December 16, 2013 2:14:09 am
Is this how you would treat your daughter,My Lord? The Additional Solicitor General asks as she shares what the law intern who has accused ex-SC judge A K Ganguly of sexual harassment told a court panel
Following the allegations of sexual harassment against a retired judge of the Supreme Court of India,the Attorney General filed a petition on the same day asking for an investigation into the matter. When the matter was mentioned at 2 pm,the Chief Justice announced that he had set up a committee in his administrative capacity,of three judges,two being incumbent chief justices and a woman judge,to investigate and give a report to the Chief Justice.
The intern gave her statement to the committee,provided the affidavits of witnesses to whom she spoke immediately after the incident,gave all the mobile phone numbers of witnesses and of Justice Ganguly,and stood by her statement. Justice Ganguly was also called and his statement was video recorded. Apart from denying the allegations,he said the new law of 2013 making sexual harassment an offence did not apply to him as the alleged incident was of 2012,forgetting that outraging the modesty of a woman was always an offence,a law under which K P S Gill was prosecuted successfully by Rupan Deol Bajaj.
The committee gave its report in which it concluded: We have carefully scrutinised the statement (written as well as oral) of the intern,the affidavits of her three witnesses and the statement of Mr Justice (Retd) A K Ganguly. It appears to the committee that in the evening on 24.12.2012,the intern had visited hotel Le Meridien where Mr Justice (Retd) A K Ganguly was staying to assist him in his work. This fact is not denied by Mr Justice (Retd) A K Ganguly. Further the committee is of the considered view that the statement of the intern,both written and oral,prima facie discloses an act of unwelcome behaviour (unwelcome verbal/ non-verbal conduct of sexual nature) by Mr Justice (Retd) A K Ganguly with her in the room in hotel Le Meridien on 24.12.2012 approximately between 8 pm and 10.30 pm.
When the judge was named as A K Ganguly,it was clear that the alleged offence occurred during his tenure as chairman of the West Bengal Human Rights Commission,a post he continues to occupy. Justice Ganguly decided to brazen it out he announced that he was shocked and shattered by the allegations,that the victim was like his child,and that she was in Delhi and she came on her own.
Justice Ganguly continues to hide behind the presumption of innocence and to get vocal support from powerful members of the judicial and legal fraternity since the details of the incident are not in the public domain. It is in these circumstances that I am compelled to make public the details of the incident as outlined in the victims sworn affidavit before the Supreme Court committee,which the three-judge committee found prime facie to be established.
I would like to ask Justice Ganguly if this is indeed how he would like his child to be treated?
Excerpts from the victimss affidavit are in quotes:
He offered her his bedroom to drink wine and relax
When I reached the suite,there were two other persons apart from the judge present there. I was told by the judge that the man was associated with the AIFF (All India Football Federation). The woman was a stenographer. The judge then informed me that the AIFF report had to be submitted the next morning,and asked me to stay at the hotel and work all night. I declined and told him that I had to finish the work quickly,and return to the PG accommodation.
However,he ignored my repeated protests and asked the AIFF man to enquire whether a room could be booked for me at the same hotel. The AIFF man said that this may not be possible,but upon the insistence of the judge,agreed to consult his superior on the matter. Thereafter,the AIFF man and the woman stenographer left the suite.
I told the judge that the internet was not working. I asked the judge whether I was at all needed as there was no internet connection,and hence I could not do any web-based research.
At this point,the judge apologised for spoiling my Christmas Eve,and asked me if it was customary in Christian families to drink wine during Christmas. I mumbled yes. He then took out a bottle of red wine,which he said was compliments of the hotel. He also said that since I had had a long day,I should go into his bedroom and relax while drinking some wine.
Is this how you would like your child to relax,My Lord?
He wanted her to share his room
I felt uneasy,unsettled and disturbed by this suggestion of the judge,and told him that all I wanted to do was to complete the work as soon as possible and return to my PG at the earliest. He,however,brought out a bottle of red wine and handed me a glass. Feeling awkward and unsure,I accepted. This kind of interaction with the judge had never taken place in Kolkata during the period that we worked as RAs (research assistants) with the judge for six months. By now,I was beginning to feel extremely uncomfortable and wanted to leave the place as soon as possible. The judge persisted in making small talk,but I concentrated on completing the typing. I also asked him to arrange transport for me to return to my PG as I wanted to leave at the earliest.
During this time,the judge was making some calls,asking for a room to be booked in the same hotel for me. Even as he was making these calls,I categorically refused to stay in a room in the hotel,and insisted that I needed to return to my PG accommodation.
