In March 2008,Bangalore-based S Shiva Kumar booked a flat in Gurgaon 21,a group housing project situated in India Next,a township being developed on NH-8 in Gurgaon by Vatika Group. While on an official visit to Delhi in August 2009,Kumar decided to visit the project site in Sector 82,Gurgaon,to check on its progress. To his astonishment,even the digging work that precedes the laying of the foundation had not begun. When he contacted the sales manager with whom he had been communicating for his booking,Kumar was informed that the site plan had changed and that the project had been shifted to Sector 83. So Kumar went to the new site to check the status of work. But there too no signs of development were visible. In fact,he had to spend the entire day searching for Vatikas project in that area. All he came across was farmland. Not a single billboard announcing Vatikas project could be found. A disheartened Kumar finally left for Bangalore. The question uppermost on his mind these days is when,if it all,will he see the apartment into which he has invested a large part of his lifes savings.
Amit Soni,another buyer in Vatikas India Next,says that when he visited the project site two weeks ago,he found no sign of the land having been acquired by the developer,as it still had standing crop. From what I saw,even the excavation work for the 15-storeyed apartment project is not likely to begin soon, he says.
BUYERS UNITE
Disgruntled with the developers conduct,hundreds of buyers have formed an online group on Yahoo called Gurgaon 21. In their last meeting held on September 1,2009,the group concluded that the developer was not treating this group housing society as a priority project. The group plans to stage a dharna at Vatikas headquarters in Gurgaon to persuade the developer to deliver the project fast or return the buyers hard-earned money. Already a few members have filed cases against Vatika in consumer courts. We also plan to take the help of government agencies. We hope the government agencies will pay attention to this issue and save thousands of people from losing their savings to this group. In the absence of a regulator for the real-estate sector,a builders are taking people for a ride, says Mittal.
According to a group member,two dharnas have already been staged in front of Vatikas head office to build pressure on the developer,but to no avail. Even after fighting for several months now,the developer is willing to neither return our hard-earned money nor address our concerns, says a member. He adds that Vatika had even tried to implement a divide-and-rule policy by trying to get several members of the group to break away.
On visiting the project site,this reporter found no evidence of construction activity on the project. Only four-five labourers were engaged in erecting the site office. It was also learnt that the developer has sub-contracted the construction work to one Tirath Ram Ahuja Builders. An engineer belonging to this builder said that completion of the project would at the very least take three years if begun in earnest now.
According to Pankaj Pal,companys executive director- corporate finance and sales,the company is ready to pay a compensation of Rs 10 per sq ft if it misses its deadline.
LITTLE HEADWAY
As for its India Next project in Gurgaon,an investigation by The Indian Express found that the developer has not even sought many of the mandatory approvals even though more than one year has passed since the launch of this housing project in March 2008. How come Vatika launched the project when required approvals were not in place? asks Kumar,who is highly perturbed as he believes that his investment of over Rs 20 lakh in the project is in jeopardy.
According to several aggrieved buyers,the most brazen act on the developers part has been to shift the project site without taking buyers consent or giving them the option to exit. The developer has communicated a tentative date of commencement of construction work: July 2009. Possession,according to the developer,is slated for March 2012,i.e.,four years after the date of booking,even though at the time of booking it was promised that the project would be delivered in two-and-a-half to three years, says Partha Pratim Bhuyan,an aggrieved buyer. He adds that there is no clarity on membership cancellation,and the buyer-seller agreement,which buyers were made to sign,is highly biased in the developers favour.
JAIPUR hanging fire
Similar reports about the developer have come in from other cities too. The group launched its township project,Infotech City, in Jaipur way back in 2006. Till date,however,the developer has not given possession of plots to buyers even though it has collected over 70 per cent of the cost of the land from many of the allottees. Priya Sarvaria,whose family has bought more than seven plots in the township project,says,We have been fighting for refund for a long time but nothing has come of it so far. It has been over three years since we bought our plots. As per the agreement,they should have refunded our money with interest two years ago. We also had a meeting with Gaurav Bhalla,one of the directors,but to no avail, she says .
An investigation by The Indian Express found that till date land for the project has not been sanctioned by the Jaipur Development Authority JDA. According to a JDA official,the developer has not acquired several of the required licences.
However,Pal says that the company had acquired all the required clearances and was in process of handing over the possession of plots in this project.
SHIFTING FOCUS
In 2008,the developer commenced the operation of one of its hospitality projects The Westin Sohna-Gurgaon Resort amp; Spa. The hotel comprises 97 guest rooms,residential villas,a meeting and convention centre,a health centre and a spa,three dining outlets,a clubhouse and an 18-hole professional golf course. According to Pal,the company has spent around Rs 250 crore from its own kitty and Rs 250 through debt raised via banks,on its various hospitality projects till now.
Some of the other hospitality projects of the group include The Westin,Jaipur,and The Westin,Bangalore. Out of these,The Westin,Gurgaon is slated to be launched by March 2010 and the Jaipur by May 2010.
A partner at an international real-estate consulting firm,who did not wish to be named,says,The group has utilised most of the funds it collected from its housing projects in the hotel project as it finds this to be a more lucrative business. Besides,the company wants to project itself more as a hospitality company.
However,Pal refutes this. He claims that the entire groups assets are worth Rs 5,000 crore. Its financial partners include Baer Capital,Goldman Sachs and Wachovia,which together have a private equity stake of 17 per cent in the group.
Bhalla says that after the completion of The Westin Gurgaon and The Westin Jaipur,the company was going to solely focus on the India Next project. He says that the company is in talk with various PE funds and is planning to raise around Rs 500 crore for its development. Till now,we have acquired 400 acres for the project and have received booking amount for homes worth Rs 1500 crore, he says .
Other than the commercial complexes and a few housing projects in Vatika City on Sohna Road,most housing projects by this developer have got delayed as the groups focus has shifted to its hospitality ventures. But this is causing misery to hundreds of buyers who are waiting for their apartments and plots to be delivered to them.