Tamil Nadu and Kerala are on collision course over the 110-year-old, British-built masonry dam on Mullaperiyar, leaving both M Karunanidhi and V S Achuthanandan rolling up their sleeves for some aggressive sabre-rattling today.
The issue is beginning to spill over to the streets, with angry mobs holding up traffic on the borders between the two states at many points. DMK workers and farmers in Coimbatore squatted on highways to Kerala. In Theni, traffic on the Cumbum-Kumuli highway to Kerala remained paralysed.
Kerala called up the three Services: the Air Force to work out emergency evacuation and the Army to do the rescue act if and when the dam bursts, and the Navy this morning to inspect the masonry dam’s safety under the water level.
The last had a furious Karunanidhi claiming today that the dam belongs to his state, while Achuthanandan flatly retorted it was Kerala’s own — and Tamil Nadu was only the lessee. Karunanidhi threatened to boycott the crucial 29 November meeting between him and the Kerala chief minister under Central aegis at New Delhi to sort things out, after Kerala got divers from the Navy, insisting it was “unlawful and provocative’’ on Kerala’s part to have done that, and would now “sow seeds of hatred’’ between the two neighbours.
His Kerala counterpart, however, retorted it didn’t matter at all for Kerala whether Karunanidhi attended or boycotted the talks, adding that nothing will make his state commiserate.
Karunanidhi shot off an angry missive to Prime minister Manmohan Singh, Water minister Saifuddin Soz and UPA chief Sonia Gandhi this afternoon, soon after the Naval divers reached Mullaperiyar. It urged the Centre to stop Kerala’s “unlawful activities,’’ adding that he would boycott the Centre-mediated talks in New Delhi, if Kerala “continued to indulge in such unfair and provocative actions’’.
Achuthanandan retorted that Karunanidhi may “hope to scare the Prime Minister, but he had better not try out his act on Kerala.’’ He said there was no question of Kerala budging, since the issue involved a direct threat to about 35 lakh of its people. “We would need to pick up their bodies from the Arabian Sea if that dam bursts,’’ an angry VS added. His Government, however, got the Navy divers off the dam by afternoon, after Soz requested VS to keep peace till the talks.
The dam is located in Kerala, but is on a 999-year lease to Tamil Nadu. While Kerala insists that the weak, old structure is a potential death sentence on people in its five districts, and wants its water level lowered, Tamil Nadu has been pushing for upping the level to help irrigate five of its parched districts using its waters for over a century now, besides generating some handy hydro-power with no formal agreement since 1959. It has been been holding up a February 2006 Supreme Court verdict that said it was ok to store up to 142 feet of water in the dam, and that Kerala’s apprehensions had no technical corroboration.
Though the Mullaperiyar issue had been simmering for over two decades now, things began sliding to a flashpoint during the last fortnight with the water level inching well over the 136-ft mark that Kerala wants kept, and Tamil Nadu shrugging off its neighbour’s apprehensions and demands.
With tempers and political rhetoric rising faster than the waters, the two states with vast populations that have their sharply different stakes in the issue have been trying to get one up on each other. A procession of Kerala politicians, ministers and officials have been looking up the dam and talked about the increasing threat, while Tamil Nadu did a similar act on the other side, accusing Kerala of scheming to deny it the water. Kerala kept claiming the river was its own, Tamil Nadu declared it was an inter-state one.
Kerala had a rare spectacle of its two fighting political fronts sinking their differences over the issue last week, and working out a consensus at an all-party meeting. The meeting decided to checkmate Tamil Nadu by building a new Rs 350-plus crore dam near the existing one, and draw up a fresh water sharing MoU with Tamil Nadu. That, however, has only served to provoke more protests from the other side.
The Mullaperiyar dam was built in 1895 on the Periyar, Kerala’s third largest river, mainly to irrigate the British-held Madras province’s rain-shadow areas. The then Maharaja of Travancore had inked a 999-year lease agreement with the then Madras government to hand it the dam and agree to divert part of the Periyar waters, which is still vital for farmers in the Madurai, Theni, Sivaganga, Dindigul and Ramanathapuram districts. The agreement was re-validated by Kerala in 1970 with few changes, but its first protests coincided with the increasing realisation that the water level maintained in the dam was not helping Kerala to generate much power from the Idukki hydro-electric power project downstream. When Tamil Nadu lowered it to 132 ft in the 1980s, some 8,000 hectares of its crops suffered, and it stridently refused to oblige afterwards.
For Kerala, the argument for lowering the dam’s water level has been meandering down the years through different routes. That includes many projections that say no masonry dam could safely outlive a sixty-year life span. Besides, a study by the Centre for Earth Science Studies that reported that the dam will not tolerate an earthquake of the magnitude of six on the Richter scale at higher water levels, if the epicentre is near the dam. Several earthquakes of lesser magnitudes have occurred in the state in the past.
But Tamil Nadu has equally compelling arguments to keep the water level up. Estimates are that the crop losses to Tamil Nadu from reducing the level between 1980 and 2005 is about Rs 40,000 crore. And without the Mullaperiyar waters, the huge and arid chunks of land in Theni, Madurai, Sivaganga and Ramanathapuram would not remain green.
It’s the height
8226; 110-yr-old Mullaperiyar dam is made of lime and brick, the only of its kind in the world
8226; TN wants storage level to be at least up to 142 ft and to 152 ft later, and has Supreme Court’s backing
8226; But Kerala wants the level to stay below 136 ft, fearing for the structure’s safety
8226; It has, since 1979, proposed construction of a new dam
8226; On Sept 29 this year, SC ruled that the dispute besettled through dialoguebetween the two CMs