I was startled by the arrangements the judge was seeking to make for me,although he had not mentioned any of this to me when he had called me up. I began to feel more and more tense. The judge kept ignoring my protests and then informed me that it may not be possible to have a separate room arranged for me,and asked me if I would stay in the same room with him to help him finish the report.
He consumed alcohol,insisted she do as well and persisted
I was shocked and taken aback by this suggestion,and I categorically informed him that it was highly inappropriate for him to make such a request. Sensing my agitation,he then said that he would make arrangements for transport to take me back. During this period,the judge had not only quickly consumed few glasses of wine,but had also taken out a bottle of Bacardi white rum and taken a few drinks of rum as well. I had,however,taken barely a few sips of the wine,although the judge was repeatedly asking me to finish my glass so that he could refill it. At this time,the judge again tried to persuade me to stay in his room,stating that he would not be able to finish compiling the report on his own,and he would guide me how to compile the same. Again,I declined.
Is this how you would expect your child to be treated by someone old enough to be her grandfather,My Lord?
He put his hand on her back and moved forward to embrace her
At approximately 10 pm,dinner,which had been ordered in the meanwhile by the judge,was served in the room… I moved from the round table where I was working,and seated myself on the long sofa… After I had sat down,the judge came and sat next to me on the same sofa. Both the judge and I started eating. During the dinner,the judge put his hand on my back and thanked me for agreeing to help him. I moved away,clearly indicating to the judge that this physical contact was unwelcome and not proper behaviour on his part.
However,the judge did not remove his hand from my back,and then moved forward to embrace me. I no longer felt safe and was extremely suspicious of his intentions.
I therefore immediately moved to the single sofa on my left to be out of his physical reach.
You know that I am attracted to you he kissed her hand and repeated that he loved her
Soon afterwards,I left my meal,returned to the round table and pretended to continue the work,while I anxiously waited for the car. By now I was feeling threatened. At this point,the judge approached me and,standing next to me,he put his hand on my head,and said,You are very beautiful. I immediately rose from my seat,but before I had a chance to respond to the statement,he caught hold of my arm,saying,You know that Im attracted to you,dont you? You must be thinking,what,this old man is getting drunk and saying such things. But I really like you,I love you. When I tried to move away,he kissed my arm and repeated that he loved me.
Is this not what Section 354 of the Indian Penal Code,introduced as far back as in 1860 is meant for,My Lord?
He followed her into the elevator,begged dont leave
I pushed him away stating that I had to leave immediately. By now it was crystal clear to me that the preceding events were not innocuous in nature,and that he was making unwelcome sexual advances. I quickly picked up my computer and bag,and left the room to take the elevator down. The judge followed me into the elevator,repeatedly saying,Please dont go,Did I make you uncomfortable?,Please dont leave me,I need your help right now,and said that the AIFF report needed to be finished. I did not answer the judge anymore. The judge had followed me to the reception. As no car was available,the judge called someone from his cellphone. Soon another man joined us,and I was informed that he was a senior member of the AIFF. The judge informed him that no transport seemed to have been arranged for me,and asked him to handle the matter. When the judge was standing alone with me in the reception,he again repeated his previous words,asking me not to leave and to help him finish the work. I did not respond to him.
I left the hotel at around 10.30 pm. After the car arrived,I returned in it to the PG where I was staying. After reaching the PG,I received a call from the judge asking if I had reached. I curtly said yes and disconnected the call immediately.
He apologised via text message the next morning
The next morning,I sent an SMS to the judge stating that given the incidents of the previous night,I felt that I could no longer continue to work under him. The message was sent at approximately 9 am,on 25th December 2012. Thereupon,the judge pestered me with innumerable calls through the morning. However,I did not answer any of his calls. The judge also sent me a text message apologising for the previous night,and requested that I converse with him for five minutes. I did not respond to this message,and the judge continued calling me several times. I did not answer any of his calls.
I have put forth the details indeed they have shocked and shattered most of us. And they have prima facie been established by three judges of the Supreme Court,two of whom are incumbent chief justices.
What have you got to say now,My Lord? Does this not call for your resignation from the post of Chair of the West Bengal Human Rights Commission. And if you still refuse to,am I not justified in asking the Prime Minister to request the President of India for your immediate removal from this post,My Lord?
📣 The Indian Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel (@indianexpress) and stay updated with the latest headlines
- The Indian Express website has been rated GREEN for its credibility and trustworthiness by Newsguard, a global service that rates news sources for their journalistic standards.