to a 25-year-old Bengali-speaking Muslim from Lakhimpur, from a 62-year-old MLA in Abhayapuri to a 26-year-old social worker from Tinsukia.

Subscriber Only Stories
Road to 2024: Modi, Shah, Nadda, all top hands on deck for poll pushPremium
India has a $1.2 trillion plan to snatch factories from ChinaPremium
UPSC Essentials: Key terms of the past week with MCQsPremium
Express Investigation: In groundwater near a Delhi landfill, heavy metals...Premium

Also read | Amit Shah draws NRC line: Security prime, all parties must clear stand on illegals

It found parents missing, sisters and brothers out, and children failing to finding a place in the draft. All they want now, they said, is to be counted.

‘Brother in, I am out’

Ananta Kumar Malo, 61; Abhayapuri. Wife, brother in but he is out.

Ananta Kumar Malo, 62, is a sitting MLA of the AIUDF from the SC-reserved Abhayapuri South constituency. He does not know why or how he was excluded from the draft. “My brother used the same legacy data of our father, and he is in the NRC draft but I am not. My wife is also in the NRC through her legacy. I think there must have been some minor problem. I am sure it will be corrected in the next round,” said Malo, a Bengali-speaking Hindu.

READ | Their names not on citizens’ register, 40,07,707 in Assam ask: What next?


‘2 children not in draft’

RAZIB AHMED, 6; Kamrup. His twin sister is in, he is out, (R) ROSE AHMED, 13; Kamrup. His parents, sister in, he and brother are out.

Sarbat Ali, 46, is a resident of Bhalukabari village of Kamrup district and teaches at a local school. Two of his three children, Rose Ahmed (13) and Razib Ahmed (6), did not find a mention in the NRC draft although he, his wife and Razib’s twin Sneha were in. “The two children do not understand anything but I am shocked. How can this happen? In one family, some are in the draft, some are not,” said Ali, a Bengali-speaking Muslim.

READ | Tarun Gogoi: ‘NRC our (Congress) baby… don’t try to make it Hindu or Muslim or Christian’

‘We will apply again’

GAUTAM PAL, 50; Guwahati. He and his brother are out

Gautam Pal, a 50-year-old vegetable vendor in Guwahati, did not find his name in the draft and is ready to pursue his case in the next round starting August 7. Pal, a Bengali-speaking Hindu, says his father migrated from East Pakistan to Cachar district during Partition and later shifted to Guwahati. “My father’s name is in the NRC prepared in the state in 1951. But my brother and I failed to qualify during the NRC verification this time because of a mistake in our father’s name in the data. We will apply again with the correct name after August 7,” Pal said.


READ | Mamata Banerjee: ‘With NRC they’re trying to divide people, there’ll be bloodbath and civil war in country’

‘Have records but not in NRC’

SATI PURAKAYASTHA, 72; Guwahati. Her entire family is in, she is out

Sati Purakayastha, 72, is a retired school teacher in Guwahati. She says she did not find her name in the draft although she has a 1964 matriculation certificate, a 1966 higher secondary certificate, and her name on voters’ lists in Guwahati since then. “Everyone in the family is there in the draft, except her. This is absurd,” said her son, a medical representative.

Express Explained | What it means to be out of NRC

‘Many trips to Assam now’

ESHANI CHOUDHURY, 26; Tinsukia, now in New Delhi. Mother in, she & her sister out

Eshani Choudhury, 26, is a social worker from Tinsukia now based in New Delhi. Her parents — a Bengali-Muslim father and a Bengali-Hindu mother — have separated. Choudhury’s mother and maternal grandmother are in the draft but she and her sister, who used the legacy data of her mother, are not. Her father and his ancestors are also in the draft. “For me, to travel back to Assam and fill the claims form and then participate in the subsequent processes might mean numerous trips by air from Delhi at short notice. I have certain financial constraints and this will add to that,” said Choudhury.

READ | As Rajya Sabha debates NRC, Opposition hits back, says citizens left out of final draft


‘This is absurd’

Masuma Begum, 25; Lakhimpur. Three siblings, parents are in, she is out.

Masuma Begum, 25, is a Bengali-speaking Muslim from Lakhimpur district who did her Masters in Assamese language and is currently pursuing a B. Ed under Gauhati University. Her name is not in the updated draft although those of her three younger siblings and parents are. Begum, a central committee leader of the All Assam Minority Students’ Union (AAMSU) and former assistant general secretary of the Cotton University union, says she is confused. “My siblings also drew their legacy from the same documents that I did — this is absurd,” she said.

READ | Assam NRC list: No person will be referred to Foreigners’ Tribunal or sent to detention centre based on final draft


‘Mistake in father’s name’

Tilak rizal, 41; Kamrup. He, his children out, his Karbi wife is in.

Tilak Prasad Rizal, 41, hails from Karbi Anglong. His two children did not find a mention in the NRC while his wife — of Karbi origin — has made it. Rizal said he has four brothers — all of them stay in Karbi Anglong — and that at least 22 persons from the extended family are not in the draft. Rizal, a political worker, says the reason for their exclusion is a mistake in their father’s name in the 1966 voters list, which they did not get corrected. “I will see what can be done after August 7,” Rizal said.

First published on: 01-08-2018 at 05:20:19 am
Next Story

Una Dalit flogging trial begins, first witness a doctor who treated victims

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments